5 ms·
"The levels were incredibly dangerous and at one point, the radiation in the air measured 300 times higher than what was considered safe, Sebourn told The Post.
by VLM 13y ago
"The levels were incredibly dangerous and at one point, the radiation in the air measured 300 times higher than what was considered safe, Sebourn told The Post."
This doesn't mean anything, its technobabble. How many REM or mSv total exposure?
"I said something complicated and science-y sounding, so you are supposed to be scared right now".
The biggest misfortune is they may even accidentally be correct, just completely incompetent about it.
A big epidemiology problem is identifying the actual cause by symptom, and avoiding the assumption that participation in something big and scary therefore means all problems must be caused by big n scary. Some goofball tipping over a barrel of solvent in the maint bay could cause many cancers later, and is marginally more likely.
- platz 13y agoAmazing how you think your claim is better informed than those from a primary source. You're right, the mystery solvent must have been it.
- yapcguy 13y agoYou can't argue with some people, perhaps like the original poster. Even if figures and readings are produced, some will talk about bananas, flying in an aeroplane, and background radiation. The biggest joke of all has been how the "safety limits" of different types of radiation were all magically raised after Fukushima.
- glenra 13y agoIf actual measurements of radioactivity were produced rather than measurements in terms of "tons of water (with some tiny unknown percentage of radioactive component)" or "300 times the level considered safe (without saying what that level actually is)", then it would be possible to talk sensibly about how it compares to other exposure sources. Such as eating bananas, living in Colorado, getting a dental x-ray and so on. And it might still be scary if we knew the numbers, but without real numbers we can't know that it's worth worrying about.
- yapcguy 13y agoYou cannot compare eating a banana to ingesting the by-products of man-made nuclear fission. I'm sorry but you have fallen hook, line and sinker for the nuclear industry's PR / propaganda / talking points. There are real numbers from the Fukushima disaster. Just because this single NYPost article does not cite that data does not mean it does not exist.
- tptacek 13y agoWhy can't you compare eating a banana to ingesting the by-products of man-made nuclear fission? Aren't both ingestible substances bound by the same laws of physics?
- HCIdivision17 13y agoThe point is that each of those vectors of exposure carry some obvious context. Which matters a lot: where you are in relation to the radiation matters immensely. Alpha is harmless from without, but deadly within. What are the energies of the decay, and what particles are emitted? Are there secondary/tertiary decays and when? Can the body keep up with the damage? Are we talking sunburns or cancer inducing high energy gamma or high kinetic energy alpha? Nuclear physics earns it's reputation as a complicated science. Units matter, and context matters. Perhaps we should fear bananas, or use it as a point if reference. Either way, it's a useful, comprehensible comparison, just like the others mentioned. Just think it through, and you don't need to worry about falling for hog wash.
- icambron 13y ago> Even if figures and readings are produced, some will talk about bananas, flying in an aeroplane, and background radiation From listening to those people, you might almost think the numbers were factual information to be evaluated thoughtfully!
- Turing_Machine 13y agoA report as spun by lawyers and the New York Post is a "primary source"? "Considered safe" for how long? For continuous life exposure? For the length of time it takes to make a medical X-Ray? It doesn't say. The OP is right. There is zero useful information in that statement.
- cpleppert 13y agoI'm a little confused here, why are the sailors on the aircraft carrier a hundred miles off the coast suing and not the helicopter crews or the sailors on the destroyers that got closer? People are bashing the article not because it is from the NY Post but because there is a zero evidence that being on a ship a hundred miles away was more dangerous than actually being at the site or in tokyo. The article is filled with all kinds of misunderstandings about radioactivity that are accepted wholesale by the reporter to drum up a good story.
- marze 13y agoWell, I wouldn't want to walk around outside with levels at 300 times what is "considered safe". Japan is just lucky that 95% of the radioactive release from the meltdowns was blown out over the ocean, otherwise a much larger fraction of their island would have become useless for agriculture. If the earthquake occurred during the fall, the winds would have been generally off the ocean.
- glenra 13y ago> Well, I wouldn't want to walk around outside with levels at 300 times what is "considered safe". Wouldn't that depend on how many orders of magnitude of safety margin went into deciding what is "considered safe"?
- coldtea 13y agoNo, because what is "considered safe" in the first place is not reachet at by scientific consensus aimed at the well being of the population, but by how far private and state interests can raise the "safe dosage" in order to cover their asses and go about their polluting as usual.
- Dylan16807 13y agoPoliticians are pretty scared of radiation, they may very well set 'safe' limits far lower than they need to be. It's not one-sided.
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoHere's numbers and a primary source [0]: "For perspective, the maximum potential radiation dose received by any ship's force personnel aboard the ship when it passed through the area was less than the radiation exposure received from about one month of exposure to natural background radiation from sources such as rocks, soil, and the sun." Meaning ~300 uSv, or three orders of magnitude short of acute radiation poisoning [1]. "Using sensitive instruments, precautionary measurements of three helicopter aircrews returning to USS Ronald Reagan after conducting disaster relief missions near Sendai identified low levels of radioactivity on 17 air crew members. The low level radioactivity was easily removed from affected personnel by washing with soap and water. They were subsequently surveyed, and no further contamination was detected." (edit) By the way, [0] says the carrier was 100 miles from Fukushima at the time. Overlay that with the calculated I-131 dose map [2] (from [3]) (I-131 is the largest early dose component); it makes it really hard to believe any of these claims. The paper [3] is relevant too: it shows off the ability to measure internal I-131 dose, long after the fact. And claims that people far closer to the disaster, with presumed far higher radiation exposures [2], are relatively safe. [0] http://www.navy.mil/submit/display.asp?story_id=59065 http://www.navy.mil/submit/display.asp?story_id=59065 [1] http://xkcd.com/radiation/ http://xkcd.com/radiation/ [2] (figure only) http://www.nature.com/srep/2012/120712/srep00507/fig_tab/srep00507_F1.html http://www.nature.com/srep/2012/120712/srep00507/fig_tab/sre... [3] (full paper) http://www.nature.com/srep/2012/120712/srep00507/full/srep00507.html http://www.nature.com/srep/2012/120712/srep00507/full/srep00...
- moocowduckquack 13y agoIf any of them have manage to ingest any of the snow, then they could be subject to long term internal exposure and depending on the type of source, it could be very difficult to scan for.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoOnce a radioactive source is in your body, even alpha radiation will kill you.
- 13y ago
- jrockway 13y agoIt's the New York Post. Don't trust a word it says.
- cpleppert 13y agoEven worse: >>“We were probably floating in contaminated water without knowing it for a day and a half before we got hit by that plume,” said Cooper, whose career as a third-class petty officer ended five months after the disaster for health reasons. The toxic seawater was sucked into the ship’s desalinization system, flowing out of its faucets and showers — still radioactive — and into the crew member’s bodies. Toxic seawater a hundred miles offshore???? You can't make up anything more ridiculous.
- Natsu 13y agoThis source is... less than reliable as they have no idea what they're talking about. It's not hard to find high school students with a better grasp of this subject than this reporter, sadly. Apparently there are still many sources that have yet to figure out that things like dosage, length of exposure and type of radiation matter quite a bit, though oddly enough, it seems like many would be more likely to understand this if it were ordinary toxic chemical exposure. That said, I wouldn't weigh things too heavily either way, just because these folks are breaking the news. I very much doubt we have the whole story here and I would prefer not to weigh in until all the information is out. Other commentators on HN have noted that this was a nuclear carrier, so there should be proper records of their exposure (not to mention alternate routes of exposure...) which should be properly evaluated before rushing to judgement here, but there are simply too many possibilities to sensibly evaluate them all without more information. For example, the article makes it sound like they were exposed to radioactive iodine (due to the thyroid conditions), something I would have expected the carrier to detect, and for which we have reasonable counter-measures (iodine pills). I do not have any insight into what went wrong, but I would focus my investigation on their records of exposure, any treatments, etc. My gut tells me that someone screwed up here, but we lack information sufficient to determine who, and everything is suspect. That aside, radiation sickness is a terrible thing, and hope they are able to recover.
- nevinera 13y ago>Tokyo Electric Power also knew that radioactivity was leaking at a rate of 400 tons a day into the North Pacific, according to the lawsuit and Japanese officials. This was my favorite line.
- dubfan 13y agoWow, I didn't realize you could weigh radioactivity!
- ceejayoz 13y agohttp://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/188316/English-water-ton http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/188316/English-wat...
- mseebach 13y agoYou can weigh water, you can even weigh radioactive water. You can't weigh radioactivity.
- moocowduckquack 13y agosure ya can, e=mc²