6 ms·
Putin critic Khodorkovsky in Germany after pardon
- adventured 13y agoInterestingly had Russia not seized and broken up Yukos, Khodorkovsky might very well be the richest man on earth today (and most certainly in the top 10). He was worth an estimated $15 billion in 2003 according to Forbes. The price of oil was about 30% what it is now, and it's very plausible Yukos' fortunes would have climbed with the recovery in Russia's economy (and assuming general business expansion).
- perlpimp 13y agoGuantanamo detainees sent to their homes. Putin declares amnesty after olympic delegates of US olympic committee to be staffed by homosexuals. Is this some sort of geopolitical game foreshadowing chilling of relations?
- lobotryas 13y agoGame? Of course. Chilling? That's bad for business.
- CamperBob2 13y agoI can't believe Putin turned him loose, honestly. That guy has got to be dangerous. He has had nothing to do for several years but sit around stewing about how to put one over on Putin. Should be interesting to see what happens next.
- hedgie13 13y agoDangerous or not dangerous, 10 years of life spent in prison is a lot. Let's see what happens next.
- smsm42 13y agoThat assumes he actually wants to put one over on Putin. But there are other ways to have a good life, especially if one is a very capable entrepreneur.
- adventured 13y agoI'm surprised they let him go too. I guess we'll see if he dies of some form of aggressive cancer a year from now.
- alan_cx 13y agoYeah, it is surprising. Must be a reason for it. Clearly he's lost most if not all of his money, but Im sure he has some public appeal which would be dangerous for Putin. Or maybe he just agreed to come to Europe, buy a football club and shut up. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
- lobster_johnson 13y agoThis, together with the release of Pussy Riot and the Greenpeace activists, has been speculated as being Russia's attempt to clean up its image for the 2014 Olympic Games. Given the timing, it's not surprising.
- bonemachine 13y agoLet's hope that similar "principles of humanity" will be applied to Chelsea Manning, some day.
- pekk 13y agoEither don't join the military, or don't violate military law. Because it's not the same as civilian law and never was.
- rz2k 13y agoWhen you put it that way, the situations begin to sound more parallel than I would have thought. There are rules to being an oligarch, though the payoff is a lot better, and Khodorkovsky should have had a more sophisticated understanding of the terms of the deal.
- smsm42 13y agoThere's a bit of a difference between running afoul of the dictator and getting 10 years in jail on a show trial and joining the military and getting jail term for leaking actual secrets you took the oath not to disclose.
- bonemachine 13y agoGeneral humanitarian principles (specifically against torture -- as Ms. Manning was indisputably subjected to) have far greater precedence over any country's military justice code.
- nisa 13y agoHe is likely a criminal[1] and I'm really baffled how positive he is portrayed in the media here in Germany. 1: http://books.google.de/books?id=q1F4otnSovMC&lpg=PA59&pg=PA58#v=onepage&q&f=false http://books.google.de/books?id=q1F4otnSovMC&lpg=PA59&pg=PA5... and the following pages
- lobotryas 13y agoSimple: "enemy of my enemy...".
- zavulon 13y agoI wouldn't use a blanket statement like that, it's actually a lot more complicated. First of all, the tax system in Russia is set up that it's impossible to run a business without violating one tax law or the other. That setup is intentional, put in place specifically so anybody who's in Putin's way can be put away for tax crimes. That's exactly what happened here, and tax charges are bogus. Having said that, you couldn't become a billionaire "new Russian" in the early 90's without doing something horrible, which I'm sure Khodorkovskiy has done at some point. So he probably is a criminal. However, the ONLY reason he was put in jail is that he dared to defy Putin. Everything else was bogus - charges were fabricated, judges had direct orders to convict him, etc.
- nisa 13y agoYes. I did not intent to defend Putin. I've edited my post. The reason for posting here in the first place was that I was baffled about the media reaction here. No mention of his past action anywhere.
- lobster_johnson 13y ago> Having said that, you couldn't become a billionaire "new Russian" in the early 90's without doing something horrible That necessarily includes Putin himself, who is alleged to have amassed a fortune that's in the billions.
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoI am sure Khodorkovsky did not make his fortune by legal means. Simply because legality was a murky concept during the time when he built his empire. On the other hand, Putin is a warlord, there is no doubt and if Khodorkovsky supported Putin instead of opposed him things would be very different for him. Some random thoughts on political situation in Russia: Dictatorships are more efficient in handling some issues, and less efficient in handling others (lower to mid level official corruption). Are his methods correct in terms of Russian mentality? History will tell. One thing is certain, empires of warlords often were in turmoil when they passed on [1]. I think Russia is in for interesting times when Putin will be stepping away (And taking rest of the world along with them for a ride due to Russia's status as a nuclear superpower). [1] It could be argued that fall of USSR was catalyzed by a string of weak leaders after some of more prominent warlords passed away.
- strlen 13y agoAs someone from former USSR, here's my take: the reason Khodorkovsky went to jail is because he violated the law of thieves, he stood up to Putin's bullying. If there was an across-the-board principled anti-corruption effort it would be a different matter, but there wasn't. I am tired of hearing Western's justify Putin's thuggery. I personally come from Belarus, where a president that was democratically elected on anti-corruption charges assumed the role of a dictator. This was well expected by most of the intelligentsia: on the day of the run off election where Lukashenko's win (against another shitbird, of course, who ended up siding with Lukashenko afterwards) was confirmed my brother called us and told us to lookup 'Sulla' (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sulla http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sulla) in a history book. The practice of using "crusade against corruption" to assume dictatorial role is as old as democracy itself. That said Putin is far more pernicious than Lukashenko: with Lukashenko there is no longer any more of a pretense of democracy than there was under, e.g., Saddam in Iraq (there are elections with mythical sounding figures and no campaigns). Putin is far more cunning: he's able to maintain the facade of democracy while having unchecked and unelected power. With recent revelations about "enhanced interrogations", NSA and FISA kangaroo courts, US -- while light years far from turning into a Russia or Belarus -- is starting to show some of these very same dangerous signs of police state(1) tactics via plausible deniability. I'll leave this quote out there on the topic of rule by robber barrons (which the oligarchs were plain and simple) vs. rule by thugs on a moral crusade: "Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience." - C.S. Lewis (1) Here I am using the historical definition of police state: while today it's equated with totalitarianism (and neither Russia nor Belarus -- much less United States even under the worse scenario -- are totalitarian states, as anyone living in those countries who has also lived under Soviet rule can attest), the original meaning contrasted a 'polizeistaat' (rule by decree without any constitutional limitations) with a 'rechtstaat' (rights state -- constitutionally limited rule of law). As a side note, it is unfortunate that the privatization process was botched enormously in USSR and its successor states. I always thought that the right approach to privatization should have been to follow the old Leninist slogan _literally_: factories to workers, farms to peasants, i.e., give the employees non-trivial amounts of shares/options in their workplace. Instead it became "factories and farms to corrupt middle managers and old Soviet elite".
- rsp1984 13y agoWhat is not clear from all the reports: Has his partner Platon Lebedev been pardoned as well or is he still imprisoned? As far as I know they were facing much the same charges.
- znowi 13y agoI thought they're about to canonize him at the end of the article :) I really feel for the guy. He took the stand, went to jail - but he's far from a "prisoner of conscience". Many high profile criminals use dislike of Mr Putin in the west as a safe getaway from Russia. They commonly claim that Putin is after them and they're the opposition. One case in point is Andrey Borodin - former president of a major bank in Russia. He made multiple billion dollar loans to himself through affiliated fly-by-night firms in the offshore. When he was caught, he fled to the UK and suddenly turned opposition overnight. Eventually granted an asylum and lives happily in Oxfordshire in his newly acquired 140 million pounds mansion. This happened in 2011. In the 90s, when Khodorkovsky operated, things were a lot less clean. He got nabbed. Many others found a way to avoid imprisonment. A lot of them now are "respectable" businessmen ranked high up in the Forbes list.
- dfkf 13y agoYes, Borodin is an excellent example. Never participated in politics in any form or shape. Set a new record for the most expensive house ever sold in Britain. Verdict? Victim of political persecution by evil Putin the mobster/warlord/thug/KayGeBee/whatever...
- mc32 13y agoThe thing is in the 90s everyone (oligarchs) was playing below board. But Putin only targeted (for prosecution) people who opposed him (or were potential threats). People who were willing to subjugate to him, of course, didn't face charges. I'd rather you not try to compare Borodin with Khodorkovsky. It diverts from the discussion the strongarming politics in Russia.
- menato 13y agoKhodorkovsky was prosecuted partly for his ambitions to move to politics.
- bostik 13y ago> But Putin only targeted (for prosecution) people who opposed him (or were potential threats). Which is why I express my cynicism at the timing of Khodorkovsky's pardon. There must be a reason for letting him out now, so I can not help but think that Putin wanted to remind someone (or many someones) what he can do to politically inconvenient opponents. The beauty, if one can use such a word in this context, is that the reminder comes in a form of letting a person out of the prison. So much more convenient.
- 1gor 13y agoThe European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has ruled that Mikhail Khodorkovsky's trial was not politically motivated. (http://www.rferl.org/content/russia-european-court-khodorkovsky/25056475.html http://www.rferl.org/content/russia-european-court-khodorkov...). This means Khodorkovsky was jailed for his economic crimes, not because of his anti-Putin stance. Why Western media keeps referring to him as a 'political prisoner' and 'freed dissident' (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-25472250 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-25472250)?
- vasilipupkin 13y agoBecause he did not receive a fair trial. It's quite obvious that he was jailed for reasons that have little to do with serving justice
- 1gor 13y agoThe European Court of Human Rights said there was no violation of the defendants' right to a fair trial. This is from the linked article on Radio Free Europe site.
- cpleppert 13y agoThe article said in a narrow sense that the charges on their own had a healthy foundation. It is very clear that the decision to prosecute a tax violation in a tax code designed to force businesses to skirt the law to remain competitive was politically motivated. The business environment is why there have been massive amounts of capital outflows in recent years. Everyone understands the game being played here, you get to play by Putin's rule are you get your toys taken away at the minimum or get sent to a siberian penal colony.
- 1gor 13y ago> It is very clear that the decision to prosecute ... was politically motivated. No, the opposite is clear. The ECHR court "found no basis that the case against the two was politically motivated, as Khodorkovsky and Lebedev alleged in their complaint" (direct quote). The supra-national court is in no sense a pro-Russian organisation, and the judges were perfectly aware of the political implications of their ruling. They did note several improprieties of the trial (keeping defendants in cages etc.), and even ordered Russian state to pay some compensation to the defendants, but that did not change their core conclusion. Khodorkovsky was enriching himself by defrauding the state and the Russian public (most of the social security is funded through oil taxes). This was the reason for his prosecution, regardless of what "everybody understands" thanks to various PR campaigns.
- beaker 13y agoCopy & paste from a friend who called this over 2 weeks ago: "12/3/13 >Free pussy riot! >But I hear he's giving them amnesty. Khordokovsky too. All hail Putin!" Look for Pussy Riot to be the next to be released...
- beaker 13y agoI hadn't seen this yet... http://www.usatoday.com/story/life/music/2013/12/19/pussy-riot-members-freed-from-prison/4123959/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/life/music/2013/12/19/pussy-ri...
- VladRussian2 13y agoOne can only wonder how fast Germany issued a visa to a criminal convicted of economic crime ( when anybody just half-knowledgeable about USSR/Russia 198x-199x history has no doubts about the crimes) . Calling him a "prisoner of conscience" is total disrespect and offense to real prisoners of conscience who stand up and suffer for their principles (like Pussy Riot girls for example). He stood up for his wealth and power refusing to accept the reality that the new rising thief at the time - Putin and Co. - become stronger than him. He challenged Putin and lost. Will Putin be called a "prisoner of conscience" when/if some new guy send Putin to a Siberia camp?
- Mikeb85 13y agoPussy Riot, really? They would have been thrown in jail in most western countries for what they did too. Hell, in Canada they may have even been charged with a hate crime... The only reason anyone cares about them is because they also happened to criticise Putin...
- VladRussian2 13y agonobody said that western countries don't have prisoners of conscience or laws which would make them. Aaron Swartz. Chelsea Manning. Or look at Animal and Ecological Terrorism Act laws. ...
- Mikeb85 13y agoVandalizing private property and hate speech have nothing to do with conscience... It's a piss poor justification... Just like people who bomb pipelines and spray paint swastikas on synagogues. Belief doesn't make a wrong a right...
- VladRussian2 13y ago>Vandalizing private property and hate speech have nothing to do with conscience... It has nothing to do with Pussy Riot. You're talking out of your a##. > Just like people who bomb pipelines and spray paint swastikas on synagogues. the same - it has nothing to do with Pussy Riot.
- Uchikoma 13y agoWhat comes to mind, again, in the discussion if he is a criminal or not: "“Did you really think we want those laws observed?" said Dr. Ferris. "We want them to be broken. [...] One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws."
- drill_sarge 13y agoI don't know why media is circle jerking about this. I am not a fan of Putin and I can see that he wanted simply to get rid of Chodorkowski and that he may or may not got a real fair trial. But in the end Chodorkowski is a criminal who tried to illegally sell/exploit property of the Russian state. I am not saying the other oligarchs surrounding Putin didn't do or tried the same, but Chodorkowski isn't a "Putin critic" for political reasons or somekind of activist. He was part of this whole game of corruption and mob crimes and he lost.