5 ms·
As much as this is a brilliant idea (opting out could possibly be recorded) I think the general consensus of the government right now needs to change, I seem t
by dijit 13y ago
As much as this is a brilliant idea (opting out could possibly be recorded)
I think the general consensus of the government right now needs to change, I seem to recall a hacker game from years ago (maybe 'Hacker Evolution') which described in it's prologue: "The world has been divided; governments censor and restrict access to the internet that was, hackers and technologists moved away from traditional means of communication and established the undernet..."
This kind of dystopian path is what we're on.
We should not hide, we should not have to.
if we do, then law enforcement will go unchecked and start penalizing us for simply hiding our tracks.
I can easily imagine a world in which using Tor becomes illegal, accessing the internet with a non-licensed browser, or having a method of tracing back to the point of origin (behind NAT) for ISP's.
ultimate accountability, ultimate censorship- possibly even having to get some form of license to even get access to the internet.
British people often forget the monopoly BT/Openreach have, it ties in closely to government (probably since they were state owned)
it would be very easy for them to enforce these kinds of legislations, and of course, when they do, they'll be doing it under the banner of 'whats best for the public'
They've taken filesharing.
They've taken sexual material. -and forced you to identify yourself-
They will take more.
there are inherent problems with even identifying yourself like this; what if another extremist party got into power. "those people, those are the perverts, we'll incarcerate them", or, assuming a 21 year old guy grows up and becomes a candidate for prime minister, the current administration could accidentally leak that he bypassed porn filters.
no, hiding should not be the default, patching should not be the solution.
I will fight, I will not stop.
and should I lose, I will simply leave this country and it's countrymen.
the EU convention lists internet access as a human right.
I find it ironic that we have more censorship now than some known human rights violators.
- IanCal 13y ago> the EU convention lists internet access as a human right. They're not stopping you from accessing the internet, they're essentially just giving people access to filtering software.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- summerdown2 13y agoI think the dystopian worry isn't that they're giving individuals access to filtering software. That would be a worthy goal. The real worry is that this system is Government controlled and built into everyone's internet connection. Personally, I'm expecting it to soon have three settings, not two: a) Family friendly browsing (opt-in) b) Access to more adult sites (opt-out) c) Blocking of whatever the government deems objectionable (no choice). ... and my guess is that they'll then make it illegal to bypass the filter or do anything other than use the official choice buttons. This is why a lot of people don't like it: because we're building the machinery of censorship "for the sake of the children."
- DanBC 13y agoThere are different filters. Some of them already have granularity. > c) Blocking of whatever the government deems objectionable (no choice). This already exists. The IWF provide sites that must be blocked and ISPs block those sites. It also happens when a company uses a court order to force and ISP to block a site.
- summerdown2 13y agoThe difference being that this is centrally controlled. Because of this, it's speed of censorship will be much quicker. Places I expect this to block in future: 1. Discussions of how to bypass the filter (eg Tor) 2. News articles the Government doesn't like (eg discussions barred by injunction such as Ryan Giggs) 3. Information during times of disorder (eg the tweeting by people involved in the Arab Spring). 4. Whatever the government of the day deems extreme porn/extremist/dissident. The future internet won't come with optional DA notices. Any new discussion like Snowden simply won't appear. Essentially, it's a selective kill-switch for the internet, and I think Edward Snowden said it best. This is about power, not safety. This is a mechanism for the establishment to protect itself.
- MisterWebz 13y agoHow do we incentivize people to fight back against every single law that could potentially harm privacy or force censorship? The people making these laws have every bit of incentive to do so, while the regular people have limited willpower, limited resources and limited time. Sure we can pull off another SOPA blackout, but I don't think we can do it consistently. They'll keep proposing harmful laws and we can't stop them all.
- annnnd 13y agoThe solution is to make those that support these bill pay the price (as high as possible - in votes, revenue, public image,...) for it. One by one...
- Centigonal 13y ago...Until we get tired or apathetic. Then we lose. There are asymmetric levels of incentive here. Organizing large-scale political action against everyone in the first world who infringes on people's internet privacy rights is simply unsustainable. You can't fight a problem that's essentially systemic by finding and painstakingly stamping out every instance of it happening. A systemic problem needs a systemic solution.
- rossriley 13y agoThe problem with this thinking is that it's impractical to vote on the basis of single issues when we elect representatives at a local level. When choosing from the ten or so candidates available we have to consider a broad spectrum of issues; who will manage the health service the best, who will be best for the economy etc. Whilst internet censorship is an important element, it's by no means the primary consideration even for us that work in the industry, let alone the wider electorate.
- gaius 13y agoYou can't. There was some guy on here yesterday arguing "your right to privacy is less important than protecting my children". Hello, parental responsibility? But something funny happens in the minds of (some, but not all) new parents and they want to see the world remade into a giant daycare centre. It doesn't occur to them that their kids will grow up and they'll find themselves in a world they don't want to live in.
- 7952 13y agoCensorship is an excellent demonstration of why network level blocking is a complete lost cause. You hardly need Tor, VPN, or a special browser when SSL is impossible to block in a non-destructive way. You can never effectively control what people do on their computer without controlling the computer itself. It would be much more effective to make blocking the responsibility of web browsers. This would allow settings at the user level, and circumvention prevented by normal OS security. Parents could enable or disable as they please.
- desas 13y agoBlocking via web browsers is definitely not going to work. It would require that every browser on each PC, phone, TV and other internet enabled device all activate the filters, all of them have a facility to activate/deactivate the filters, all of them don't allow other web browsers to be installed and don't allow booting from alternative sources. Most parents don't know how to do this. They do know how to tick a box when they are signing up for a broadband service. There are millions of devices already out there. SSL-enabled sites can already be "blocked" in the UK, they block the entire domain and the IP.
- 7952 13y agoSo you believe that the best way to help parents is to have network level blocks? People should use poorly designed technology because they are stupid? But to prevent kids getting around network level filtering you still need to have all the anti-circumvention measures baked into the OS/browser/anti-virus. The UK government have created a network level filter that still needs client level changes to actually work. I understand that most parents would have a hard time doing this, but a government backed effort could have made a difference. I see this as similar to installing antivirus (which a lots of parents seem perfectly capable of). I understand that it is possible to block SSL by IP address. However, it is also possible to send anything down the same tunnel; but you can't inspect the actual packets to see if they are clean. Some filters perform a MITM, but I think we can agree that is a terrible idea. Browser based filtering lets you filter any site based on its contents and also maintain the security of the data. It also avoids domain level blocks that block other sites by accident.
- hipsters_unite 13y agoThis is pretty much what Peter Sunde was getting at with this talk I think [0]. I agree though, I ended up having an argument with my parents on this subject. My old man's been working with software for goodness knows how long and he still doesn't really see it, so I think maybe it's more that some people implicitly trust and support the status quo. > and should I lose, I will simply leave this country and it's countrymen. the EU convention lists internet access as a human right. This. I really believe that together we're stronger. For all its (many many) failings, the EU is just a political confluence in the same way as the internet at its best is a social confluence, and if the country of my birth lets me down then I'll move to the continent and leave the Little Englanders behind. [0] http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2013-11/18/peter-sunde-hemlis-political-apathy http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2013-11/18/peter-sunde-h...