3 ms·
Say you have 2 credit cards: 1 from BoA with USD and one issued by a third party linked to your BTC account. You enter in a grocery store and you need to pay, w
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Say you have 2 credit cards: 1 from BoA with USD and one issued by a third party linked to your BTC account. You enter in a grocery store and you need to pay, which one you think most people choose? The rational choice is to use the USD because it's an inflationary currency, while BTC is not.
It doesn't matter. Say you want to maintain a portfolio of 90% bitcoins, 10% dollars. You have $100 USD and $900 worth of bitcoins. If you use the BoA card, you spend $50. Then you shift $45 from bitcoins to USD and maintain a 10/90 portfolio. If you use the Bitcoin card you instead shift $5 from dollars to bitcoins.
The only reason to choose one over the other is transaction costs. I.e., if it costs you $1 to make this transaction, and you expect a $50 USD deposit in the next month, you'll use USD to avoid the $1 transaction fee. If transaction costs are a % of the transaction size, you'll pay with the BTC card (and pay only x% of $5, rather than x% of $45).
Your post still doesn't explain why a deflationary currency will cause a person to stop consuming. Just as we could hypothesize a BTC backed credit card, we can also hypothesize an SPY backed credit card. The mechanics would basically be identical - at the point of transaction, the card company converts from the buyer's preferred asset to the seller's preferred asset. Both BTC and SPY backed credit cards already exist - it's equivalent to getting a regular USD credit card and selling BTC/SPY whenever you want to make a monthly payment (modulo a couple of extra clicks).
Incidentally, your post completely ignores the reason central banks manipulate currencies. The reason has nothing whatsoever due to the distinctions you make between currencies and assets (which, if I'm understanding correctly, is merely liquidity and the ability to pay taxes in them).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominal_rigidity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominal_rigidity
- atmosx 13y ago> Your post still doesn't explain why a deflationary currency will cause a person to stop consuming. I never said will stop consuming. It will consume less. It makes sense, a consumer will spend whatever has bigger Y% of having LESS value in X time, not more! Secondly: Have you tried buying/selling bitcoins? If you use a bank it's a pretty straight forward process but has huge costs. Thirdly: Do you buy products using bitcoin? Do you think that people uses bitcoin to buy products online? Because all the transactions I'm aware off are either illegal (hard to track) or perceive bitcoin as an asset. Central manipulate currencies in order to adjust the economy of a certain group, which is under their authority, as far as I know. The distinction I make between currencies and assets come from ~ 300 BC (at least, probably way back) and I don't understand why even is a topic of discussion. BitCoin is treated by 99% of it's users as an ASSET not as a CURRENCY. No one is buying services in Bitcoin, if does not want to hide. Isn't it weird that while Silk Road used BTC as it's main currency, Amazon, eBay, Apple and every other big player, doesn't even care? You think it's out of spike or anything? I'm not making any assumptions here, I'm stating facts. It's you who are suddenly re-writing 2000 years of economic history by assuming that buying with Gold (bitcoin) is the same as buying with FIAT.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI'm not arguing with your distinctions between currencies and assets. I don't care what label you choose to apply to BTC or SPY. I'm asking why a positive real rate of return on BTC will cause consumption to drop in a manner that a positive rate of return on Gold or SPY would not. I strongly suggest you go read an economics textbook that actually does the math. Working the models will help you avoid arguing with yourself about definitions (a pointless exercise even if you had a partner http://lesswrong.com/lw/np/disputing_definitions/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/np/disputing_definitions/ ).