3 ms·
What does "science" mean in this context anyway? An astronomer, say, can work with vast, vast swaths of data but that doesn't make the astronomer a "data scient
by joe_the_user 13y ago
What does "science" mean in this context anyway? An astronomer, say, can work with vast, vast swaths of data but that doesn't make the astronomer a "data scientist". Statistics has some fairly generic tools but it doesn't seem to me these add up to science in the sense that fields like chemistry, biology, geology and physics are sciences.
My modest exposure to machine learning at the professional level gives me impression that the "real experts" combine a strong mathematical understanding, long experience and some good rules of thumb to perform better than a grad student shooting in the dark, if they happen to perform better.
Oddly enough, all articles about how hard it is to become a "real data scientist" gives the impression that however much expertise is involved, that expertise isn't the codified understanding that is "real science" - even a physics undergraduate does real physics because scientists, physics codified their methods.
Maybe "data science" can become science. But suspect that what will become scientific is the understand of whatever entity is producing the data. Which isn't to discount the learning of experts here but simply to note that compendiums of rules-of-thumb and feelings indicate what Thomas Kuhn might a pre-scientific field.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- stiff 13y agoI think a great many of astronomers were in fact "data scientists". For example, Kepler's life's work in the end amounts to finding the simplest possible model that could plausibly account for Tycho de Brahe's data. In fact, many of the most basic statistical modelling methods originated in the process of trying to find explanations for astronomical observations, like least squares: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Least_squares#History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Least_squares#History In one sense science is just the outcome of correctly applying the scientific method to a given problem, and in that sense data science is perhaps a meta-science, in that it focuses on the part of the scientific method concerned with making inferences from data, and tries to improve it's effectiveness, using process that is itself scientific to some degree (applying mathematical reasoning to find more reliable ways of inference, introducing additional empirical experiments like cross-validation into the inference process itself for confirmation). I think comparing physics to statistics is a categorical error, and at the same time it's worth keeping in mind that modern physics, biology and chemistry certainly rely very heavily on probability theory and mathematical statistics, so those disciplines always brought up as "properly scientific" are in many respects only rigorous to the extent statistics is.
- kyzyl 13y ago> I think a great many of astronomers were in fact "data scientists" I think the data component is a feature of applied physics in general. Physics problems have had a tendency to be extremely data driven, because when you're dealing with things out in the cosmos, or trying to model nuclear structure for the first time, or shed light on the Higgs mechanism, the data is all you have. You often can't see it with your eye, or a microscope. The effect you're observing only lasts a femtosecond, so you conceive of extremely fancy contraptions that measure the secondary effects en masse (if you'll allow the pun), and you end up with fantastically large data sets. That said, when I look at the scientists I knew/know, including astronomers, their solutions often take a different approach that what I see today in the "data science" blogosphere. There, the approach seems highly centered on scaling various methods to work with huge amounts of data, whereas most of scientists seem to do just the opposite. They go to great lengths--such as building massive integrating antennae the size of football fields--to make sure they collect precisely the correct data, and nothing more. They then take that data and apply the technique that they know must work, if their hypothesis is correct.
- gaius 13y agoIf data science was a real thing, then quants would consistently beat the market.