7 ms·
In a Car-Culture Clash, It’s the Los Angeles Police vs. Pedestrians
- bwanab 13y agoI'm not even sure this is news. In 1990, on my first business trip to LA from NYC, my contact there - a transplanted New Yorker, warned me that jay walking wasn't tolerated in LA.
- ballard 13y agoNWA said it best: "Fuck the police." But look at the date... End-of-the-month quota-filling dragnet likely.
- slurry 13y agoYou're getting downvoted for the first line, but the second line is the most insightful comment so far.
- talmand 13y agoNo, it's worse than that, far worse. In hard times a city with a failing budget does many things to generate revenue. One of the easiest sources of revenue for a city is a series of laws that imply fines on people for actions that at the time is considered normal behavior. Often the reason given is for "public safety" or for "public goodwill" or other similar notions. New taxes is popular too, but if you live in a city that has legal issues with creating new taxes they suddenly institute new "fees". As more cities drown in their budgets you can expect more of this behavior from some cities. Not all of them will go down this road, but many will. You can expect, and we've already seen much of this, new ideas of generating revenue such as fines, fees, and/or taxes. All at the expense of the people that these revenues are supposed to somehow help.
- walshemj 13y agoThis the problem when you let local government have to many powers and set their own laws.
- talmand 13y agoNot just local, but all governments. All governments over time build themselves up to a point that it can no longer be supported by society, nor itself, so that it eventually collapses. Then the people pick up the pieces, vow to never let that happen again for the sake of future generations, and then they go about doing it all over again.
- Moto7451 13y agoNot sure if this really paints the most accurate picture. For one, LA has plenty of unmarked crosswalks that are completely legal to cross. When I worked in Downtown LA I never had a problem with this. Secondly the LAPD regularly does the reverse of this crackdown and has plain cloths officers cross said crosswalks in order to catch motorists who aren't paying attention/don't care. I live in Hollywood and every few months I see a jay walking/unmarked crosswalk related accident. When you have distracted motorists in a busy area it's going to happen. When it gets really busy the LAPD cracks down on both sides and erects barriers to keep people on the sidewalk. Seems to work well here but probably is too manpower intensive for downtown.
- jrockway 13y agoWould love to see the NYPD do this. People make absolutely bone-headed decisions as to when and where to cross the street and get killed every year. My favorite is when people block traffic to cross one way, then the light changes, and they do the same thing to cross the other way. If they had just crossed the two streets in the opposite order, they would have done both crossings with the right of way. Stupid, stupid idiots. I also enjoy it when people jump out from between parked cars right into the bike lane. It must be nice to have a destination that would be out of the way if you went to the fucking corner to cross the street.
- jrockway 13y agoI should also point out that I'd like to see this, after we increase car ticketing a thousandfold. Every day, I see cars running red lights, people driving 50 in a 20 zone, cars illegally triple-parked, completely blocking ambulances, and so on. The reason so many people die in traffic in New York is because the NYPD does not enforce any traffic laws, and the laws have no bite anyway. Did you know that if you don't have a driver's license and you kill a little kid on the way to school, the maximum penalty is a $500 fine and 30 days in jail [1]? If you ever want to murder anyone, the message is clear: do it in New York, with your car. [1] http://www.streetsblog.org/2013/12/20/unlicensed-truck-driver-kills-noshat-nahian-8-in-northern-blvd-crosswalk/ http://www.streetsblog.org/2013/12/20/unlicensed-truck-drive...
- code_duck 13y agoI would love to see traffic enforcement increase - as Lon as it is fairly and evenly distributed and not tied to illegal substance possession enforcement.
- placeybordeaux 13y agoI live in Atlanta and people jay walk, aggressivily every day. I have never seen either anyone get arrested or an accident result from jay walking. I hope the LAPD move onto something more reasonable.
- w0rd-driven 13y agoI live in the suburbs of Atlanta and it's pretty much all over here. I have a problem with noticing it primarily because I don't bother doing it, I can wait those few extra seconds or minutes to be safe. I think the main reason it's annoying is people often do it knowing cars are coming at full speed, with no real regard for their safety or the safety of others. Jaywalking to me is a privilege when used correctly and I'm all for not fining the hell out of people. It's when they become a douchebag, seemingly trying to win some sort of lawsuit lottery with their arrogance that really rubs me the wrong way. You more often die from an automobile striking you than them slowing down just enough for it to be a "love tap" you can take to the bank anyway.
- sologoub 13y agoSome of the details are a bit sketchy, buy $197 for jaywalking really caught my eye. Got a parking ticket a couple if months back... $128. Seems like these more than doubled in last few years. Inflation anyone?
- ztrerwtr56 13y agoHe crossed a red light, that seems fair to me( Europe has similar "prices" ). A car doing that would get at least 2x times that plus points depending on the country.
- ssprang 13y agoHe was ticketed for starting during the flashing "Don't Walk" signal. That seems more like a yellow light to me. In other words, there's still plenty of time to cross if you're a fast walker. Don't walk too fast though, you might get a speeding ticket.
- ztrerwtr56 13y agoFlashing green light for cars means stop if you are safely able to( again laws in Europe ). Not sure for pedestrians but by logic this applies to them as well. Logically a flashing don't walk signal to someone who hasn't started walking over the crossing means Stop. What else could it mean?? Run over the road or cross as fast as possible. Definitely not as that would increase accident probability. http://www.walkinginfo.org/faqs/answer.cfm?id=16 http://www.walkinginfo.org/faqs/answer.cfm?id=16
- ssprang 13y agoThere's often a countdown timer as mentioned in the article. You know exactly how much time you have until it's a solid "Don't Walk". Usually, I will pass several people already in the crosswalk at my normal walking speed.
- swombat 13y agoWhen pedestrians have accidents they get a bit flustered and apologise. When cars have accidents people die. It's not that unreasonable to have a different law for cars than for pedestrians.
- nlh 13y agoIt's remarkable how different cities have such radically different approaches and attitudes toward pedestrians. More so how drivers - on the whole - have this almost ESP-like ability to share a common like or dislike. One of the most (pleasantly) jarring things I noticed about my move from NYC to SF is how totally dominant pedestrians are in SF, how totally deferential drivers are to pedestrians, and frankly how polite drivers are to each other. SF is filled with 4-way stop signs, and there's a very efficient (unspoken) system of coordinating who goes when (based on arrival time at the stop sign). If you dare break the system, you get yelled (honked) at mercilessly. As a pedestrian in SF, I sometimes have to insist that cars go ahead (I'm rarely in a rush when I'm walking, and I know how frustrating it can be as a driver to wait for a slow person to meander across the street). You need to do nothing more than approach a crosswalk and every car in every direction will stop and wait for you to cross -- people even insist that you cross and will stop their cars while in mid-turn. I find that sometimes ill have to actually walk away from the curb if I'm waiting for someone or not actually crossing yet, otherwise I impede traffic. It's pretty cool. I spent a weekend in New Orleans recently, and one of the first things I noticed was the complete lack of that pedestrian deference. Step in the street at a crosswalk and cars will rush to get through before you start crossing. I guess that's what they mean when they say "Live in Northern California, but leave before you get soft" ;)
- PeterWhittaker 13y ago> a very efficient (unspoken) system of coordinating who goes when > approach a crosswalk and every car in every direction will stop and wait for you to cross I confess to being baffled by these quotes: Are these not the law? In every province in which I've lived, the rules for stop signs are simple: First in, first out. In case of multiple simultaneous arrivals, vehicle on the right has right of way. Only pathological case is a multi-road intersection with perfectly equal spacing between roads, e.g., four-way intersection of two perpendicular roads - the drivers have to sort something out, but it's such a rare case it's not worth solving. That regulation works just as well for large intersections when then the lights are out: As you arrive, take note of who else is already there - you have right of way when they are all gone, everyone else has to wait for you. That regulation is observed in Ontario, NB, NS, PEI, and, to a lesser or greater extent, Quebec (highway regs are provincial, but we're pretty consistent on many sensible points). Likewise, pedestrians have absolute right of way wherever they are permitted to be. That is less observed, especially in bigger cities in Ontario and especially in Quebec, but is strictly observed in the Maritimes: Popup from between parked cars in Wolfville - or even Saint John, on many streets - and traffic halts for you.
- thrillgore 13y agoThis screams of quota fulfillment.
- elwell 13y agoWhen I lived in philly, I jay-walked all the time. Now I live in LA, the streets are usually wider and the cars tend to drive faster so I very rarely jay-walk.
- pg 13y agoApologies for looking at everything through startup-colored glasses, but my first thought on reading this was that LA is going to have a hard time becoming a startup hub with attitudes like this. The hackers and designers that startups want to hire seem to be disproportionately likely to want to travel on foot or by bike. So they like to live in cities where you can do that, and dislike car-centric cities. There is a bigger trend here though. As several recent studies have shown, people in their 20s are turning against cars. So a city that favors cars at the expense of pedestrians and bicycles is also one that favors the old at the expense of the young.
- mjn 13y agoDo you guess that's also the driver behind startups gravitating more lately towards walk/transit-oriented SF and Oakland, and away from the car-centric Valley? Or is something else at work there?
- toomuchtodo 13y agoShould every city gravitate towards catering to startup culture? Will we witness large major metro areas trying to move swiftly with regards to policy decisions, attempting to outdo each other? Interesting times.
- 9999 13y agoLos Angeles consists of a lot of cities within cities. The downtown core is actually remarkably accomodating for pedestrians, train riders, and bike riders with the exception of this stupid and wrongheaded new enforcement policy. It's funny that Eric Garcetti and many other LA boosters keep trying to create the "Silicon Beach" when downtown, Koreatown, and Culver City all have far superior environments for startups when you consider cost of living, cost of office space, public transit and walkability. Santa Monica, Manhattan Beach, El Segundo and Venice are horrible in comparison.
- fudgekludge 13y agoWeather, weather, weather. The "silicon beach" is 10 to 15 degrees cooler than downtown on a summer day with noticeably less smog. For many the west side is where its at,
- replicatorblog 13y agoI think the framing of this is a little off—from what I understand from friends living in LA, ridiculous ticketing is endemic, for minor traffic infractions to jaywalking. Their perception is that large swaths of the police force are basically being repurposed as tax collectors. It makes sense, it generates a ton of revenue and isn't subject to many of the traditional political procedures. I'd be curious if any LA locals agree or disagree with that assessment?
- 9999 13y agoI'm an LA local, and from my own anecdotal experiences and those of my friends, I partially agree with your assessment. There was a a period about 8 years ago when the LAPD and CHP waged an aggressive campaign against automobile drivers that failed to yield the right of way to pedestrians (including jaywalkers). Going after pedestrians (that are actually using crossswalks, but are just entering them after the don't walk countdown starts), seems like a shift in policy against pedestrians. The greater threat by far to life and well-being for citizens here are drivers that don't yield to pedestrians. Of course, pursuing that sort of policy would be to the benefit of the majority of Los Angelusians, and the LAPD's general purpose is not to do anything of the kind.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoNo, this is not at all my experience in Los Angeles, and certainly not with LAPD. I've gotten tickets here, but one was on the freeway from CHP, and the other was in Burbank (which is a different city and police department). In Burbank the officer was explicitly waiting for someone to do what I did, which kind of annoyed me. But in Los Angeles itself, LAPD has left me completely alone. I joke that unless you're actively stabbing someone in front of them, they have better things to do. Parking is another matter. There's a parking enforcement department, and they are quite aggressive, 24 hours a day.
- mixmastamyk 13y agoFor those of us not prone to drug sales, extortion, murder, etc... traffic and parking are our only interaction with local PD. So in most cases it sounds like you are actually in agreement despite the comment above. Most of us have very little interaction with LAPD, since they maintain low numbers of officers for a city its size. But when it comes from extracting $$$ from citizens they are a well-oiled machine. You can expect a parking ticket within 15 minutes anywhere in the city. Santa Monica (a different city) is even more aggressive.
- Fizzadar 13y agoAs a Brit living in London the whole idea of 'jaywalking' is hilarious. It's totally ridiculous to force pedestrians to always use lights & pelican crossings. Assuming everyone has a bit of common sense (don't walk in front of a moving car) I can think of absolutely no reason why these ridiculous laws even exist. A huge number of hours are saved in London every day by everyone not having to wait for a green man. And a $197 fine?! WTF? Glad I'm not living in LA, I could rack up thousands of dollars in a few hours if walking as one does in London.
- walshemj 13y agoYes we dont have jaywalking laws in the UK and the world hasn't ended - maybe the LA cops need to concentrate on more serious crimes or maybe there are to many cops?
- justincormack 13y agoThere were mass protests on Western Avenue in London when the first footbridge was built over a road, forcing pedestrians off the roads. The car still won. http://www.flickr.com/photos/26245280@N00/256217251/in/photolist-oDbsP-oE2HY-oMxV1 http://www.flickr.com/photos/26245280@N00/256217251/in/photo...
- pwg 13y ago> Assuming everyone has a bit of common sense (don't walk in front of a moving car) And therein lies the problem. There is a subset of American pedestrians who, because the law says they have the right of way, believe that the laws of physics also do not apply to them either. I have personally witnessed, too many times to count, a pedestrian approaching a crosswalk across a busy, four lane road, who continues, fast paced, without slowing the slightest, towards, into, and across, the crosswalk, without so much as even a glance left or right to check where the oncoming traffic happens to be. I.e., they just step out in front of cars (4 lanes worth) moving 35MPH, with no regard for how much distance there is between a cars hood and their spot in the crosswalk. The only thing that saves them from getting killed is the random positioning of cars such that they don't actually step in front of a car with only 20 feet left before impact, and the fact that the drivers with 100 feet of space left nearly skid to a stop because of the fool that forget what his/her mother taught them: "Always look both ways before crossing the street". Sadly, this total lack of common sense seems to infest about 20% of the pedestrian population, and is a major factor contributing to the accident rate. Because quite simply, if you are not in front of a moving car, you can't possibly be hit.
- bradleyjg 13y agoIn some of the most popular squares / blocks there shouldn't even be car traffic during popular hours. It makes no sense to reserve 80% of the commons 60% of the time for hugely inefficient users of the space. Take Times Square, why should thousands of pedestrians have to wait extra time to cross, or even just have less breathing room to stand around, so that cars with one to four people in them can have a more direct route to wherever they are going? Let them go around.
- culturestate 13y agoThis is the case in some parts of Hong Kong, and it works beautifully — it's actually part of an active campaign on the part of the HK government to increase HK's pedestrian accessibility[1]. Interestingly, even here in one of the most densely-packed cities on earth where 95% of the population uses public transportation on a daily basis, pedestrians are only now being thought of as more than second-class citizens. 1. http://www.td.gov.hk/en/transport_in_hong_kong/pedestrianisation/pedestrianisation/ http://www.td.gov.hk/en/transport_in_hong_kong/pedestrianisa...
- pkulak 13y agohttp://paleofuture.gizmodo.com/the-invention-of-jaywalking-was-a-massive-shaming-campa-858926923 http://paleofuture.gizmodo.com/the-invention-of-jaywalking-w...
- revelation 13y agoWe need to desperately change perceptions for traffic. Cars are the recurring factor in all crashes, and they can't be even near pedestrians. If that means they can't clog up the city center, then thats what we have to do. Just look at this statistic from NY for 2012: http://www.streetsblog.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/dmv1.jpg http://www.streetsblog.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/dmv1.j... 135 pedestrians killed. These are not people that suddenly collapsed and died, they died from intersections in the space-time continuum with cars. And nobody is being charged for these crashes, if you are not drunk or flee the scene, you can kill people with impunity (jumping the curb included). I highly recommend reading through http://www.streetsblog.org http://www.streetsblog.org for a few pages. Or try this article, it's a good summary of all that is wrong: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/01/nyregion/traffic-agent-fatally-struck-in-manhattan.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/01/nyregion/traffic-agent-fat...
- moocowduckquack 13y agoReminds me of the elderly UK historian who managed to get himself locked up for jaywalking in Atlanta. "First, I learnt that the Atlanta police are barbaric, brutal, and out of control. The violence I experienced was the worst of my sheltered life. Muggers who attacked me once near my home in Oxford were considerably more gentle with me than the Atlanta cops." http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/commentators/felipe-fernandezarmesto-the-accidental-criminal-431881.html http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/commentators/felipe-fern...
- atacrawl 13y agoRevenue generation masquerading as public safety.
- steamer25 13y agoI'm a card-carrying member of the National Motorists Association so I totally get the idea of maintaining a free-flowing thoroughfare but this seems ridiculous. The law should be amended thusly: - if (person.isCrossingWithoutSignal) officer.cite(person, fine=$197.00); + if (person.isCrossingWithoutSignal && nearbyTraffic.isImpededBy(person)) officer.cite(person, fine=$30.00);
- jack-r-abbit 13y ago"People upset that previously unenforced rules find renewed enforcement... news at 11" I get that a fine of $200 for starting to cross on a flashing "Don't Walk" is a bit excessive. But people should not be surprised by a ticket for jaywalking. They are only surprised because it turns out that "everyone does it" isn't really a good defense. I do it. By myself and with groups also doing it. Never got a ticket. But if I did get a ticket, it would totally be justified.