8 ms·
Surface Music Kit features
- NicoJuicy 13y agoAdditional, the link to the app: http://apps.microsoft.com/windows/en-us/app/surface-music-kit/f08c6781-dec8-47e5-a845-1fad916163e2 http://apps.microsoft.com/windows/en-us/app/surface-music-ki... This app/hardware actually looks really neat..
- slantyyz 13y agoIt would be cool if applications like Amplitube supported it.
- julianpye 13y agoIt is not compatible to Surface RT tablets. I don't understand how Microsoft is willing to burn its early adopters so much. Surely it is not a technical matter or a matter of resources? If anything, Microsoft should do everything to keep all of them happy. Regarding the hardware itself - if you have ever tried out a Native Instruments Maschine, which this is kind of modeled on, you know that the haptics of the pad keys are key. This won't work well with the type of switch of the touchcover.
- salient 13y agoI don't understand why Microsoft even calls the two tablets the same, when they couldn't be any different from the software, hardware and price perspectives. The only explanation I can come up with is that they're trying to confuse the consume and think that one is just as good as the other (you can do the same things with both), and this title "Surface Music Kit", even though it's just for the Surface Pro device, proves my point.
- anonymfus 13y agoYou are confused. It's compatible with non-pro "Surface 2" (second generation Windows RT based device). It's incompatible with "Surface RT".
- jessaustin 13y agoEven the confusion seems to prove the point that Ms are confusing their customers.
- slantyyz 13y agoMy company just ordered some of the original Surface Pros on discount. The labelling on the boxes had us doing a double take, because we thought we received the ARM units by mistake. Surface Pro boxes just say Surface on them, so you actually have to look at the additional text to see that the OS is Windows 8 Pro or that the SSD is larger than the RT before you realize you go the right unit.
- gum_ina_package 13y agoHow is this any different than Apple only supporting nth Gen iDevices?
- sleepybrett 13y agoGenerally when Apple stops supporting some generation of devices it's 100% because of a hardware reason. Sometimes that hardware reason is processor bound (siri, and yes I know people have used siri on jailbroken 4's but the performance is adversly effected) and sometimes something else ( iBeacon and other Bluetooth LE technologies ). I generally don't like to give MS the benefit of the doubt, but in this case I know a lot of work went into the keyboard cover between the 1st gen (both pro and RT) and 2nd gen surface units. Is it possible that the connector has changed?
- Eyas 13y agoYes, Microsoft's keyboard connector changed between the Surface RT and Surface Pro to add additional pins for power. This is why Microsoft's latest Power Cover also doesn't work on the Surface RT but works on the rest. It is possible the Music Cover takes advantage of the additional pins.
- cmelbye 13y agoHow is that at all like this? Apple doesn't drop support for their devices after a year, plain and simple, and that's what Microsoft has done here. If there's a genuine "hardware limitation" that prevented them from giving support to their early adapters, then it's absurdly shocking to me that they didn't have the foresight to know that they might want to create covers like this in the future and add support for them preemptively.
- kenjackson 13y agoThey still support Surface RT. It's simply that they introduced effectively a new HW port on the new devices, which they haven't retrofitted on old devices. Apple has done the exact same thing on gen X to gen X+1 in the past. Everyone has.
- Eyas 13y agoAs I said in a separate comment below, I believe there is an actual hardware limitation here. According to two of the MSFT team's reddit AMA, the peripheral connector hardware did change (a few power pins were added).
- cmelbye 13y agoDid they seriously not have the foresight or product planning to know that they might want to create covers like this in the future? That's such a weak excuse. It's not like the Surface RT came out four years ago, it was the end of last year. They should've done everything they could to prevent themselves from leaving their early adopters behind, although I'm not surprised in the slightest that they did so. They did it to Windows Phone 7 users in the transition to Windows Phone 8, and they're doing it again now.
- pionar 13y agoSaying that everything people do needs to be backward-compatible is what leads to having to support IE 6. I'm sure you had the foresight a year ago to know that they'd want to attach different covers in the future, why didn't you tell them?
- cmelbye 13y agoI mean come on, I'm not expecting 12 years of backwards compatibility, I'm just saying that maybe one of their hardware engineers might have said: "Gee, is it possible that we might develop a new cover next year that needs power, for a backlight or something? We're under a time crunch now, so we probably won't have time to take advantage of it yet, but maybe we could add a couple pins for power to future proof it?" It's absurd to consider that an impossible foresight to make.
- anonymfus 13y agoThey still don't sell it, it's only for contest winners... Why?!
- NicoJuicy 13y agoIndeed, didn't knew about that... They reference the store, but the music kit can't be found there. PS. the site is http://www.surfaceremixproject.com/ http://www.surfaceremixproject.com/
- musicalentropy 13y agoIt would be great too if Microsoft develops something for real musicians to make some real music !
- actsasbuffoon 13y agoThe biggest reason that audio software/hardware manufacturers tend to ignore Windows is its latency problems. Latency is the amount of time it takes to send input to the system, or to get output from the system. Total latency is the combination of the two; how long it takes from the time I pluck a string until I hear the processed version play back through my headphones. High latency throws your timing off. It's a lot like when you speak into a microphone in an auditorium and the delay between when you speak and when you hear your voice is confusing. The two primary audio APIs available on Windows have very high latency, to the point where they make tracking with effects virtually unusable. You can increase your sample rate to improve the latency, but that is far more taxing on your CPU. OS X uses a system called Core Audio, and it has very respectable latency and is comparatively easy to develop for. We're at the point where a sort of self-sustaining feedback loop is well under way. Poor latency causes musicians to prefer OS X to Windows. Audio hardware manufacturers want to release products for platforms that people are actually using, so they target OS X. Now musicians who were on the fence about switching to a Mac have to in order to get access to decent recording equipment. I have an Apogee Duet that works on OS X and iOS(!), but it doesn't support Windows. The really weird thing is that I get better latency when recording through my iPad then I do when recording through my beefy gaming rig. tl;dr: Nifty controllers won't fix the problem. Microsoft needs to get serious about audio performance if they want musicians to use their platform.
- mullr 13y ago> audio software/hardware manufacturers tend to ignore Windows Really? Apogee is the only manufacturer in this market I can think of, out of many, that supports Apple products but not Windows. All latency-fearing Windows audio software and hardware uses ASIO, for which there is broad industry support. > Audio hardware manufacturers want to release products for platforms that people are actually using, so they target OS X. I think you perceive their motivations correctly, but most people would reach a different conclusion than you have. Anecdotal evidence suggests that said manufacturers have as well. > The really weird thing is that I get better latency when recording through my iPad then I do when recording through my beefy gaming rig. The latency of a digital audio system is determined by the amount of buffering in the signal path, but your computer must be able to keep those buffers reliably full. Your iPad, being a more controlled system with fewer background processes, should be able to do a much better job of this than your desktop box, where anything goes.
- xixixao 13y agoThis doesn't make sense... Why not use the touch screen as the controller, with variable number of sliders and track numbers and attach it to a PC/monitor for displaying the rest of the UI?
- sleepybrett 13y agoI imagine it might have to do with the actual surface of the 'keyboard' being embossed. It's very hard to use a tablet based UI to accomplish tasks like this because of the lack of physical controls. Oftentimes the operators attention is focused elsewhere and having to look down at a virtual set of controls is detrimental. I imagine not even this will help that much. Sometimes nothing beats an actual physical control panel.
- Gracana 13y agoBecause then you wouldn't need the surface's differentiating feature to use it.
- anonymfus 13y agoCapacitive touch screens are incapable of measuring pressure applied to buttons. This thing allows user to press buttons with different force to produce sounds of different volume.
- gress 13y agoFalse. Capacitive touch screens can measure finger pressure based on the size of the contact patch between the finger and the screen. They can also measure impact of the finger against the screen via the accelerometer.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- untilHellbanned 13y ago...and MSFT is 10 years behind once again. Garage Band has been around and highly successful for years. If only they'd done a Google, err...Bing search to know that.
- nivla 13y agoWow din't know Garage Band had a music kit for my Ipad. Where can I buy one? /s I believe OP intended to emphasize discussion on the hardware and not the software when posting this.
- thirdsight 13y agoHuh? Where did you get your crack pipe? Windows has made a reasonable DAW for at least 10-15 years. And hell I don't even use a PC. Some of us still use workstations (Korg: you rock).
- scep12 13y agoI think i'm missing the news-worthy part of this. Looks to me like a half-assed product that's stuck in limbo. What of it?
- Gracana 13y agoI couldn't tell from my quick skim through... So does anyone know, is it velocity sensitive?
- mdisraeli 13y agoThe pads appear to be sensitive to pressure, if I've read it right, which is a start
- mdisraeli 13y agoAs a DJ beginning to look into music production, this feels poorly designed to me. The sliders are without any physical control, so they add little over pure touchscreen sliders. And the fixed-functions are disappointing. Similarly the control buttons don't seem to add anything at all. The pads do make sense - having even slight physical definition to them will make them easier to use when performing. Really it needs piano keys, as again, the physicality they would have offered would have helped with performance. Another case, I suspect, of designed by someone who wouldn't actually use the final product.
- kenjackson 13y agoJoe Hahn has composed with it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oK6Hs-qHh84 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oK6Hs-qHh84 As an ex-DJ I could definitely find use in something like this. The core music program has to be good, but a complimentary keyboard like this one would certainly enhance the experience -- especially for live Performances.
- mdisraeli 13y agoOh, I could find uses for it, especially if it presents as a usb midi device[1]. And I'm sure it can be used for some fun things and actually have a place in a live set. It just feels like a toy, rather than a serious bit of music kit for musicians (even if it has been used by serious ones, however anything can be used by musicians :P) [1] Actually, if it did, that would get me a lot more excited by it!
- WalterSear 13y agoAs an electronic musician, it's totally a toy. No velocity sensitive anything, nothing but a mediocre imitation of a drumpad for input, and no inter compatibility with other devices. It is M$'s answer to the tenori-on.
- WalterSear 13y agoAs an electronic musician, it's totally a toy. No velocity sensitive anything, nothing but a mediocre imitation of a drumpad for input, and no inter compatibility with other devices. It is M$'s answer to the tenori-on.
- Casseres 13y agoFor those of you who are saying the Music Cover isn't a good device for making music, I don't think Microsoft was trying to make a music product, but rather an example. A while ago, some people from the Microsoft Surface team did an AMA (Ask Me Anything) on Reddit. I think the idea was that different "blades" could be made for different tasks [1]. Microsoft made the first blade to show what was possible, and this is what they came up with. [1] "This unique digitizer platform we built can enable a number of different blades and unique interactions. We are super excited about the possibility." - http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1mz20e/hi_im_panos_panay_corporate_vp_of_surface_at/ccdzk55 http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1mz20e/hi_im_panos_pan...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mdisraeli 13y agoAnyone know what the licensing restrictions on the surface keypadcovers is? Could anyone make a custom one?