3 ms·
So what... apply a highly reflective coating to your drones/shells and that thing is worthless.
by doliork 13y ago
So what... apply a highly reflective coating to your drones/shells and that thing is worthless.
- breischl 13y agoAnd bullets can be stopped by vests, or tank armor, or a sandbag, so we might as well just stop using those as well. It ups the ante for anyone that wants to fight the US. That's really the point. And I'm guessing that making your drones highly reflective reduces their stealth a bit.
- ZanyProgrammer 13y agoAlso, if hit by enough lasers, would the reflective coating remain effective?
- XorNot 13y agoTry firing a shell with a reflective coating that doesn't get dirty, or outright destroyed, by the firing process. One problem with lasers is that you have to keep their optics very clean because dirt becomes a heat absorber, which then deforms the optics, which then absorbs more heat... You might be able to make it work with a missile, but it wouldn't be easy, and any such coating would require high technology to make and have to be actively maintained - can't fire dirty rounds. So, beyond the capability of militias, even if someone was supplying them with silvered rounds that worked. And while you could definitely silver a drone, the problem is a drone isn't ordnance - you can just keep lasing it all day long till something fails or you hit a weak point (like the camera optics on the drone, which by definition terminate on an absorptive surface).
- doliork 13y agoBullets, shells sure, that might be a problem. But as for drones: If you know there is such a laser defence system, dispatch one or two silver drones (which maybe high in maintenance) destroy it. Then send the normal drones.
- XorNot 13y agoBut again: it assumes you can build a drone which wouldn't be killed by the laser system. Even if you silver the drones, they're not going to reflect the laser back at it - they'll just scatter it away. But a drone is a complicated surface - you've got optics, flaps etc. on it. And a silvered drone would reflect the sun incredibly brightly - it would be the easiest LADAR or just optics target to find in the sky, which means you wouldn't need to hit it with radar and reveal your position to shoot at it - and if the camera optics look at the laser, they'll be destroyed instantly.
- 6d0debc071 13y agoMirrors aren't perfectly reflective, even if they deflect the majority of the energy for a fraction of a second, they will absorb some of it, scorching and becoming less shiny. You can use mirrors in laser optics because the beam is relatively diffuse at that end. I believe the best defence against a laser is likely to be a matter of having a material with a high vaporisation energy for its mass and to spin your projectile very fast so that the laser has difficulty maintaining a single point of contact. Or, you know, just fire your weapons in mass and hope to saturate their point defence systems. These things must cost like a million bucks each or something - mortar rounds must be pretty cheap. And war is, when you get down to it, an extension of logistics and thus to an extent of whether your system is cost effective.
- TsiCClawOfLight 13y agoThere is a cool calculation in response to the top comment :)