27 ms·
Interesting post, probably true enough, but I don't think testing is the major problem. The law itself was rushed through, to the point that the President and
by a3n 13y ago
Interesting post, probably true enough, but I don't think testing is the major problem.
The law itself was rushed through, to the point that the President and members who voted either way didn't really know what was in it. It was huge, and rushed because they had to beat the clock of the potential coming of a hostile Republican House. Even champions of the bill in Congress admitted that it would take years to fully understand what the bill does. The mind reels.
The law has many hostile stakeholders, and many turf grabbers, and the real requirements were not managed by a single entity who wanted to get it done the best and most economical way possible. Members of Congress (keepers of the purse) were and are fighting it at every turn. Government agencies had to have a piece of it, providing data for deciding customer eligibility and policy level; law enforcement and immigration concerns play a part. The requirements were a result of compromise (in the political sausage making sense) and turf dominance, some of which are part of any project, but at a hyper level when government agencies are involved. There was probably no technical adult in the room telling political people that this and that just can't be done in any economical and working way.
The government does not normally provide web sites to manage and coordinate anything between government, citizens and corporations on this scale. The most you'll usually see, from the outside as a citizen/consumer, is listing of information in text or pdf format, possibly filling in a form to make an appointment or communicate with a representative. They don't know what they're doing, in a profound sense and on a grand scale.
The government just doesn't have experience managing and running such a site with such requirements. They're trying to do something like Facebook in its current incarnation right from the start. It's like never having gone to the moon and strapping some astronauts on the top of an ICBM and hoping for the best, which is a formual to "fail fast" in the worst sense.
Because they didn't know what they were doing, and because it was probably thought of as just another IT contract effort, they followed standard procurement practices and used standard ("we know them") vendors. And that failed miserably.
And because of all of the above, and general inexperience for such a project, and relatively unlimited funds to get it as wrong as possible, they started actual specification and implementation way, way late, with the added complication that the possibility of a time overrun was just not there, because of a hard political deadline. It's no wonder that testing was done so poorly and ineptly, they just had no time at all.
- jeffdavis 13y agoI don't see how Congress can be responsible for most of the reported problems. If the law was just too complicated, then I could see how portions would be inaccessible. But what we see here are major UI failures, availability problems, losing applications partway through the process and forcing people to start over, and inexplicably inconsistent results and behaviors. These are failures of execution.
- a3n 13y ago> These are failures of execution. They are, but in my opinion they happened because they tried to do a full on web site in a rush with outdated federal procurement and hostile stakeholders. The implementers and implementation were doomed. There's a lot more to a web site fronting a huge federal program beyond mere technology.
- sp332 13y agoObama seemed very surprised that no one told him the project was going so badly. Delaying the project would have been bad for his reputation but not nearly as bad as the fact that hardly anyone could log in on the day it launched! Somehow he had managed the project so badly that he hadn't even communicated this basic set of priorities to the team.
- d23 13y agoThe unavailability of the site made for great headlines for a couple of months, but ultimate it will be nothing more than a footnote in the history books.
- a3n 13y agoI hope the law itself will be nothing more than a footnote in the history books. It's maddening to me that we still have insurance companies in charge of and gatekeepers to health care.
- gdubs 13y agoLaws are messy, that's pretty much a given. A nasty set of requirements didn't screw this up -- an outdated process for software development screwed it up. It's also solvable. So, rather than throwing our hands up and saying "government can't handle big problems", we should demand reform in the bidding process, and in how technology processes are managed and executed.