5 ms·
I highly recommend The China Study for a more detailed, epidemiological study of nutrition.
by grandalf 17y ago
I highly recommend The China Study for a more detailed, epidemiological study of nutrition.
- kingkongrevenge 17y agoIt's pretty well dismantled. http://www.cholesterol-and-health.com/China-Study.html http://www.cholesterol-and-health.com/China-Study.html http://www.thegreatcholesterolcon.com/The_China_Study.html http://www.thegreatcholesterolcon.com/The_China_Study.html
- grandalf 17y agoI suppose so, if you consider some random people's blogs authoritative. I thought this was HN and not Reddit :) These are blogs written by people who are promoting a high cholesterol diet -- hmm, ever notice that there is lots of money in promoting nutrition advice that confirms to what people are currently already doing?
- jshen 17y agopeer reviewed science being "dismantled" by some dude's blog. LOL
- kingkongrevenge 17y agoThe china study book is just "some dude's book." It is not peer reviewed. Some of the underlying study is, but most of the conclusions expressed in the book are not a product of peer review.
- Devilboy 17y agoThis china study 'dude' is a well respected scientist. That blog author is not.
- kingkongrevenge 17y agoDid you miss the part where he blatantly misrepresents research? The writer irrelevant. Utter your soothing "well respected scientist" mantra all you want. You can look at the abstracts yourself that show campbell's misrepresentations.
- jshen 17y agocare to give an example?
- fatdog789 17y agoYes I did. Campbell did not misrepresent anything; abstracts are highly condensed summations written by someone else who may or may not have the background necessary to fully convey the underlying research. Poorly written abstracts are the leading cause of sensationalist headlines.
- jshen 17y agoThe "China study" referred to in the title is the China Project, a study comparing diet, lifestyle and disease chacteristics in sixty five counties in rural China in the 1970's and 1980's conducted jointly by Cornell University, Oxford University, and the Chinese Academy of Preventive Medicine T. Colin Campbell, Ph.D. has been at the forefront of nutrition research. His legacy, the China Study, is the most comprehensive study of health and nutrition ever conducted. Dr. Campbell is the Jacob Gould Schurman Professor Emeritus of Nutritional Biochemistry at Cornell University and Project Director of the China-Oxford-Cornell Diet and Health Project. Dr. Campbell received his master’s degree and Ph.D. from Cornell, and served as a Research Associate at MIT. He spent 10 years on the faculty of Virginia Tech’s Department of Biochemistry and Nutrition before returning to the Division of Nutritional Sciences at Cornell in 1975 where he presently holds his Endowed Chair (now Emeritus).
- zngtk4 17y agoOn the other hand, as I explain above, epidemiological studies are essentially useless for anything other than formulating hypotheses (see the debacle with hormone replacement therapy). It baffles me that anyone would entirely change their diet and lifestyle based on an epidemiological study.
- Tichy 17y agoSo how could they overlook the effects of the hormone treatment if they studied so many women? Shouldn't there be some statistical observations?
- zngtk4 17y agoAbsolutely, and the observations suggested that hormone treatment was possibly even beneficial. That's why it's completely true that correlation != causation. You can try to "control" for differences in the observed groups, and epidemiologists try this all the time, but unless they already understand everything involved, it's impossible to get this completely right. And sometimes the things they try to control for are themselves based on other epidemiological studies. This is the main reason we are always hearing in the press about how a "study shows that X is bad for us" then a "study shows that X is good for us". The majority of the time when there are such conflicting studies, it is the result of epidemiology or poorly controlled studies.
- Tichy 17y agoSo there was some other factor that by chance made the hormones benefitial for the women in the study? Or all the women somehow where more healthy than "normal" women to begin with? How does that happen? And how could one control for it, wouldn't you need thousands of identical twins?
- grandalf 17y agoThe evidence is not just from the epidemiological study, there have been lots of follow-up studies to examine the processes in detail. I would argue that a broad, epidemiological study is the most persuasive sort of evidence to use when considering whether to make drastic changes. Otherwise you're dealing with information like "omega 3s prevent x, y, and z" so you end up taking an Omega 3 supplement along with the dozen other supplements while eating Wendy's for lunch every day. Thinking that health can be understood on the basis of "taking supplement x is good" is the root of the current supplement gold rush (people sell tons of snake oil substances that contain "omega 3's" etc.) and a highly irrational way to behave.