30 ms·
Can you explain how exactly or why would anyone buy any items (that's what currencies are for after all) using a deflationary currency? Why would anyone ever c
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Can you explain how exactly or why would anyone buy any items (that's what currencies are for after all) using a deflationary currency?
Why would anyone ever cash out of any position with a positive rate of return?
By this logic everyone should stop consuming and put all their money into SPY, or similar market tracking indices. Yet they don't.
- saosebastiao 13y agoExactly. The traditional keynesian definition of rationality (wrt inflation/deflation) is so far removed from reality that it should be a joke by now. Nobody actually behaves the way their mental model says they should.
- gnaritas 13y agoExcept that's not what Keynseian's say, and people do behave the way Keynseian's say, deflation does curb spending and inflation does encourage it; Keynseian's don't claim people will stop spending, they claim they'll spend less.
- saosebastiao 13y agoNone of them seemed to act like that was their view when we were looking at 0% inflation. The general attitude of mainstream Keynesians was that we were on the verge of an unstopable downward spiral if we didn't act in that very moment...which I remind you was driven by housing prices crashing back down after their biggest bubble ever. In reality, people don't sense inflation or deflation as it is reported by the CPI, PPI, or any other price index. They sense it locally on a product by product basis. And it is still entirely uncertain as to the relative attribution of reduced income vs deflation as a cause of reduced spending.
- haberman 13y agoI think the better question is: why would anyone invest if simply holding currency is an investment? If you are an entrepreneur or a company going IPO, the you'd have to offer a better expected return than the currency itself. Your competition for investment dollars would be not only other companies, but cash.
- tptacek 13y agoBecause (1) people do not agree that SPY ETFs are a reliable way to earn a return, (2) the process of moving money in and out of ETFs is far from frictionless, and (3) once people move money into an investment vehicle, they are in fact hesitant to liquidate it simply to make purchases, in a way they are not with "currency".
- yummyfajitas 13y agoLook, the real problem with deflation is that it increases real interest rates and makes structural rigidities caused by sticky wages/prices more potent. If you want to argue against bitcoin on Keynesian grounds, start there. The only way deflation will reduce consumption is if the rate of deflation exceeds all other rates of return. Simple math: I consume if (value of consumption now) > exp(-(discount rate - rate of return) x time) x (value of consumption in future) The `rate of return` term is the rate of return on my best investment - this is affected by deflation primarily if the deflationary currency becomes or improves my best investment. If you plug in some example the numbers, you'll see that the effect this has on consumption is miniscule compared to the effect this has on the allocation of investment. That's because when choosing between investments both sides of the equation have the discount rate, and it cancels. Atmosx is appealing to newspaper column keynesianism (that vague "I dunno what AD is, but I want more of it" flavor), and doesn't really understand what he is talking about. Do a back of the envelope calculation and you'll see I'm right.
- onebaddude 13y ago>Why would anyone ever cash out of any position with a positive rate of return? The opportunity cost of doing so is predictable and calculable, and, really, needs only occur when there are better investments available. Inflation in a currency is a feature, not a bug.
- atmosx 13y agoNot sure what you're trying to say here, but looks to me that you're confusing currencies with assets/investments.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI don't see a relevant distinction between them for the purposes of this discussion. Can you explain what you believe the relevant difference is, and why it matters? (Express your model in maths as much as possible, for the purpose of clarity.)
- atmosx 13y agoCurrency[1]: Primarily a medium of exchange. Asset[2]: Anything that has value and can be converted to cash. For the purpose of this or any other discussion I've made this argument, the author of the comment/post clearly confuses the two above stated words or uses them interchangeably. Currencies, in modern economics, are control by central authorities (FED/EBC/etc) which control their performance and try to adjust them. In their optimal status, when the economy goes well currencies loose value (inflation) by 1-2%. This behavior enhances money exchange and induces a spending behavior which is viewed as good for the economy. You will buy a computer today because your money will not buy the same model/computer tomorrow. When you buy something, you fight unemployment, pay taxes to the state and so on. The computer you buy can be an asset though. The moment you buy it, starts loosing value. You won't go to the grocery store to exchange the computer for tomatoes. You will need a medium to do that, that medium is money (and that's exactly what BTC claims to be, but up until now it's not). The computer though except from an asset is also an investment. It can help you, generate value either in form of entertainment or money (programmers/designer/etc.) but it's still not money. Sure you can exchange it for something but that's not a straight-forward process as buying beers with a currency. The next question is: Why I should own a currency? Because the local authority (a government) impose you to use it's currency to pay taxes. Currencies are never adopted, they are always enforced to populations by supreme state governments, as means of exchange. There is no other for anyone wanting to own an inflationary currency, except for that fact that you can't do anything without it. Of course in my example, I take for granted that we're talking about a relatively healthy state. Otherwise, people will prefer a foreign, more stable (less inflationary, or deflationary if possible currency. Note that less inflationary means deflationary for them anyway). Now, BTC introduces a currency that has some characteristics. One of them is that it's finite[4]. So, deflation is chosen here by design. Say you have 2 credit cards: 1 from BoA with USD and one issued by a third party linked to your BTC account. You enter in a grocery store and you need to pay, which one you think most people choose? The rational choice is to use the USD because it's an inflationary currency, while BTC is not. Then, why Satoshi choose to add deflation in BTC: Because otherwise no-one would even care holding any. What kind of value an inflationary digital (non-backed) currency could ever have? None. Bitcoin is better viewed as Gold in digital form. Say you have 10.000.000.000 USD and you wanna convert that money into some asset. Would you chose a 5 year old asset or a 5.000 old year asset to do that? The rational (obvious) choice is gold. It's 5.000 old and pretty much stable, BTC as long as we know can turn to ~ 0 tomorrow if the big players choose to opt-out or USA/CN/EU/RU decide to ban it. Why is all this relevant for the purpose of this discussion: Because the commenter (Aqueous iirc) is talking about bitcoin as a currency and not an as an asset. NOTE: Currency is viewed as assets at FOREX[3] but I'm sure it's not relevant for the purpose of this discussion. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_market http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_market [4] 20,999,999.9769 BTC. - https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ#How_long_will_it_take_to_generate_all_the_coins.3F https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ#How_long_will_it_take_to_gene...