3 ms·
If both Mozilla and Google (alongside H.264, but still) are willing to support Ogg, why didn't they just go with Ogg? Since Firefox has the largest market share
by w1ntermute 17y ago
If both Mozilla and Google (alongside H.264, but still) are willing to support Ogg, why didn't they just go with Ogg? Since Firefox has the largest market share of the <video>-supporting browsers and Google is running YouTube, there should be enough Ogg support for it to win. Why is Apple's opinion even relevant? Safari's market share certainly isn't large enough to make a big difference.
Moreover, the efficiency concerns regarding Ogg will be solved in the future, so that shouldn't be a concern in the long run (which is what this standard is for).
- ubernostrum 17y ago"Safari's market share certainly isn't large enough to make a big difference." Sigh. Please read this: http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2006/05/13/cluster_effects.html http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2006/05/13/cluster... If you're too busy to read it, a good summary applied to this situation would be that small-market browsers do indeed matter if they're being used by the sorts of critical early-adopter/well-connected people who make or break your service through their social connections. And remember that Safari is on every single iPhone out there, and so is the mobile browser used by lots and lots of those people.
- w1ntermute 17y ago"small-market browsers do indeed matter if they're being used by the sorts of critical early-adopter/well-connected people who make or break your service through their social connections. And remember that Safari is on every single iPhone out there, and so is the mobile browser used by lots and lots of those people." I still don't feel that this even comes close to matching the massive impact that Firefox has. It is also popular among early adopters, and were Ogg to be made the standard and implemented on YouTube as the sole <video> codec, I think it would be possible to force Apple's hand on the issue.
- ubernostrum 17y ago"I still don't feel that this even comes close to matching the massive impact that Firefox has." The question is not "is X bigger than Y". You have to stop thinking in those terms if you want a successful service built on social networking effects. You simply cannot afford to lock people out, period. "were Ogg to be made the standard and implemented on YouTube as the sole <video> codec, I think it would be possible to force Apple's hand on the issue." No, it wouldn't, because YouTube is run by people smart enough to realize that punishing millions of users to try to stick it to one of your business partners is not a good plan. And even if they went Theora-only (which they're not going to do), they'd have to provide a fallback for IE, which would probably end up extended to Safari as well.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoubernostrum: "And even if they went Theora-only (which they're not going to do), they'd have to provide a fallback for IE, which would probably end up extended to Safari as well." I'm not bothered about the actual format shipped, let the market sort that out. What I want is to be able to publish a webpage with a video and know that all standards compliant browsers will play that media. Safari doesn't have to only use Ogg Theora, YouTube doesn't have to stop using flash. Keeping the openness of the web means allowing content creators a path to create content unencumbered by license disputes IMO. They should go back and specify it for HTML5 standard compliance and let Safari fail compliance.
- ubernostrum 17y ago"What I want is to be able to publish a webpage with a video and know that all standards compliant browsers will play that media." Your proposed remedy does not accomplish this. Putting language in the spec and "letting" browsers "fail compliance" leaves you in the same situation as not putting language in the spec.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoWell all compliant browsers will play the media, by definition, so the remedy is effective. Safari wouldn't fail compliance they'd suddenly find the time to implement Ogg Theora as a fall back and if they've any sense the chip manufacturers would be falling over themselves to offer an optimised stack to court Apple.
- rimantas 17y agoAnd remember, that Apple can use chips for decoding h.264 on iPhone and iPod Touch. That matters a lot.
- Create 17y agoWhy is Apple's opinion even relevant? Eric E. Schmidt. Going MPEG LA, doing evil?