12 ms·
It is profitable. If terrorists disappeared tomorrow. Let's say we use our surgical strike weapons to target every cell every member, and in one hour they are
by rdtsc 13y ago
It is profitable.
If terrorists disappeared tomorrow. Let's say we use our surgical strike weapons to target every cell every member, and in one hour they are gone. What would happen? Billions of dollars disappear from the pockets of everyone in the chain. Military contractors, drone maintenance, promotions, bonuses, career advancements, no more completed missions, medals, no job to go to.
So the direct financial and career incentive for everyone in the chain is to always make sure there is a stream of new terrorists, new cells, new intelligence chatter about "the Great Satan". And that is indirectly accomplished by indiscriminately bombing civilians. Everyone who is involved in picking the target and knows it is a funeral, will know civilians will die. I can't help but think they also know it is job insurance as well. They would be stupid not to.
American public via media has been tested enough during releases of so many atrocities, torture tapes, lies, monitoring that by now, I think they've built an accurate model of how much outrage will be generated and how much will actually threaten future operations, funding, reelection and so on (so far not much).
The bottom line, I don't even know and 100% believe them when they say these are all "mistakes". The incentives and the motivation, especially in the long term, is for them not to really care if civilians get bombed.
- frogpelt 13y agoLet me guess, you think there's a cure for cancer but the doctors are withholding it and Exxon Mobil bought the patent for a combustion engine that would achieve 100+ mpg. Any industry that is built on addressing problems that people naturally have is going to generate lots of revenue. It has been proven that people naturally fight with each other. People fight over race, religion, sports, politics, and territory. Nations do the same thing. If you think it would end terrorism by killing all current terrorists and if you think it would even be possible, I think you're misguided.
- dalore 13y agoLet me guess, you said something similar to all the people that said the NSA were tracking everyone.
- mikeash 13y agoThey laughed at Einstein[0] but they also laughed at Bozo the Clown. The truth of one conspiracy cannot be used as evidence for the truth of others. It simply doesn't make sense. [0] They didn't really laugh at Einstein, but you get the idea.
- a1a 13y agoThe metaphor in your argument is dependent on the fact that Einstein and Bozo are two separate entities. Once Einstein[0] had published his theory of relativity people stopped laughing, and they never laughed at him again. [0] They still didn't laugh at Einstein, but you get the idea.
- mikeash 13y agoHmm, now that is really interesting! My initial reaction to your question is, "Of course they're separate entities." But then the person I'm replying to probably thinks, "Of course they're a single entity." Is that the true division between conspiracy-minded people and others?
- a1a 13y agoI don't agree with rdtsc's either, and I am not "conspiracy-minded" just because I point out that your einstein-clown argument is fallacious. Therefore I would not like to draw that line. I would however say it's a division between our views. I do believe that a government can be considered a single entity. Care to explain why you disagree?
- mikeash 13y agoThe government is a collection of a lot of different entities with different views, resources, and goals. It doesn't make sense to me to say that e.g. the FDA and the NSA are part of the same entity. Furthermore, what's being discussed involves non-government actors too. Exxon, doctors, and defense contractors are entities outside the government.
- csmuk 13y agoI worked for defence companies in the past. There are no morals and ethics. Just profit and plunder. The parent of your post is spot on.
- quantumpotato_ 13y ago"I worked for war companies in the past"
- csmuk 13y agoExactly that. And I'm fucking ashamed of myself for doing it, unlike the other 132000 employees who still work there. I was naive to the point of being stupid.
- lolbertarian 13y agoThank you for having the integrity to not try to justify the time you spent and the money you made by enabling these madmen. I admire your intellectual honesty, you don't see it very often when it comes to criticizing one's own actions.
- bluecalm 13y agoIt doesn't matter what he or you think is likely happening right now. The fact is there is a conflict of incentives and in such situations people act according to the ones the closest to their personal ones. We can't expect people to be heroes against their own personal interest. It won't change until people in the chain have incentives to avoid war. Now let's think how to accomplish it: maybe there should be huge tax on profits for military contractors in the time when operations are going ? Maybe private for-profit military contractors have to go in the first place ? Maybe we shouldn't pay them for every piece of equipment but only for time spent working ? As to people in the field, there are some ideas as well like freezing all bonuses during the military operations and such. The thing is it has to be profitable for individuals involved to seek peace not war. The war machine is never going to stop otherwise. The balance should be such that once high command in charge feel it's necessary to start military operations they should meet at least some resistance from rest of the chain not "fuck yeah sir!" as it is now.
- refurb 13y agoI have to agree. Someone out there benefits from every single bad thing that happens out there: securities fraud, child abuse, cancer, money laundering, murder, etc, etc. Using the same logic, nothing should ever get better because those who benefit from "bad things" will never allow them to be stopped.
- rescripting 13y ago> Using the same logic, nothing should ever get better because those who benefit from "bad things" will never allow them to be stopped. Thats not true because it ignores existing structures of power. A common thief benefits from the bad things they do, but has no power to influence those that might seek to stop him, and so is convicted. A banker who committed fraud (read: stole) during the recent financial crisis has the power of capital and lobby behind them, and walks. The existing structures of power in place are actually designed to stop many of the bad things you describe, however there is nothing intrinsically moral about them so they can be corrupted by capital and lobbyists.
- guptaneil 13y agoThe difference is, in the OP's argument, the people whose job it is to stop these bad things are also the ones who are benefitting from it. Normally, it is the police's job to stop child abuse. However, if the police force happens to be running the child abuse ring, they are not going to do anything to stop it themselves. In such a situation, there is no incentive for these things to stop. (Note: I'm not convinced war profiteering is the driving motivator for the NSA, just pointing out the fallacy in your argument.)
- refurb 13y agoSure it still work... let's look at my list: securities fraud - all those jobs at the SEC would disappear if they ended securities fraud, therefore they must not really want to stop it child abuse - the cops, social workers and judges would lose their jobs if child abuse stopped, therefore they must not really want to stop it cancer - oncologists would have no job if cancer was cured, therefore they must not really want to stop it money laundering - DOJ would lose their jobs if there was no money laundering, therefore they must not really want to stop it murder - cops would lose their jobs if there was no murder, therefore they must not really want to stop it And you can't say those people I noted above are not a part of the power structure...
- hindsightbias 13y agoIt's all about capabilities. Back in the 80's and 90's, people who insisted the NSA did all this or that really couldn't explain how the technology would work to do all that. People insisted spy satellites could read my newspaper, yada yada. About 5 years ago, the chips, scale-out HW, storage and Linux (thanks submitters!) reached the point where the known daily capacity of information stream or their meta could be stored by someone like the NSA or Google. One just needs to assume technical capabilities is what defines reality.
- bediger4000 13y agoUsenet, before Sept 1993, carried the rumor that "the CIA" was archiving all Usenet posts. I don't think that was too off-the-wall, even in 1988 or '89. I can recall, although not google up, at least one back-of-the-envelope effort to figure out if some organization could store all internet traffic. I think the answer was "yes", and this was done maybe 5 years ago.
- yodsanklai 13y ago"Any industry that is built on addressing problems that people naturally have is going to generate lots of revenue." And in the meantime, if they can make people think they have those problems, that would be even more revenue. Like the pharmaceutical industry that sell you drugs for diseases you didn't even know existed. Or cigarettes manufacturers that want to solve your problem of not being addicted to nicotine...
- cscurmudgeon 13y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. You have made these accusations without any evidence. Be responsible and ethical and show us something real, if you have it. (note: I am not taking sides.)
- bunderbunder 13y agoThere's really nothing extraordinary here; it's just boring old business-as-usual American politics. Consider reactions to the idea that we cancel the Joint Strike Fighter program. Long story short, every politician who had a contractor working on the project in his constituency started making noise about all the jobs that would be lost if we were to shut down the program. No secret conspiracy; that was an open debate that happened in the public sector, and which many Americans were talking about over dinner. Even the actual influencing of decisions to engage in hostilities is so everyday as to be unremarkable. For example, the big defense contractors spent a whole lot of money lobbying members of Congress to convince them that the 2009 Afghanisatan surge was a good idea. I think some wonks wrote columns about it in Foreign Policy magazine, but otherwise the news was barely even noticed. As for how that leads to a sort of "continuous warfare" policy where we're always on the lookout for new enemies. . . I think that just emerges. If you've spending billions and billions of dollars of taxpayer money on some new toy, then at some point someone's going to start asking why. And of course if your job is tied to a project, the very last thing you're going to say is, "No reason, actually this is a pretty silly lark if you ask me." So folks start coming up with hypothetical adversaries, and starts inventing war games and conducting exercises built around these hypotheses. And things just sort of roll along from there.
- cscurmudgeon 13y agoWe know that people go after profits. Nothing extraordinary here. What is extraordinary is the assertion that people acted unethically and (probably) also illegally.
- willvarfar 13y agoWhat part is illegal?
- mattlutze 13y agoI will continue to refuse to believe American military personnel choose to strike otherwise-collateral civilian targets. You're talking about moral humans, here. Our soldiers/airmen/marines/sailors are not soulless automatons, nor are officers that develop strategy and provide direction. Nor would I consider their pay to be either incentive or motivation.
- brazzy 13y agoYou must have been very busy ignoring a lot of evidence then. Not that that's unusual.
- gaius 13y agoThey didn't choose to strike civilian targets. They played Xbox, high-fived then went home to their nice lives. That is why drone warfare is so terrifying. It makes evil into something banal.
- pygy_ 13y ago> You're talking about moral humans, here. I'm sorry to break it to you, but there are immoral individuals in the US army, especially in the high ranks (where sociopath usually meet), like everywhere else.
- lostlogin 13y agoWhat does your first sentence mean? Otherwise-collateral civilian targets? Let's say for arguments sake that no civilians were intentionally targeted. Why is it ok to kill civilians at all? And what civilian death rate is acceptable to you?
- FedRegister 13y agoThen you're a fool. Operation Northwoods[1] talked about killing American civilians on American soil. It had the backing of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the CIA, and the Secretary of Defense. So let's not think that there isn't precedent. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Northwoods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Northwoods
- 13y ago
- mseebach 13y ago> Military contractors, drone maintenance, promotions, bonuses, career advancements, no more completed missions, medals, no job to go to. You forgot the one group of people who could actually stop this, literally overnight: Politicians.
- willvarfar 13y agoAren't they in the pocket, though?
- mseebach 13y agoThey might be, but that doesn't change the fact that they have the full legal power to pull the plug on this and that nobody else on the list has that.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoYou realize that the fiction of a coherent "Military Industrial Complex" has been debunked several times right? One by the General Accounting Office showed that military contractors actually had higher profits in peacetime than wartime because they got money for 'research' and didn't have to actually produce any product.
- d23 13y agoNo, I didn't realize that. But if you have some credible sources, I'd love to read it.
- diydsp 13y agoIt doesn't require coherent, self-identification to exist. It doesn't need to make more profits during wartime than in peacetime to exist. It only needs to have multiple actors whose interests align to produce more military funding and hardware than is needed to defend the nation.
- typon 13y agoThat sounds extremely unlikely. Most research projects don't get hundreds of millions of dollars of funding, while a single F-22 costs upwards of $150 million.
- nekopa 13y agoThe total program cost of the F22 is $66 billion. On a Pentagon spending request site they put the per unit cost as $354 million if you include R&D and procurement costs. So maybe it's more likely than you might think.
- wutbrodo 13y agoNot that I necessarily buy in to the idea of "a coherent Military-Industrial Complex", but this doesn't really debunk much. It seems to me that peacetime profits for military contractors are dependent on the assumption that there's going to be wartime usage of the research they're doing in the short- to medium-term. Surely if we went a significant period without any military engagements, there would be far less of a push to fund the research of military contractors (I know that military research tends to make it into the consumer sphere and make us all better off, but that's definitely not what motivates the funding).
- meowface 13y agoI think you are greatly overestimating the US military's competence.