4 ms·
These size comparisons always seem strange to me. Uruguay has 3.3 million people, so they collect tax from that many to spend on important stuff like schools,
by grecy 13y ago
These size comparisons always seem strange to me.
Uruguay has 3.3 million people, so they collect tax from that many to spend on important stuff like schools, firemen and healthcare.
The US has 310 million people, so they collect tax from that many to spend on important stuff like schools, firemen and healthcare.
The fact that the US has more people to collect taxes from means it's spendings pot is obviously much bigger, but that absolutely does not mean it can be wasted on "trappings" for the leaders. Each and every person still needs all the basic services, so at the end of the day, there is the same basic amount per person to spend.
Why do you think that a country with more taxpayers has more money for "trappings"?
- bpodgursky 13y agoI agree with you on stuff like schools, firemen, and healthcare. But it's a different calculation for a head of state. When 300mm people look to an individual as a leader (rather than 3mm people) there are 100x as many threats to their security via disgruntled citizens, crazy people, etc, so physical security has to scale. It's like saying, "why does the mayor of my town not need the same number of secret service as the president?" There are just far fewer things they feel the need to defend from.
- Of_Prometheus 13y agoThe comparison, then, should be with the governor of Oklahoma, who lives in the Governor's Mansion.[1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Fallin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Fallin
- Of_Prometheus 13y agoThe comparison, then, should be with the governor of Oklahoma, who lives in the Governor's Mansion.[1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Fallin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Fallin
- grecy 13y agoRather than spending money "defending" your leaders, wouldn't it be better if you addressed the issues and actually figured out why people want to cause harm to their leaders? You know, many developed countries don't even have a security force for their leaders, and for example, the ex-Prime Minister of Australia went jogging all the time by himself, in whatever city he happens to be in.
- true_religion 13y agoPerhaps it is as simple has having more enemies because you have more citizens under your rule as a bigger country. after all no president has been assassinated by a foreign plot.
- mynameishere 13y agofigured out why people want to cause harm to their leaders Here's why people try to assassinate politicians: #1 They're nuts (Hinkley, Czolgosz, Squeaky Fromme). #2 They have some reason for doing so (Gavrilo Princip, Booth, probably Oswald). There. Figured it out. As it happens, there are probably 100x as many nuts in the US as Uruguay, and probably 10,000,000 times more possible motives to kill the head of state/head of government/commander in chief/international celebrity who holds the US's highest office. Now you try and fix those two things.
- grecy 13y ago> Now you try and fix those two things. You mean with care for the mentally ill, etc. like in developed countries?
- beachwood23 13y agoSo you want to lock up any person who shows the slightest sign of instability?
- grecy 13y agoI said care, not incarceration. I want to treat them, give them access to professional help - you know, care for them.
- walshemj 13y agoyou missed #3 as part of a coup attempt - which unfortunately South America has had a lot of.
- mikeyouse 13y agoWhy do you think that a country with more taxpayers has more money for "trappings"? "The trappings" are essentially a fixed cost at any scale of country. Let's say you need a palace, a security detail, a motorcade, and a jet to have all of "the trappings" for the ruling family. If you assign some costs to these things, say $500k/yr for the palace, $1mm/yr for security, $500k/yr for motorcade, and $10mm/yr for the jet, you can figure out the annual cost -- $12mm/year in this example. So in a country with only 3.3 million people, that's $3.60/citizen/year for the ruling family to have their trappings. In a country with 310 million people, that would only be $0.038/citizen/year. Even if you need more security, or a bigger motorcade, or a more expensive plane, you're still on the magnitude of pennies/person/year instead of dollars/person/year.
- ricardobeat 13y agoThe size of the government is proportional to the population. Those costs are not fixed at all. Anyway, you're missing the point. He doesn't have all of this by choice, not because Uruguay can't pay for it.
- claudius 13y agoThe size of the head of state is rather constant, and that is the only size discussed here – of course the underlying bureaucracy grows larger in larger countries, but that doesn’t mean the president can suddenly be in two jets at the same time.
- Xylakant 13y agoSure, the president can't. But since the size of the country is much larger, there's the governors and mayors of large cities which govern about as many people as the head of Uruguay and I'm fairly certain that each of those has a "palace" about as big as the presidential palace in Uruguay, a motorcade, a security detail larger than 2 armed guards and neither of them showed up on a vespa after elected or - for that matter - any time at all.
- mikeash 13y agoThe size of your surplus will depend on the size of your country. Let's say that a country can afford 0.01% of GDP (number pulled out of nether regions) for Presidential luxuries. That would mean that the US can spend about $1.5 billion/year on Presidential motorcades and airplanes and housing and so forth, while Uruguay could spend about $4.9 million. It's a vast difference. While scale doesn't really matter for stuff like schools, firemen, and health care, it does matter here, because the President doesn't scale. It's one guy no matter how big and rich the country is, and if it's bigger and richer, then there's more to spend on that one guy.