4 ms·
Rather than worrying about raising prices or cutting the number of employees, what about if the burger joint just made less profit? McDonald's could double wag
by grecy 13y ago
Rather than worrying about raising prices or cutting the number of employees, what about if the burger joint just made less profit?
McDonald's could double wages and it's operating profit would still be $5.5Billion. What's wrong with $5.5billion in profit?
http://www.businessinsider.com/mcdonalds-could-double-wages-for-employees-and-make-less-money-2013-7#ixzz2aZHNwoL5 http://www.businessinsider.com/mcdonalds-could-double-wages-...
- Domenic_S 13y agoRead the article. One effect of raising wages would be that McDonald's would then have access to a larger pool of labor (people who would not work there at $7/hr but absolutely would for $15/hr). As a result, the poorest & least skilled labor may not benefit at all from a raise in wage, rather, they'd be priced out completely because of a huge influx of "better" workers.
- drabiega 13y agoThey said this in the article, but it doesn't make any more sense here than it did there. If unemployment remains the same, where are these 'better' workers coming from?
- thecage411 13y agoOne possibility: unemployment is defined as someone who is not working AND actively looking. If wages at McD went up to $15 an hour, some people who were not actively looking may enter the workforce.
- drabiega 13y agoThat is certainly true. However, if I had said 'employment is not decreasing' instead of 'unemployment is not increasing' it would still have been a valid critique without being vulnerable to that response, however.
- thecage411 13y agoYep. FYI economists use the term "labor force participation rate" for this concept.
- adventured 13y agoWhat's wrong with firing 50% of employees and automating their jobs with robotics over the next dozen years and boosting profits to $20 billion? In the case of McDonald's: absolutely nothing, it's a business, it exists to generate a profit. That is its purpose, to optimize returns. Others may choose a different path, non-profit for example, or low-profit (eg Costco). There is nothing inherently wrong with either path. If McDonald's makes the wrong choice, then they open themselves up to a very large market of competition to hammer them. The problem the labor of McDonald's has is simple: their customers will not care whether a person or a robot makes the burgers, so long as they taste the same and are inexpensive. This problem will never go away, and the robotics revolution will ensure the obvious outcome.
- the_watcher 13y ago>> are inexpensive Low costs are critical to this piece.
- adventured 13y agoI definitely agree. Nurses and teachers in Germany and France are happy if they make $30,000 per year. I think $30,000 burger flippers, fry cooks, and order takers, that come with all the complications of human labor, will be mostly easy to replace at a fraction of that cost. The fast food workers have completely lost perspective on what their labor is worth. A very popular convenience store chain on the east coast, called Sheetz, has been running the order taking of their very successful food business (where they make all of their money), strictly with touch screen order kiosks for nearly 20 years. McDonald's could eliminate, what, four or five order taking employees with a simple change. No way they keep order takers at $30k per year. That's just one simple example of course.
- brc 13y agoIf I were an investor in McDonalds, I would certainly wonder why the profit lowered. Headline billion-dollar profits sound impressive, but are meaningless until you see how much capital has been employed. It's all very well to say they should halve their profit, but if that then meant that the returns for the company fell below what is expected from the sector, there will be other flow-on effects, such as a falling company value, difficulty in raising further capital if required, and other problems. I would turn the question around - what's wrong with a $11b profit? The duty of the McDonalds management is to increase returns for the shareholders, not to run a make-work business.
- georgemcbay 13y ago> I would turn the question around - what's wrong with a $11b profit? Nothing, by itself, but in the case of McDonalds, Walmart and others who make massive use of minimum wage workers that profit is heavily subsidized by all of us as taxpayers since by holding on to that money and not sharing it with the employees we (taxpayers) now need to help fill the gap created between the cost of living and what those corporations are paying the majority of their workers.
- the_watcher 13y agoWhy is McDonald's obligated to take in less profit? It has actual, not utopian, obligations to its owners (shareholders)
- drabiega 13y agoWhat about it's obligations to the taxpayers it is soaking?
- the_watcher 13y agoWhat taxpayers is it soaking by not taking in less profit?
- drabiega 13y agoThe tax payers who have to supplement the sub-living wages?
- Zhenya 13y agoIf you think they should make less profit and "give back" more to the tax payers - thats called TAXATION. Change the laws and you can take their profit down to zero. Horray!
- drabiega 13y agoNot forcing tax payers to foot the bill for McDonald's labor is taxation?
- Zhenya 13y agoAnd how do you propose that we force McDonalds to "foot" the bill for their labor other than taxation? Minimum wage increase? That's a short term fix until McDonalds lowers their new high expense with automation.
- drabiega 13y agoIf you keep minimum wage in line with living wage, you get the jobs that are worth doing. If the taxpayer has to kick in money to make the jobs live-able, we'd literally be better off just giving people money.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoThis cuts to the core of the ethics of the free market. It is more ethical for McDonalds to make a higher profit, and pay lower wages, if they can. This is because they have an agreement (and I don't care about the precise legal nature of this agreement) with the shareholders to maximize the profit of the company. The employees on the other hand, they never made any promises to. Employees have a relationship with the company as long as they are willing to take the wages/conditions on offer. You might think that it is ethical for McDonalds to redistribute money from their shareholders to their workers (and their workers are surely poorer on average). But this is solely the role of the government, and private charity. I can't prove this properly in a single post, but it is closely related to the First and Second Welfare Theorems.
- grecy 13y ago> This cuts to the core of the ethics of the free market. I know, that's why I left it as an open question. > They have an agreement with the shareholders to maximize the profit of the company. It's fascinating we let that agreement trump the implicit agreement they have with all humans on earth. > You might think that it is ethical for McDonalds to redistribute money from their shareholders to their workers (and their workers are surely poorer on average). But this is solely the role of the government, and private charity This is how the system currently functions, but I strongly believe the system needs to (and must) change. For a business to purely be concerned with profit can only lead to destruction for all of us. They'll bleed workers dry, kill the planet and be happy doing it.
- yetanotherphd 13y ago>This is how the system currently functions It's also the system that makes the most theoretical sense given the First and Second Welfare Theorems, which state (or more accurately strongly imply) that any desired outcome can be achieved by the free market, and government redistribution. "killing the planet" is an externality that can be addressed by environmental legislation (e.g. a carbon tax).
- 13y ago