3 ms·
If you wanted to help people with low incomes, you'd do two things: 1) More skill based education, enabling them to upgrade out of their low paying, low skill
by adventured 13y ago
If you wanted to help people with low incomes, you'd do two things:
1) More skill based education, enabling them to upgrade out of their low paying, low skill jobs
2) Make it dramatically less expensive and easier to employ people, lower regulations (rather than adding thousands of new regulations per year), simplify compliance, simplify healthcare dramatically, and overall stop providing huge disincentives to hiring
The only tax that poor pay is sales tax. The bottom 40% pay a negative income tax rate. We could attempt to kick the sales tax back to them, but it wouldn't make even remotely as big a dent as improving the macro economic environment.
We should also become fiscally responsible and stop destroying the poor's standard of living through inflation. Inflation harms the poorest the most, by far.
And I don't mean the bogus CPI, which was substantially adjusted to mask inflation under Clinton's presidency. I'm talking about the massive inflation in: energy, housing & rent, food, education, health care. The cost of a new car has gone up by 50% in 20 years, while we're selling less of them (relative slack demand). The cost of milk & eggs has doubled in 15 years. The cost of a house has doubled in 15 years. Meanwhile, we have 14% real unemployment, with no justification for the massive increases in prices on the demand side (ie it's primarily driven by the Fed's massive devaluation of the dollar, with QE being used to avoid bankruptcy at the federal level; aka the poor are being papered to death in the process of masking our nation's fiscal irresponsibility).
- yetanotherphd 13y agoI'm talking about policies that might be thought of as tradeoffs: raising the minimum wage vs lowering taxes (for people on low incomes) or raising benefits. What you are talking about is policies that (you claim) would benefit the economy in general and should be done regardless of how we deal with people who are currently on low incomes. And inflation does not harm people's standard of living because real wages will rise or fall depending on the market. Inflation has some short term effects, but if nominal wages remained stagnant (which they haven't), that would be because the value of labor went down, not because of inflation.
- drabiega 13y ago>Inflation harms the poorest the most, by far. I don't think that word means what you think it means. When prices go up, so does income. It has to because there are two sides to every economic transaction. Inflation often seems to coincide with declines in the real median wage because it's easier for your employer to not give you a raise instead than it is to reduce your salary. But over time it doesn't matter because even with no inflation if there's real wage decline you still have the same problem.
- adventured 13y agoWhy yes, that word does mean what I think it does. If we're talking about what inflation is, well, prices going up is not inflation to begin with. The expansion of the money supply is inflation. Prices going up is merely a potential symptom of inflation. Inflation does in fact harm the poor dramatically more so than anybody else. They're the most susceptible to rising prices, their incomes rise the slowest, and they have no capital or assets to leverage to keep pace with inflation through hedges (such as stocks, gold, commodities in general, housing, etc). Incomes do not inherently go up hand in hand with prices. In fact it's the exact opposite, the greater the inflation the less able incomes are to keep pace. America is dramatic proof of that over the last 40 years, as the cost of major goods such as housing, education and healthcare have vastly outstripped gains in income. Your theory that wages inherently keep up with inflation assumes that there are no spin-off consequences to inflation, that's blatantly not correct. It generates a downward spiral, cascade effect; just ask Argentina how that works, their economy has been getting hammered by it the last few years. As you expand the money supply, devalue your currency and generate inflation, all sorts of costs from external sources begin to climb, such as the cost of imports (raw goods like plastic or steel, completed goods like toasters, commodities etc). This one effect alone guarantees domestic wages can never keep pace with inflation. Inflation also destroys savings, and the poor always have the smallest base of savings to begin with, and are least able to shift their savings into higher yielding investments. There are numerous recent examples from around the world where inflation outstrips wage gains. Brazil is an obvious recent example of it, the cost of goods in Brazil is outrageous, and was one of the reasons for their recent riots. The high inflation there, requiring incredible interest rates to fight, has far outstripped their wage gains. Venezuela and Argentina are two other recent examples of it. And there are extreme examples of it, in which the people of a country have been wiped out by inflated prices while their incomes did not keep up (Zimbabwe is an easy example of that).