14 ms·
Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoUraguay is actually the second current nation to legalize this. North Korea being the first. Cannabis is not regulated as a drug at all in North Korea.
- Crito 13y agoFor anyone else wondering the same thing as I was, it seems this legality extends beyond just tourists, and marijuana is available too, so it's legality isn't just a technicality. Interesting stuff: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/08/marijuana-in-north-korea_n_4067341.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/08/marijuana-in-north-...
- shiven 13y agoIt may be self-regulating in a way. Could you imagine getting the munchies in a starving, dictatorial, failed nation-state. Already nothing to eat and now a drug that makes you crave food even more. No, thanks!
- Crito 13y agoOn the other hand, it's not like there is going to be much to watch on TV... Apparently alcohol is extremely popular in North Korea. Probably a better entertainment/hunger compromise.
- jpatokal 13y agoIt's not as straightforward as that. A followup from the original author of the blog post: http://www.thebohemianblog.com/2013/11/smoking-weed-in-north-korea-critical.html http://www.thebohemianblog.com/2013/11/smoking-weed-in-north...
- Crito 13y agoInteresting, thanks for the link.
- ddoolin 13y agoDid they legalize it in North Korea? I suppose not if it wasn't illegal to begin with. Possibly it was never illegal, or it could be a legal grey area.
- gclaramunt 13y agoMy bet is just a lab test for Monsanto's GM cannabis. We're already a big exporter of GM soy
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoThat's a big lab.
- WalterSear 13y agoGovernment weed has the Monsanto grandfather gene in it already.
- blah32497 13y agoI'm all for legalization, but my concern would be that now gangs will grow pot in Uruguay to export to neighboring countries. This may spark turf wars and the like... Given the limits on how much you can buy at have, hopefully they can still tackle large operations EDIT: Let me expand, because I think people are missing the point. There are drug gangs in the region that grow pot. After this law comes in to effect it suddenly becomes easier to do business in Uruguay. Wouldn't that be an incentive to move shop to Uruguay? It seems like if all the local countries don't sign up, then you're signing yourself up for trouble.
- Crito 13y agoVicente Fox, former president of Mexico, believes that legalization of marijuana in Mexico is the solution to the extreme cartel violence in Mexico. Of course while he was in office he was prohibitionist; my understanding is that he believes that faltering prohibition in America (primarily signaled by legalization in Colorado and Washington, and near de facto legalization in California) presents an opportunity to legalize in Mexico and choke out the cartels.
- almosnow 13y agoVicente Fox is a shareholder and the public image of one of the first 'entrepenurial' companies that plan to distribute marijuana at a major scale... So yeah, that argument is kind of: 'but George Clooney said that I should buy Nespresso!'
- Crito 13y agoThis would be the case if you completely ignore what he actually says. The merit of his arguments can be evaluated, we don't need to just judge his character. And of course he flat out admits that he would like to grow and sell it. That is no secret.
- r0s 13y agoTax and regulation will account for produced cannabis far better than the current black market. No different than alcohol. I think it's worth considering that legalization is the ethical choice. Irrational laws in neighboring countries shouldn't dictate all policy.
- chimeracoder 13y agoUntil today, the only places in the world where marijuana was legal are two states in the US (Colorado and Washington)[0], and the entire country of North Korea[1]. Other jurisdictions have decriminalized marijuana, but most of us haven't seen the legal sale of recreational marijuana in our lifetimes (in the US, it was all-but-illegal since 1937, and truly illegal since 1970 - there were only 6 months in 1969 during which there were technically no laws prohibiting its sale). These are exciting times we live in. [0] Technically these haven't gone into effect yet, but I'm still counting them. [1] Surprising, but (as far as we can tell) true. Less surprising when you consider that exports of drugs that need to be engineered (like methamphetamine) are one of North Korea's biggest sources of foreign currency.
- coldtea 13y agoWell, it was also legal to buy marijuana in Amsterdam coffee shops. Don't know if there was any legal technicallity behind it, but it was (is) as legal as you can get.
- chimeracoder 13y ago> Don't know if there was any legal technicallity behind it, but it was (is) as legal as you can get. It was not legal. They practice gedoogbeleid ("tolerance"). They agree that it is illegal but prosecutors rarely enforce the law, because they prioritize other crimes instead. In that sense, marijuana has been "legal" in Oakland's Measure Z clubs for a long time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oaksterdam,_Oakland#Measure_Z_clubs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oaksterdam,_Oakland#Measure_Z_... In both cases, sale to customers is tolerated, but sale to the coffeeshops (and growth/production) is illegal. Because wholesale growth and production are illegal, this setup lacks a key benefit of legalization: cutting off a major source of cash to organized crime syndicates and drug cartels. (This is the exact reason that the former president of Mexico, Vincente Fox, now supports legalization). Furthermore, in the Netherlands, coffeeshops have been dwindling in number in recent years, due to crackdowns, zoning regulations (oftentimes targeted at coffeeshops specifically), and other laws/policies that restrict the degree of "safe harbor" that such coffeshops have. (There was recently a proposal to ban sale to tourists; I believe it was due to go into effect recently, though it may have been delayed or reversed). As long as these businesses are forced to operate in a legal grey area (whether in the Netherlands or in the US), they cannot demonstrate the true potential of legalization.
- smtddr 13y agoI can't wait for the results of this to come out so I can use it in debates with people who are against legalization. I'm almost certain Uruguay will be better off for this. The resources involved in trying to suppress cannabis is ridiculous; especially for a substance that doesn't even do as much harm to society as some other things that are perfectly legal.
- pstuart 13y agoYou have Portugal as a reference already: http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/evaluating-drug-decriminalization-in-portugal-12-years-later-a-891060.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/evaluating-drug-d... Edit: yes decriminalization is not legalization. But whole point of illegality has ostensibly been to "protect people from themselves." This shows that it's not necessary.
- TylerE 13y agoThat's decrim, not legalization. Big difference.
- smtddr 13y agoAccording to the article that comment linked to; it's now on the same level as a parking-ticket for those growing it without proper registration or in possession of more than 10-days-worth. I can live with that very positive step in the right direction. Would put a huge dent in the War-On-Drugs cash-cow the USA criminal system is seriously milking. My main concern is pretty much the arrest, jailing and criminal-record that drugs causes. All that goes away if it's just a parking ticket.
- Crito 13y agoMany places in the US already have local decriminalized possession of reasonable quantities. Legalization, as seen in Colorado and Washington, should be interesting since it will shortly become possible to run a legitimate business with marijuana (as far as the states are concerned...).
- pstuart 13y agoIt feels like we're just about at the tipping point with cannabis. Once enough states in the US legalize it, the Feds will have to back down. The next step will be for people to wake up to the fact that harder drugs need to be legal too. Not so that more people can take them, but so we can have less crime and eliminate a key justification for the growing police state.
- tga_d 13y ago>Once enough states in the US legalize it, the Feds will have to back down. Or the federal government can just use it as a means to arrest pot-smoking undesirables at will? I don't really see how state laws come to a head with federal ones in this case - state police and lower will not enforce the federal laws, but FBI/DEA etc. can and probably will continue to. When it's a federal law granting someone a right (e.g. Roe v. Wade, the 14th amendment) then the federal government gets to go in and change state laws, but I've never heard of a case of federal laws changing because something it criminalizes was explicitly legalized in state laws. The most analogous historical precedent we have is prohibition, and iirc state laws didn't change until after the ratification of the 21st amendment, so that doesn't really apply. Unless you're saying that states would pass a constitutional amendment, which seems a little far fetched to me, though not impossible.
- cstejerean 13y agoLook at what is happening with gay marriage. It started changing at the state level, and once the public sentiment changed enough some of the previous federal restrictions are starting to fall as well. The same could (in theory) happen with marijuana if a critical mass of states begin to legalize.
- ojbyrne 13y agoExcellent point. Consensus seems to come at the state level. Another example that seems to be happening lately is reforming of mandatory sentencing/3 strikes laws.
- fiorix 13y agoI like the quote from Uruguai's president, José Mujica: We just regulated an existing market.
- alan_cx 13y agoThis for me is the whole point. Not only regulate, but tax too. I still cant get my head around the idea that government leaves regulation and profits to the black market. Its just makes no sense what so ever.
- cfontes 13y agoUruguai's president, José Mujica is a truly unique old man. He is a very interesting Character. I advise everybody to learn a bit about him and his way of leading the country. Put that aside I think that way of working one works on small Countries or Cities with small populations.
- ggambetta 13y agoI advise everybody not to stop at the current state-sponsored propaganda of Mujica as a wise old man; for completeness, also read about his colorful, shooting-cops-in-the-back-of-the-head, soviet-union-financed terrorist activities background, or the way education, everyday violence and society in general have gone to sh*t since he's in charge. He has almost single-handledly destroyed the country. This is the reason why I left three years ago; it got to a point I couldn't take it anymore. A lot of young, qualified people are running away for the same reasons. Even if the government changed overnight and started doing everything right, the damage they've done in the last 5-10 years will take generations to reverse :(
- thisiswrong 13y agoI hope you've settled somewhere with a more conservative gvt that has everyone's best interests at heart (sarcasm). Perhaps your new home is in the land of the free?
- ggambetta 13y agoMy new home is Zürich, and to be honest, it's pretty awesome.
- elohesra 13y agoHang on now, at no point did the parent comment state that he was looking for a more conservative government, nor did he state that there was anything politically wrong with Mujica. Instead he rebutted the homely, nice, old man image that was being presented of Mujica by pointing out the decidedly unpleasant things that Mujica has supposedly done (I can't comment on that; I know nothing of Mujica or his history). If the parent had said something along the lines of "Mujica is a commie, pinko bastard who loves the USSR!" and had stated that as the flaws with Mujica as a leader, then your rebuttal (as I rather charitably term it) would perhaps be more valid. But to launch into a not-so-subtle criticism of right-wing governments in response to the parents comment seems, frankly, like rather a non-sequitur. To preempt the inevitable comment that the parent had mentioned Mujica's "soviet-union-financed terrorist activities", and thus clearly had a problem with left-wing politics: the "soviet-union-financed" adjective seems rather less relevant than the "terrorist" adjective in both that sentence and the general theme of violent rule in the parent's post.
- thesimpsons1022 13y agosee weed is bad. it turns you into north korea.
- andyl 13y agoI've got addicts and alcoholics in my family. My cousin died from overdose. I've got close friends who killed themselves with drink. Lots of you do too. Exciting times? IMHO, the last thing we should celebrate is new ways to get a buzz on. There should be more discussion about how to minimize the incredible damage caused by drugs and alcohol.
- nested 13y agoNot everyone uses cannabis to get their "buzz on".
- r0s 13y agoFar more people die from overeating, where's that crusade?
- tedunangst 13y agoBloomberg was trying...
- pdwetz 13y agoWell, alcohol is a much more dangerous drug. As far as I know, there are no known fatalities from cannabis. It's also not physically addictive (unlike alcohol or nicotine).
- toyg 13y ago>It's also not physically addictive (unlike alcohol or nicotine). That's debatable and irrelevant anyway (coffee is addictive, should we ban it?).
- enkephalin 13y agodebatable yes, but not irrelevant. if you want to stop taking your drug of choice, and you're spared from having to cope with physical withdrawal symptoms, then that's a big plus.
- 13y ago
- jusben1369 13y agoWhat's so interesting here is that here's a government implementing this against the will of the majority of its people. That's pretty rare period/full stop. Fascinating here. True visionary bold leadership or blatant disregard for democracy.
- rosser 13y agoAs opposed to all the other "democracies" instituting policies that their polities don't want?
- aianus 13y ago70% of Canadians support, at minimum, decriminalizing marijuana yet our government recently increased sentencing for cultivation.
- cracell 13y agoWhy is that? I don't understand Canadian politics but the main explanation I've read online for this is that it was due to US pressure. But since the US government is allowing Colorado and Washington to go forward with their legalization that explanation no longer makes sense. Do Canadian citizens just not have an effective way to influence their politics or what's the deal?
- aianus 13y agoPeople choose who to vote for based on a variety of issues and I guess the legal status of marijuana isn't a priority over things like healthcare, taxes, fiscal policy, and 'job creation'. There's also the problem of having first-past-the-post elections with one conservative party and two to three liberal parties diluting the left vote.
- GFischer 13y agoI don't think it's against the majority. There are very vocal opponents, and it's probably close (I'm Uruguayan). Maybe it would be good to put it to a popular vote, I think it would pass (by a slight margin).
- waingake 13y agoI suspect that nearly everyone here will be of the opinion that this is a good idea. If you are up for an alternative ( and yes I know, oh so unfashionable ) point of view, then I recommend watching this. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36L0p2w_jtA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36L0p2w_jtA Its a fascinating and well put argument by Peter Hitchens that legalisation isn't beneficial to society. Yes imagine that.
- cookingrobot 13y agoI watched the video for a few minutes, and I found that everything he said was very stupid. But I do want to hear some good (unfashionable!) arguments for that point of view. Can you summarize some of his better arguments here?
- toyg 13y agoA Daily Mail correspondent? Somebody whose entire business is to stir controversy for the hell of it? Seriously?
- nwatson 13y agoA side effect: the sale of the tasty "chivito al plato" will soar (look it up).
- bitsoda 13y agoAl Jazeera English posted a really good interview with Uruguay's president, Jose Mujica. If you haven't seen it yet, I highly recommend it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nu12Dhoma0k http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nu12Dhoma0k
- delian66 13y agoThank you ! This interview is really very good. I wish that more people, in positions of influence and power, become as humble and clear in their reasoning, as this man is.
- beloch 13y agoUp in B.C., I'd appreciate legalization with a "gondola" provision. i.e. Cannabis would be legal, but if somebody insists on lighting up on a ski gondola I'm going to be stuck in for the next ten minutes, I'm allowed to toss him out if there's a nice soft snow-bank to aim for.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoI'm surprised there's still people who are so concerned with punishing people for putting things in their body. Many of these things actually being present in over-the-counter medicines. Also I despise it when people treat alcohol and tobacco as distinct from "drugs". Illicit drugs, yes.
- toyg 13y agoAlcohol and tobacco and coffee and Coke and energy drinks. Yes, fellow geeks, we're all addicts.
- enkephalin 13y agoi'm actually pretty surprised that most people totally ignore their caffeine addictions, or don't realize that they actually have a problem at all (probably due to the fact that they just don't stop taking it). as little as one cup of strong coffee a day can lead to physical dependence, which for some people can cause quite extreme withdrawal symptoms.
- andyhmltn 13y agoI certainly didn't. I've been drinking Tea all my life (British) and when I went without it for 3 days when I went abroad it was surprisingly hard.
- squozzer 13y agoUS invasion imminent.
- oakaz 13y agohttp://www.magnumphotos.com/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult&ALID=2K1HRGQK1_Q' http://www.magnumphotos.com/C.aspx?VP3=SearchResult&ALID=2K1... See the heroin addicted family photo first, then make your freedom speeches.
- bronson 13y agoRight after you finish your "let's throw the entire family in jail" speech.
- aaaahhhhh 13y agoHeroin is illegal, and the family still got addicted... any neurons firing up there yet?
- emiliobumachar 13y ago"Sorry anonymous your search - - did not match any document. Suggestions: - Make sure all words are spelled correctly. - Try different keywords. - Try more general keywords."
- anoncow 13y agoStop downvoting posts you don't agree with.
- bdcravens 13y agoI agree that downvotes are for poor comments, not differing opinions, but look at how HN doesn't work. If I say "patent lawsuit protect innovation" with supporting thoughts or "open source results in poor software", I'm likely to be downvoted as well. In most cases, it's the result of someone disagreeing with me.
- toyg 13y agoIn my experience that's not true. I've seen top-posts that in most other fora would be moderated out of existence, thrive on HN when they're well-supported with sources and rational thinking.
- almosnow 13y agoLegal drugs != less crime... On one hand, yeah sure, some people won't end up in jail for buying/selling/consuming drugs but those are just like little drops in the sea. The sea is actually the major criminal organizations that are perpetually conflicting with each other in order to maximize their particular profits. A situation where the demand becomes bigger (because it's not illegal anymore) will only put more fuel onto their war. And yeah, you would say 'it was the same way with alcohol'; NO it wasn't. That was a problem of a very different society at a very different time; to put that on perspective: when have you heard of ENTIRE countries employing practically everyone (even children) to grow, launder and even murder for the business?
- aaaahhhhh 13y agosome people won't end up in jail for buying/selling/consuming drugs but those are just like little drops in the sea. No. At any given time, around half of the men and women incarcerated in the US are there for non-violent drug offenses. To date, 31 million people have been arrested on drug related charges. A situation where the demand becomes bigger (because it's not illegal anymore) will only put more fuel onto their war. This is just obnoxiously wrong. How can you not understand that drug cartels won't even be a part of the picture after legalization? It will be LEGAL! It will be exactly the same as any other commodity. Beyond that, available evidence suggests that rates of drug abuse decrease when punishments become less draconian (see Portugal).
- almosnow 13y agoOk wow, I didn't knew that the proportion of inmates related would be that high! I didn't make my homework hehe. But drug cartels will still be part of the picture; with police out of the way they would have one less thing to worry about and they will still be fighting between each other for the market. Those people will not give up at all.
- freewhiffy 13y agoThe police won't be "out of the way" if the cartels continue with murder, selling to minors, underage workers, kidnapping, tax evasion etc. Those are all still crimes even if hard drugs were made legal. The cartels would have to choose between going legit, and delivering goods like coors, malboro etc, or continuing their other illegal activities and get taken down by the police
- alexhutcheson 13y agoReminds me of this interesting 2009 essay from Steve Yegge about the complexity of legalizing marijuana: http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2009/04/have-you-ever-legalized-marijuana.html http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2009/04/have-you-ever-legali...
- aaaahhhhh 13y agoI'm always surprised to see people arguing against legalization of any recreational substance. If this is your stance, I'm curious, how old are you? (serious question)
- enkephalin 13y agoin my experience age has nothing to do with it. it mostly boils down to misinformation, or knowing or having known people who's lives have been ruined by drug abuse (these people also often can't discriminate between 'use' and 'abuse'), and not stopping to think how this situation was brought about in the first place, or how destigmatization of the whole topic could maybe have prevented the whole thing from getting out of hand. Edit: taken from the commment directly below mine at the time of writing: I've got addicts and alcoholics in my family. My cousin died from overdose. I've got close friends who killed themselves with drink. Lots of you do too. Exciting times? IMHO, the last thing we should celebrate is new ways to get a buzz on.
- stplsd 13y ago"Why is the drug czar of this country - Well, lets go back. Why do we have a drug czar in this country, a)? b) Why is he a cop? Why isn’t he a guy in recovery, who’s had alcohol and/or drug addiction and overcome it? And why doesn’t he help people with the same problem with compassion rather than condemnation? Why do we put people who are on drugs in jail? They’re sick. They’re not criminals. Sick people don’t get healed in jail. See, it makes no sense." -- Bill Hicks
- stplsd 13y agoIt is a shame that all legalization efforts goes to cannabis - the drug that causes the least problems by being illegal. What we really need is to legalize "hard drugs"[1] - heroin, methamphetamine. These drugs cause the most harm by being illegal and it is a shame, because, for example, pure heroin is gentle and harmless drug. Too bad I am not see this happening in the next 100 years. But I am sure that it will happen eventually. Future generations will see the "war on drugs" the same we see slavery today. [1] "hard drugs" is meaningless term
- misterjangles 13y agoNot sure I agree about heroin being gentle and harmless, but I do think that making any drug illegal immediately creates a black market, which in turn leads to violence and powerful, wealthy crime organizations. I'm not sure where the line should be. I'd like to say make all drugs legal, but as soon as the first high school kid is killed in a drug-related car accident we will see an army of furious parent organizations screaming about making stricter laws.
- enkephalin 13y agoit isn't a matter of opinion. heroin is in no way a harmless drug. it's highly addictive and easily lethal if taken in to high a dose or combined with other drugs, like e.g. alcohol, or benzodiazepines. EDIT: the same goes for most other opiates/opioids.
- stplsd 13y ago> highly addictive hacker news is highly addictive, should we ban it too? > and easily lethal if taken in to high a dose or combined with other drugs Just use common sense. Water is lethal taken in to high a dose [1]. Almost every substance is lethal if taken to much for body to handle. And mixing heroin with benzos is just plain stupid. Of course if heroin would be legal, it could be printed with warnings, etc. And people take heroin (or other opioids) with benzos for two main reasons: a) Unknowingly take a mix then dealers mix diluted opioids with benzos for better effect and to hide that their shit is weak b) Users mix themselves then opioid is weak or doesn't produce enough high (methadone, etc) If users should have cheap source of medical grade heroin no one would use them with benzos. So legal heroin have only benefits. Of course some people are plain stupid (for example taking too much paracetamol and end being without kidneys) So just don't do heroin alone, have a Naloxone for worst case scenario and heroin will be safe as milk. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication
- ioddly 13y agoIt's a little depressing how relatively radical the attitude of the legislators in the article is. It's not that they think this is 100% absolutely going to work. It's just that they realize what they're doing now isn't working and they need to change it and see if they can get better results.
- redxblood 13y agoHa, i'm from uruguay and i'm reading about it here. Go local news.
- jollyjoe88 13y agoThis changes everything. But we're yet to find out whether the US govt will follow this precedent.
- bigsassy 13y agoThis is somewhat relevant. One of the candidates for Governor is Maryland, Heather Mizeur, is running on legalizing cannabis. You can see her discuss it here: http://www.heathermizeur.com/news/wusa9-plan-to-legalize-marijuana-in-maryland http://www.heathermizeur.com/news/wusa9-plan-to-legalize-mar...
- ck2 13y agoBTW you can also marry whomever you want in Uraguay too, so they are way ahead of the USA in many other more important ways. Would be really strange if national legalization of recreational drugs is legalized first before being able to marry whomever you love.