5 ms·
1. Mobile devices are cheaper than PCs. One reason mobile ended the PC era is that the manufacturing economies of mobile devices are better than those for PCs.
by Zigurd 13y ago
1. Mobile devices are cheaper than PCs. One reason mobile ended the PC era is that the manufacturing economies of mobile devices are better than those for PCs.
2. Mobile connectivity is more available than fixed connectivity, even to the poor.
3. Touch interfaces are friendlier than PC interfaces.
So if you want to make a realistic comparison, find out what a person with limited resources is going to buy first: A smart mobile device, or a PC?
- falcolas 13y ago1) I can purchase a fairly powerful computer for under $300. Finding an unsubsidized smartphone for that price is fairly hard (subsidized phones require credit checks, and people with poor credit can't get smartphone subsidies, and need to put down $1-200 in escrow in the event that they are unable to pay a month's bill). 2) What kind of mobile connectivity? WiFi is getting harder to find, as more and more APs lock down their connections for liability reasons. There's also the security risks with open WiFi APs. 4g is expensive, and with some pretty low data caps. 3) Depends on what you grew up with. The only thing touch replaces is the mouse, and if you grew up with a mouse, it can take a bit to learn all of the "natural" gestures that tablets expect. To summarize, I'm paying about $140 a month for my and my wife's "cheap" smartphones, with a $200 up front payment and a 2 year contract. The computer I'm typing this on, on the other hand, costs me $40 a month for fiber, with a $200 up front payment (chromebook). Mobile certainly isn't cheaper, at least for me, and I'm in a comfortable place with my finances.
- eropple 13y agoYour numbers sound high. The Nexus 4 was $299 at release, dropped to $199 nearing the end of its lifecycle. The new Moto G is something like $179. It was hard to find an unsubsidized phone a while ago, but that barrier is coming down rapidly. As far as service is concerned, I pay $45 a month for HSPA+ service on AT&T's network with Straight Talk. Unlimited talk/text/web (and they say "no tethering" but you have to do something stupid to get dinged for that), no contract. I could go to T-Mobile for $30 a month but their service in my area is much worse, especially inside buildings, and I'm willing to pay $15/month for convenience. Mobile is cheaper than my $80/month Comcast bill, and the only reason it's even remotely close is because my rMBP was provided by work. I'd rather have a computer because it's better for me, but I would not be surprised at all to see downmarket audiences switch aggressively (and I've started to see it around me already, but I live in a very urban area with good cell coverage).
- mathattack 13y agoMany regions skip landlines and go straight to mobile phones. This idea that everything will get stolen because people are poor speaks to a very small subset of the population. People have mobile phones in the favelas of Brazil. You don't get much poorer or high crime than than.
- a3n 13y agoYour post and generalpf's post make me wonder, if a person's only internet connection is their phone, and it gets stolen, then how would you manage post-theft security features like locking, disabling, spying (on the presumed thieves) and wiping? And a further barely related thought, as phones get cheaper, what a rich spying device would be a phone dropped outside a company or government building, compared to a dropped flash drive.
- marcosdumay 13y agoFor your first part - smart people have backups, everbody else lose data. It was always that way, it'll always be. The only feature missing is remote locking - here at Brazil phone line locking works quite well, but not device locking, that later one requires encryption, and risks losing data (see that part about backups) so it won't become widespread, no matter how prevalent is theft. About that second point, I guess phones are already cheap enough to be used that way. Up to now it's probably more effective to just hack somebody's phone, it probably has lower risks, and a highter success ratio. If phones become more secure, I can imagine people just doing what you said.
- elorant 13y agoMobile devices are cheaper than PCs. One reason mobile ended the PC era is that the manufacturing economies of mobile devices are better than those for PCs. In the long run they're actually more expensive. You don't change your PC every two years. Actually, if you don't play video games you don't even need to change it for five years or more. Most smartphone users I know change devices every 18 months. Touch interfaces are friendlier than PC interfaces. I see a lot of people who have developed mild RSI problems in their wrists from usage of mobile devices, especially tablets. In the PC we have a wonderful accessory which is the trackball. I prefer it 10x times more than dragging my whole hand over a hard surface. Give it another 10 years and we'd end up with a whole generation with severe health problems in their hands.
- gizmo686 13y ago>In the long run they're actually more expensive. You don't change your PC every two years. Actually, if you don't play video games you don't even need to change it for five years or more. Most smartphone users I know change devices every 18 months. I suspect this is a short term phenomena. Smartphones have been getting better at an exceptional rate, wheras computers have recently reached the point of 'good enough', where people do not need to upgrade as often. Combined with the free upgrade system that a lot of companies have, and the connection with contracts, it is easy to imagine that the current state is not long term. Also, the poor are exactly the people who would continue to use an old device that is good enough, even after a shinier model comes out.