12 ms·
Good News You Might Have Missed in 2013
- paul_f 13y agoI am proud that the technology industry, of which I am a part, has created Bill Gates, a living saint.
- simias 13y agoMmmh, I'm trying really hard not to be contrarian for the sake of it but "a living saint" seems a little too strong an expression. I mean, of course what he does is awesome and I'll probably never be in a position to do anything remotely that significant in my life but I feel it's easier to do that kind of stuff when you're that insanely rich. That being said he could probably as easily not do it, so props to him for that. He seems like a good man, saint or not. Humans are rarely all black or all white, that's what makes us interesting.
- svenkatesh 13y agoBut, there are many wealthy people who do not give their time and money over to philanthropy. Conversely, there are many who are not wealthy who also do lots of charity work (could be something as small as volunteering in a soup kitchen on Christmas or Thanksgiving, helping out at the local hospital, spending time at a nursing or retirement home, etc.). I know many people who fall into this category.
- prawn 13y agoSo many saints are considered as much for far less than he's helping accomplish.
- tptacek 13y agoI don't think he's a saint. I think a lot of people on HN, given the same resources Gates has, would do substantially similar things with their lives. It seems like incredibly rewarding and important work. I'm just really glad he chose to do it.
- graycat 13y agoAnd what is the role of his wife and her schooling from nuns?
- tptacek 13y agoI don't know, but modern Catholic nuns are kind of bad-ass. For instance, the Ursulines who taught Melinda Gates recently gave a middle finger to the Catholic hierarchy and vocally defended Gates' work despite its support for contraception. Wherever you look for close-minded reactionary people stuck in the 1950s chastising members of their own church for unapproved good works, chances are you'll see nuns on the other side of the argument. I don't doubt that there are a whole lot of bad nuns out there (though just typing those words seems kind of silly to me), but in the modern organized faith they seem like one of the bright spots.
- judk 13y agoDo also note that the top of that hierarchy, the current Pope, is dragging the ethical values of the Catholic Church forward through the centuries, despite significant baggage he can't be expected to just discard (though he should if he could)
- tptacek 13y agoThe Jesuits are another bright spot in the Catholic church. I had four years of Jesuit high school, and everything people like us seem to like about Pope Frank plays right to the Jesuit type.
- graycat 13y agoI have been guessing that the nuns that taught Melinda got her highly devoted to 'charity' in some general sense and that she and Bill had a 'deal': After he worked his tail off at Microsoft to make a lot of money and, thus, necessarily spent a lot of time at the office instead of at home with her and the kids, he was to back off from an active role at Microsoft, e.g., be just COB, and, then, join with her in using much of the money for charity. So, in this way Melinda would get to pursue the goals and values of charity she got from her nuns. Just a guess. I could make this guess because my wife, her sisters, and their mother were all highly devoted to a life of charity via 'volunteer' work, and much of the origin of their interests in charity was from Christian religion, although in their case Methodist instead of Roman Catholic. But, 'deal' with Bill or not, the record seems to be that Melinda is one heck of a 'super fundraiser': She also got Buffett to hand over much or nearly all of his fortune. Then she publicized the value that any really wealthy person should leave 50% or so to charity. So, I'm guessing that the nuns got Melinda to get Bill and others to cough up $100 billion and counting. And what is Melinda's 'sales pitch?" My guess is just total sincerity with nothing for herself, no money, of course not, but neither fame, status, prestige, etc. It seems to me that in charity Melinda is fairly closely following the values of the nuns. And she did one more: As we know, just having the money and giving it away does not necessarily do much to 'alleviate human suffering' or 'improve the world' as the nuns might want. Instead, giving the money away in effective ways is hard work. So, Melinda got Bill dedicated to the work, and Bill is a bright guy who knows the heck how to get things done. I'm suspecting that heavily Melinda, and before her her nuns, are the real driving force behind all of this. Instead, Bill might be driving/racing Porsche cars! Finally, we have to suspect that 'hard hearted', no nonsense, bottom line oriented, take no prisoners Bill is totally taken with, in awe of, head over heels in love with, and has awesome respect for Melinda. But then some such fits: Supposedly Bill's mother was a big influence on Bill, and a boy with a good mother tends to look for a wife much like his mother. It's nice that tough guy Bill is now harnessed as a very bright and capable horse pulling the wagon of Melinda and her nuns!
- tn13 13y agoWell, I think Sainthood is given to those people who work out of their religious beliefs and are busy glorifying poverty and suffering (Example: Mother Teresa). Gates is a not a saint he is just a philanthropists and a good one at that.
- tptacek 13y agoIf Mother Teresa is the one modern venerated person you've heard of, I guess that would be a reasonable summary of the meaning of Catholic sainthood. I agree though with the underlying point, which is that "sainthood" is a political concept that isn't relevant to the work being done by the Gates Foundation.
- pizza234 13y agoI feel exaclty the opposite, of both the technology industry, and Bill gates. It's really easy to be charitable when you can't even count the money you have. In addition to that, it's also easy to invest your time in charity when you left a company you worked for, with exceptional intensity, for a life, and suddenly you have nothing to do anymore. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that Bill Gates is "evil". I'm saying that there is very little to admire in such behavior. Most of the people, with unlimited money and time, and having exhausted their stack of accomplishments, would do the same. Secondly, the root of the main problems around the world is not technological, but social in nature. And again, don't get me wrong, it's good to cure people, invent cleaning bacteria, cleaner energy etc.etc. If you don't work out the social root, it's going to be a whack-a-mole game.
- ArtDev 13y agoThe Gates Foundation is different than other charities: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_%26_Melinda_Gates_Foundation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_%26_Melinda_Gates_Foundati...
- greeneggs 13y ago"It's really easy to be charitable when you can't even count the money you have. In addition to that, it's also easy to invest your time in charity when you left a company you worked for, with exceptional intensity, for a life, and suddenly you have nothing to do anymore... Most of the people, with unlimited money and time, and having exhausted their stack of accomplishments, would do the same." Whether or not it is easy, not only don't most billionaires invest anywhere near as much money or time as Gates into charity, almost none of them do. Check out the Forbes list of 20 billionaires if you don't believe me [1]. A typical example: "At a then estimated $16.3 billion net worth, she contributed a total of $3.5 million cumulatively between 2002 and 2006." [2] [1] http://www.forbes.com/billionaires/list/ http://www.forbes.com/billionaires/list/ [2] http://www.facesofphilanthropy.com/christy-walton/ http://www.facesofphilanthropy.com/christy-walton/
- ccarter84 13y agoHe links to a pretty decent site too -- 'oooh shiny visualizations' http://www.healthmetricsandevaluation.org/gbd/visualizations/country http://www.healthmetricsandevaluation.org/gbd/visualizations...
- mateuszb 13y agoThings you might have missed in 2013: The Gates Foundation's Hypocritical Investments http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/12/gates-foundations-24-most-egregious-investments http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/12/gates-foundat...
- salient 13y agoSeems like the Gates Foundation is mostly a front for a profit-seeking venture.
- tptacek 13y agoYeah, Bill Gates has sure pulled the wool over all our eyes on this one.
- benched 13y agoPlease explain what sense it would make for a gargantuan liquid fund not to try to invest profitably?
- icegreentea 13y agoIf you read the tax return, you'll see that your statement is literally not true.
- jblow 13y agoIt is the other way around. If you are doing effective altruism, you want to make sure you have money coming in that you can be altruistic with. The bit about Walmart was especially badly done. If the author of this article thinks Walmart employees are poor on the same scale as the poor that the foundation targets, he really has no clue about world poverty. If the minimum standard of living throughout the world were equal to that of a typical Walmart employee, the world would be tremendously better off.
- rbanffy 13y agoSo, your argument is that it's right to make Walmart employees poor in order to maximize profits because they are not nearly as poor as the poorest people in the world? If there is something poor here, it's the excuse.
- Daishiman 13y agoI wish he were to post something similar regarding climate change and energy developments.
- dredmorbius 13y agoYep. That was a pretty conspicuous omission from his list. That and coordinated approaches to significant problems, whether at the national or international level. I'm seeing less rather than more success at both scopes.
- tptacek 13y agoI wish someone was working as hard on climate change as Gates is on preventable disease in the developing works. But I do not wish that Gates worked any less diligently on the problems he's chosen. Global poverty and disease in the developing world are, particularly in the way they stifle the potential of a huge fraction of the world's people, root causes of most of our other big problems.
- pizza234 13y ago"Global poverty and disease in the developing world are, particularly in the way they stifle the potential of a huge fraction of the world's people, root causes of most of our other big problems." No, they're definitely not the root causes. There's plenty of interest from the richer countries to keep poor countries in such condition, that is the root cause.
- tptacek 13y agoWaiting for the drone strikes to take out Bill Gates then.
- Nimi 13y agoIf you're interested mainly in at-a-glance summaries, this might fit: http://www.ipcc.ch/ http://www.ipcc.ch/
- robotys 13y ago
- dbalan 13y agoHealth activists in India, observers the states push for pentavalent vaccines with suspicion. They are more expensive and does not really provide the cost-to-benefit.Also, experts are divided on the fact that there are 18 deaths reported on which state has confirmed 3 being caused by the vaccine. EDIT: Context - gates pushes pentavalent vaccine being the exciting thing for next year. [1] http://www.downtoearth.org.in/content/centre-confirms-three-pentavalent-vaccine-deaths http://www.downtoearth.org.in/content/centre-confirms-three-... [2] http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Thiruvananthapuram/pentavalent-vaccine-caught-in-fresh-row/article5455511.ece http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Thiruvananthapuram/penta... [3] http://www.downtoearth.org.in/content/policy-draft-backs-new-expensive-vaccines http://www.downtoearth.org.in/content/policy-draft-backs-new...
- icegreentea 13y agoUgh, it's seriously hard to read those articles. The writing is just off enough a bit to make it super jarring to read. In summary: 2 million doses delivered, 3 doses per child, 18 reported deaths (of which two apparently were in child who didn't take the vaccine at all). Depending on the sources, the actual number of deaths caused by the vaccine is 3 or up to 16. This is ontop of a base infant mortality rate of 12 deaths per 1000 infants per year. Also controversy over the actual need to vaccine Hep B and Hib (the two additional vaccines added to the original 3-combo vaccine), over spending their resources on other vaccines.
- tn13 13y agoAs people in Tech industry we should be very proud of Bill Gates and what he has done with Microsoft and his charity work. A lot of people totally miss the point when they say "hey anybody could do all that if they have enough money". That is simply not true. Charity is not just about throwing money at poor, it is a far more difficult job than say building a company. Working for profit is simpler where clear regulations, contracts are in place and a government which has an interest in making businesses work. Charity is a different ball game, I remember I was in Pune-India when Bill Gates quietly flew there in his private jet sneaked into local red light area to meet the health workers and monitor the progress. No one knew about his visit, when media reached there his private security somehow managed to make him disappear. He had a review meeting with health workers and key government people, and then simply flew out. He does this in all the countries where no sane minded Billionaire would set a foot. Throwing money and feeling good is simple. Achieving results is very difficult. Pune's red light area has benefited immensely by his efforts. There are at least 3 NGOs who have successfully managed to reduce AIDs and help the children of prostitutes rehabilitate in better professions. Over last 10 years, the sex workers in this area have reduced. Bill Gates is actually very stingy when it comes to money. You cant simply setup a NGO in red light area and get funding from him. The whole process by which he chooses whom to help is the real USP of his work. That is something takes a lifetime to build and he has done it well.
- rattray 13y agoUSP = Unique Selling Proposition, for those who also didn't know.
- lisper 13y agoI would be a lot prouder of Bill if he hadn't made his money by breaking the law.
- jseliger 13y agoThat is simply not true. Charity is not just about throwing money at poor This is an important and underappreciated point. Ken Stern makes it in his book With Charity For All, which I wrote more about here: http://blog.seliger.com/2013/06/02/with-charity-for-all-ken-stern-book-discussion/ http://blog.seliger.com/2013/06/02/with-charity-for-all-ken-... . In essence, we spend a lot of money on various charitable efforts without knowing what those efforts are really doing. Foreign aid is probably the most interesting part. Since 1945, I've seen estimates that say the U.S. and Western Europe have donated in the neighborhood of $1 – $2 trillion (with a "t") dollars to various developing countries. It hasn't done much. Why not? That's a question that a host of books have attempted to answer (I recommend Dead Aid, The Bottom Billion, and Why Nations Fail to the curious). I don't think we'll ever get a complete answer but we should at least be asking the right questions. (Relevant observation: I'm a grant writing consultant for nonprofit and public agencies. I see a lot of stuff that makes me. . . very skeptical, let's say. . . of many aid efforts.)
- simbolit 13y agoIn slightly related news,nobody is talking about the UN Millenium Goals [1][2]anymore, which are due next year. And it doesn't need a prophet to predict that we will miss most, if not even all eight, of them[0]. [0]http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/pdf/report-2013/2013_progress_english.pdf http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/pdf/report-2013/2013_progr... [1] http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/ http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/ [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Development_Goals http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Development_Goals
- matthewmacleod 13y agoI don't really get the canonisation. I'm very happy the the Gates' foundation is doing good work. You'd be a fool to say that it wasn't. However, I don't believe that the tech industry should be proud as a result, nor do I think that there is a particular difference between the foundation and some other charities, nor do I understand the obvious astroturfing. I especially don't think that the act of charity somehow excuses the dodgy business practices or Microsoft or the long-term damage done to the tech industry. So we should be grateful that the Gates' money is being used to positive ends. But that certainly doesn't make Bill a saint, and I suspect that this hyperbole and short-term memory-ism can fuel the backlash.
- ArtDev 13y agoThe Gates Foundation is unlike any other charity or foundation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_%26_Melinda_Gates_Foundation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_%26_Melinda_Gates_Foundati...
- matthewmacleod 13y agoThat's a link to the Wikipedia article about the foundation, which I'm pretty familiar with. You haven't really provided any evidence that the Foundation is significantly different. It's large, but in what manner is that qualitatively different and better?
- rbanffy 13y agoWhich is not entirely bad: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_%26_Melinda_Gates_Foundation#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_%26_Melinda_Gates_Foundat...
- Houshalter 13y ago>I especially don't think that the act of charity somehow excuses the dodgy business practices or Microsoft or the long-term damage done to the tech industry. How much damage do you think that is? You don't think all the lives saved have "made up" for that? You don't think the world is better off than it would otherwise be without Bill Gates?
- stesch 13y agoHow to Become As Rich As Bill Gates: http://philip.greenspun.com/bg/ http://philip.greenspun.com/bg/
- rbanffy 13y agoSaint William of Redmond?
- suprgeek 13y agoBillG is one of the very few people about whom I have completely changed my opinion. Post his Microsoft days, he is the highest profile "rich tech person" who has promoted so many projects and efforts to help the poor. While Microsoft was famous for “embrace, extend—and extinguish” where it crushed any product that felt like a threat (saw this first hand with Netscape). Now BillG is using his enormous wealth in the best possible way! Kudos and Thanks
- dennisgorelik 13y agoI have different view on that. The charity Bill Gates is doing now is good, but what Bill Gates did as Microsoft founder was much better and way more important. Lots of people are still using Microsoft products.
- berntb 13y ago>>Lots of people are still using Microsoft products [which are really good/important]. And lots of people are using Kalashnikovs e.g. the LRA, so they must be good? Please don't just write simple opinions like that on HN. Let me take a simple counter example: Microsoft had(/have?) a monopolist strategy. This meant they needed to have software/api/data formats hard to clone and be compatible with. this means they had to be over complex and varied in incompatible ways over time (then replaced regularly with new over complex implementations). That results in lower life quality for me and everyone else that had to use their stuff. The lack of better implementations, because of the monopoly, was a waste of money, blood pressure and time for at least tens of millions of people. I do agree about the charity, as a philantropist Gates has a serious attitude with setting goals and trying to reach them. Afaik, that made an incredible difference compared to e.g. the foreign aid of my country Sweden, set at 1% of GNP.
- aestra 13y ago>Lots of people are still using Microsoft products. Huuuuuh? What? What does that have to do with ANYTHING? Lots of people still use Bayer aspirin but that doesn't make their actions during WWII ok. They used slave labor and manufactured gas used in Nazi gas chambers and their executive Fritz ter Meer, sentenced to seven years in prison for his actions. They also invented heroin as a "non-addictive morphine substitute."
- amalag 13y agoI would be more interested in they can work for self sufficiency. They seem to be more interested in bringing big business to every corner of the world then making corners of the world self sufficient. Instead they want to push GMOs along with the purchase of those seeds.
- techtivist 13y agoIt's a little unfortunate that rather than discussing the contents of the piece we are focusing on the individual But I would like to comment on the substance because that is the link that was shared; and avoid all the on and on conflicts about the author of the piece. I hate to be that guy, but while I appreciate the optimistic note (no pun intended), I think we really should introspect on how 2013 was actually a year of setbacks in fight against poverty and other related social problems including the ones listed by BillG, which I want to point out. I am writing on the basis of my knowledge (which I can assure you is credible) and will append references later. 1.Polio: While there are some obvious achievements, the question of Pakistan is one country that has taken long backward steps since being close to eradicating it just before 9/11, and most of that has to do with geopolitical reasons. Post 9/11 the insurgent groups started targeting polio workers and banning immunization programs alleging that they were American spies. Because none of these were allegations were substantiated, the village elders fought against their voices, and the immunization program continued with the insurgents not being able to do much. However that changed with the Laden killing which in a way vindicated the insurgents as the chief informant was a doctor affiliated with the polio program. Since then the elders lost their ability to object, and the insurgents gained their authority which has resulted in completely dismantling of the polio program with periodic killings of polio workers, the last one less than a week back. The number of polio cases in Pakistan has grown about 40-50% since then. And one would argue there's a lot that the west can do to regain confidence for the local workers without jeopardizing the so-called continuing war on terror. This is a contentious issue, but ones that needs to be highlighted and not as simple as the Pak PM giving assurance to Gates. 2. Child mortality: Sure child mortality has gone down but it is far from the target set in the Millennium Development Goals (UN MDGs). More importantly its not just the poorer countries that are doing badly. Amongst the worst performing countries has been India which goes on to my next point that economic growth or the rate of poverty going down means nothing more than in numbers to the state of social welfare. The overall child mortality has gone down because of two separate factors: 1. Countries in latin america and south east Asia have improved drastically through better "socialistic" maternal and child welfare programs while the rest amongst the poorer countries languish. 2. The civil wars that plagued sub saharan countries before the 2000s have gone down both in their occurrences and their casualties, of which women and children formed a huge number. Sure you hear about the current violence in the likes of South Sudan, Mali, Syria and CAR but these are nothing compared to the violence of the past and the civilian casualties are much lower in number. 3. Poverty rate: From the point above while in absolute terms poverty has gone down, social inequality has grow. More importantly the measure of poverty line is highly debated as growth in income in low and middle income counties has also seen concurrent high real inflation on the ground which is highly under measured. 4. Rich counties re-committed to saving lives: This is actually perhaps the most concerning. Just read this piece by Jeffrey Sachs, one of the world's most well known development economist who was is a key advocate of the Global Fund that Gates mentions that http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-sachs/world-to-poor-drop-dead_b_4385420.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-sachs/world-to-poor-dr... Sorry if this sounds like a long rant. But I really strongly believe that we need to be realistic of what has been achieved. I appreciate what Gates is trying to do, but we need to introspect on how little we are doing to address these grave issues. And discussing the man and not the article itself is one of those key symptoms of our indifference and lethargy.
- braydenm 13y agoIf others in the tech industry are keen to contribute to having as big an impact on the world as Bill has, I encourage you to check out the Effective Altruism movement in your area. Effective Altruism overlaps with lean approaches and evidence based action, and many of the proponents are big names in the Valley: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism
- sidcool 13y agoI love you, Bill. I will do everything in my ability to get all help to your foundation, financially or otherwise. Thanks for your enormous contribution to the world. Here's hoping you get a Nobel peace prize.
- kayoone 13y agoA lot of people here hate on BG for his past and at the same time idolize Steve Jobs. If you would just have swapped MS and Apple in terms of market growth i am not so sure if Jobs wouldn't have made as many questionable decisions as Gates. Apple of today is making lives harder for a lot of companies, arguably more than MS of today. Also MS seems to share a lot more (Open Source, Public research) while Apple seems to be 100% self-centered. That of course makes sense for any competitive company, just saying that when one reaches the top, they always look kind of evil while the underdogs seem more sympathetic.