5 ms·
It’s yet to be seen to what extent national landlords, with easy access to capital and loans, can keep outbidding first-time homebuyers, depriving families of t
by jseliger 13y ago
It’s yet to be seen to what extent national landlords, with easy access to capital and loans, can keep outbidding first-time homebuyers, depriving families of the opportunity to build wealth, and what their impact on rents will be.
This is an insane comment, for the reasons Matt Yglesias discusses in The Rent is Too Damn High and, to a lesser extent, here: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/04/26/housing_isn_t_an_investment_but_land_is.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/04/26/housing_isn_t... . Over the long term buying versus renting should ideally be revenue neutral, and whether or not you can "build wealth" via a house depends in large part on where the house is. Someone who bought a house 30 years in San Francisco or the west side of L.A. has made a lot of money. Someone who bought in the greater Detroit area hasn't.
The myth that buying a house is a key to unlocking wealth needs to be addressed and yet is too often propagated by journalists.
EDIT: See also this: http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2011/05/the_rent_isnt_too_damn_high.html http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2011/05/the_... .
- VLM 13y ago"buying a house is a key to unlocking wealth" It most certainly is, for journalists. Take a look at the ads and follow the money. You're not going to sell ad space to home depot or the local real estate agents if your readers are renters. Also revenue neutral is not as strong of a claim as inflation neutral. A stick built box of air is the new "gold". A non-performing asset which varies in price somewhat scarily, but more or less on a long term tracks median income, which increases at a lower rate than inflation but not too much lower (else you get a revolution)
- nwzpaperman 13y agoEdit: requires maintenance and taxes. Renting a home is the same thing as mortgaging a home, but with a put option.
- Brakenshire 13y agoAre you suggesting that newspapers are involved in a conspiracy to push the idea of home ownership so that they can sell adverts to DIY / home improvement companies? That is an, interesting, idea.
- benjaminwootton 13y agoNewspapers are in the business of telling their readers what they want to hear, and people they want to hear that owning is the path to wealth and that the value of their home is going up. In addition much of our media and the people within it have a vested interest in property price rises, usually because they are up to their necks in buy to let property. Exhibit number 1 from here in the UK. http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Un_cxT0Q4M0/Tw7ZZCg1feI/AAAAAAAABgw/K0MISGjob00/s1600/1.jpg http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Un_cxT0Q4M0/Tw7ZZCg1feI/AAAAAAAABg...
- malandrew 13y agoWhoa. That image is enlightening. I'm curious if it is highly curated, conveniently leaving out certain covers, of if it is an accurate reflection of the newspaper's bias.
- Brakenshire 13y agoNo, the Express genuinely is that crazy, you could create the same panel of images for conspiracies about Princess Diana being murdered. But, other than the Mail, it's not at all representative of the rest of the British press.
- jbooth 13y agoNo conspiracy necessary. Just lots of little biases.
- VLM 13y agoA group of businessmen convergently evolving their profit maximization strategy is called a "business sector" not a "conspiracy". And I'm not claiming just big box DIY stores, but listing real estate agent ads, bank and mortgage broker ads, home repair, upgrade, and maint ads (plumbers, roofers, etc) and last but not least real estate developer / condo advertisers. Don't bite the hand that feeds you, especially when you're really hungry.
- dasil003 13y agoI like the elegance of that ideal, but a lot of things make me wonder how well it holds up in practice. For intense, why is buying property in Europe so expensive relative to the US, but renting is not?
- maxerickson 13y agoI don't think it explains everything, but population density tends to drive land prices up and government regulation tends to hold rent down. There's also a lot more of what you might call undeveloped land in the U.S., where large pieces of land are privately owned and carry little in the way of building restrictions (and maybe in addition the land is not very productive for forestry or agriculture).
- clavalle 13y agoWell, the 'myth' has merit. Let's apply common sense. You buy a smallish house in a suburb and pay $1000/month for you mortgage. $900 of that goes directly to equity. At the end of the year, if you home retains its value, you have over $10,000 in equity. If you pay the same amount for rent, you have nothing to show for it. And oftentimes rent for an equivalent house is actually more than the mortgage + tax payments. So, which is better $10,000 or $0? The volatility of the last few years has complicated this a bit (people going underwater, for example), and I don't think people should see a home as a vehicle for getting rich, but it is generally a nice value store. Plus, there are HUGE advantages for people invested in the area to own their property. It is more stable for them (they can't be kicked out), they are more likely to invest in the value of their area (volunteerism, making sure local politicians take care of the parks, reporting crime, that kind of thing). Edit: Let me point out that yes, these numbers are made up and don't accurately reflect reality. I did not use a mortgage calculator or anything (I thought that would be obvious) but the underlying idea that I was trying to convey holds....if you are spending x dollars and are able to store any portion of that in something that holds some value it is better than spending x dollars and not storing any of that value. So, even if only $10 of every $1000 spent on the mortgage goes into equity, it is better than $0 if you rent.
- pnut 13y agoHave you ever actually had a mortgage? The majority of your mortgage payment goes directly to interest, NOT equity. Equity contributions only ramp towards the very end of the term. Up front, you are paying mostly interest.
- seandhi 13y agoAnd if you live in a state with high property taxes, like Texas, then your taxes will likely dwarf any principal that you pay at the beginning of your loan.
- marincounty 13y agoIt seems like so many people fail to realize how much property taxes can add up too?
- busterarm 13y agoThat's all nice if you live somewhere where rentals and mortgages are even. Do those even exist? Where I live renters pay a $300-500/mo premium over what they'd pay if they had a mortgage. I sure would like an extra $6000 a year to go to building my wealth vs building someone else's, wouldn't you? Edit: That money is almost pure profit here as well, because the homeowners here don't put any money into upkeep and most don't even pay their PoA/HoA fees as most of those are bankrupt here and having a hard time collecting from anyone.
- mjmahone17 13y agoWhere I'm from (not where I live), renters pay about $300-500/mo less than the cost of a mortgage.
- busterarm 13y agoYeah, renting in a lot of places is a good deal. A lot of real estate markets (read: NY & SF) are totally insane. A lot of wealthy people (corporations are people too now. The courts said so!) are sitting on limited space and expecting outrageous ROIs out of their land (that goes for rentals too). But they're never even, and that's the point. I don't want to get on my LVT preacher's box, but man would I be pleased to see that happen.
- patrickk 13y ago> Where I live renters pay a $300-500/mo premium over what they'd pay if they had a mortgage. >I sure would like an extra $6000 a year to go to building my wealth vs building someone else's That's the crux of the argument here. Money that would otherwise be spread around (the difference between owning and renting) instead lines the pockets of the shareholders of private equity firms. It's almost like a forced tax, because if you have to live in an area (e.g. can't move because of family, employment, access to schools etc), but are outbidded from the house you'd otherwise be able to afford - that means you are forced to rent.
- busterarm 13y agoExactly, I was just driving it home. ;) In my situation I don't mind it right now. It's a lot cheaper than living in New York and I work remotely. There's absolutely no decent work here, so I don't want to be trapped owning a home down here. Unfortunately, I'm starting to realize that with my increased travel costs, living in New York would still work out better for me financially and (more importantly) socially.
- thatthatis 13y agoIt shouldnt be exactly neutral, it should be risk adjusted neutral.
- beagle3 13y agoAn, but "risk adjusted" assumes a specific risk model, and there isn't one that's universally applicable (not even a measure of risk). And without specifying these, inflation or profit neutral still make sense, and risk adjusted doesn't.
- thatthatis 13y agoNot necessarily. Modern Portfolio Theory says that in stocks, even though the lack of universal risk model exists, the market still finds a way to price risk such that portfolios cannot get risk free returns just by diversifying. So, even without a standard risk model the market usually prices risk within a bound.
- beagle3 13y agoWhich is useless in the context of two options are equivalent under "risk equality" - the context of this discussion.
- thatthatis 13y agoWhy do you think a result within a bound is useless?
- beagle3 13y agoBecause the bound is unknown, and unspecified. I agree that the market tends to price some sort of risk. However, the discussion was "ownership vs rent", with the consensus beIng the cost should be equivalent under some measure; however, some expect it to be cashflow neutral, some inflation neutral, and some risk neutral. Of these, the first two can be quantified but the last cannot - and it is therefore not useful in the discussion of whether the prices make sense. After more than 100 years of discussion, there is still no consensus among economists over whether one should maximize expected value or expected logarithmic value. People often mention use "on a risk adjusted basis" without qualifying the adjustment - and that's a useless thing to do.
- craigyk 13y agoI don't know about buying a 'house', but I think owning land is a key component to achieving wealth, provided one buys at the right place and/or time and that one can also afford to sell it when the time comes. Unlike gold or BTC, land is a limited resource that actually has intrinsic value- especially in countries that grant ownership of resources. Even buying a primary residence is a reasonable path toward wealth if one plans well and is willing to sell and move somewhere cheaper when the time comes.
- busterarm 13y agoWouldn't it be amazing if wealth were a product of your own labor and not of your ability to stake claims and extract it from other peoples' labor? If wealth from land ownership is all about location and timing, then you have insane advantages like being lucky enough to be born before the next schmuck who wants some land. Come to think of it, if you really wanted to invest in your future generations' future, one of the best investments you can possibly make (albeit risky) is to stake claims on the Moon/Mars/Asteroids/etc. I totally need to rethink my position on Plantary Resources and Deep Space Industries.
- VLM 13y ago"intrinsic value" Intrinsic liability, you mean. My little plot of land comes with a $300/month prop tax liability aka "rent" in addition to the costs of ownership. And of course land comes with unlimited legal liability unless you pay $50/month or so for liability insurance. BTC of course costs nothing to store, although most people who will store it for you would like to skim, and/or there is some fundamental lower limit on the cost of storing/maintaining a wallet. As for gold, you'd be shocked what can be fit into a mere $25 credit union safe deposit box and for the $350/month that my land costs, I could get a safe deposit box big enough to park a motorcycle or scooter in it. In some ways gold is free, in the same way that unless you're a lunatic you have some kind of off site digital backup scheme with flash drives getting rotated monthly or so into a safe deposit box so the empty space could hold some coin. Of course in the same way BTC is free because you've got a backup scheme anyway and a wallet is pretty small. Either are much cheaper than "owning" land.