8 ms·
1) What the heck do they mean by a hologram? The analogy here baffles me. Is this just a layman's analogy, or does this actually mean something scientific? 2)
by crazygringo 13y ago
1) What the heck do they mean by a hologram? The analogy here baffles me. Is this just a layman's analogy, or does this actually mean something scientific?
2) Anybody have any suggestions on a high-quality layman's explanation? I finished reading Feynman's QED the other week, and loved it, and was wondering what the closest might be for string theory.
- devindotcom 13y agoYeah, this is trouble, because the common understanding of "hologram" is very different from the actual definition. As far as I understand it (and another person has explained it better below), the indication is that the way we perceive the universe indicates that the "data" producing those perceptions is not stored in the same structures we see or detect - instead, those structures (space, mass) are sort of "implied" by a more fundamental way of "storing" that data, which we interpret secondhand because we can't perceive the original. Not sure if this is clear or accurate, but that's what I've taken away from previous articles on a holographic universe.
- bitops 13y agoEven if it's not completely technically accurate, I think your explanation makes the most intuitive sense to me out of all the responses I read.
- jonnathanson 13y agoSo basically, Plato was correct. (Sort of.)
- X4 13y agoIf I get this right, then the irony here is, that everybody is correct and wrong at the same time. Just draw some dots, circles etc. on paper and it could be that one day that non-local representation of the holographic universe holds true.
- Florin_Andrei 13y agoWhat's interesting is that your description would also be appropriate for a computer model, or simulation.
- a3voices 13y agoFrom a few long Youtube videos I just watched, the amount of information in the Universe is limited and based on the total surface area, not the volume.
- wyager 13y agoThis is true. Maximum entropy increases with the surface area of a space, not its volume. This is well explained by the holographic principle.
- andy112 13y agoOthers can hopefully chime in with more, but when I first was learning about it, my reaction to the word "hologram" was the same as your (1). My understanding is that when they say "hologram", they're simply meaning an n dimensional object that's encoded in n-1 dimensional space. If you're not familiar with the basics of the Holographic Principle, start here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle It's been a while since I've watched these, but IIRC these are very good videos to start with: - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2DIl3Hfh9tY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2DIl3Hfh9tY - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHgi6E1ECgo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHgi6E1ECgo EDIT: Key clippings from the wikipedia article- "But Jacob Bekenstein noted that this leads to a violation of the second law of thermodynamics. If one throws a hot gas with entropy into a black hole, once it crosses the event horizon, the entropy would disappear. The random properties of the gas would no longer be seen once the black hole had absorbed the gas and settled down. The second law can only be salvaged if black holes are in fact random objects, with an enormous entropy whose increase is greater than the entropy carried by the gas. Bekenstein argued that black holes are maximum entropy objects—that they have more entropy than anything else in the same volume. In a sphere of radius R, the entropy in a relativistic gas increases as the energy increases. The only limit is gravitational; when there is too much energy the gas collapses into a black hole. Bekenstein used this to put an upper bound on the entropy in a region of space, and the bound was proportional to the area of the region. He concluded that the black hole entropy is directly proportional to the __area__ of the event horizon." (__'s mine)
- rthomas6 13y ago>Bekenstein argued that black holes are maximum entropy objects So would it follow that the equilibrium state of the universe is one gigantic black hole?
- Ygg2 13y agoWe are essentially sitting inside a giant black hole. As our cosmos expands faster than speed of light, we can't ever escape this cosmos. Our light cone is similar to one that sits in a giant black hole.
- jasonwatkinspdx 13y agoFrom Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle): "The holographic principle is a property of quantum gravity and string theories that states that the description of a volume of space can be thought of as encoded on a boundary to the region—preferably a light-like boundary like a gravitational horizon. First proposed by Gerard 't Hooft, it was given a precise string-theory interpretation by Leonard Susskind[1] who combined his ideas with previous ones of 't Hooft and Charles Thorn.[1][2] As pointed out by Raphael Bousso,[3] Thorn observed in 1978 that string theory admits a lower-dimensional description in which gravity emerges from it in what would now be called a holographic way. In a larger sense, the theory suggests that the entire universe can be seen as a two-dimensional information structure "painted" on the cosmological horizon, such that the three dimensions we observe are only an effective description at macroscopic scales and at low energies." So the analogy is that the field inside the volume can be completely described by some function over the bounding surface of the volume, similar to how the light field captured by a hologram is projected and recorded on a flat glass or film plane. I can visualize that pretty easily, but I don't know enough to tie that to some concrete relationship to the fundamental physical forces of the universe.
- 1qaz2wsx3edc 13y agoI understood some of those words.
- X4 13y agoIt means in essence, that we live in the two-dimensional space, which contains just enough information (thanks to interference patterns), to be projectable to the 3rd dimension. In holographic duality, this is a way to derive a more complex dimension from the next lowest dimension. It is thought that the four-dimensional space, which you may have just been thinking about, exists due to distant entangled quarks and may be the thing we call space-time. The holy grail every physicist is searching for is "gravity". Nobody on earth knows for sure what gravity exactly is. But it is thought to exist in the fifth-dimension "bends & shapes the our space-time. Don't confuse this with the simulated universe theory, as I initially did. That's a whole nother story. Time is believed to not exist as a separate dimension, but as a byproduct of gravity. -- Please correct me, if I'm wrong on something.
- Ygg2 13y ago1) The gist is this: Hologram is a 2D picture that encodes a 3D object using light interference. Holographic principle states that information encodes reality into matter/energy and gravity. Basically gravity, matter and energy are sideffects of information. They are its projections. How does this relate to hologram? Well dots that might appear like two separated dots on the 3D model, could be encoded on the 2D surface as very close. What this explains is "spooky action at a distance". We perceive two entangled electrons as being far away on a reality hologram, when in reality they are close on the fundamental 2D picture of the world. Summary: What we perceive and measure as reality is not what reality fundamentally is. NOTE: This is extremely layman termish and don't be too surprised if it's wrong. I last read UiaN years ago. There are also some other interesting properties, like that the any part of hologram contains whole picture of hologram but of lousier quality, etc. 2) I think Universe in a Nutshell covers most of this theory pretty well.
- chiph 13y agoSo the Celestial Spheres[1] model used by Plato, Ptolemy, etc. wasn't entirely wrong? ;) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celestial_spheres http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celestial_spheres
- Ygg2 13y agoIn the same way Flatland was a real life story :)
- nimble 13y ago> What this explains is "spooky action at a distance". So what's the explanation for why almost all interactions that we perceive seem to not be spooky or at a distance?
- Ygg2 13y agoThe same reason you don't see each dot on your monitor as separate light source, unless you take a magnifying glass. Or that you don't experience theory of relativity when accelerating. Senses are imperfect and the information such as those aren't vital to our survival. And their effect is tiny, tiny, tiny. I'm pretty sure spooky action (iirc quantum tunneling) at a distance keeps our sun running, or at least computers.
- VLM 13y agoA piece of hologram film doesn't look anything like the image, but it does have a certain distinct "look" to it. Much like the famous quote about not being able to define pr0n but I know it when I see it. Holograms have a certain "look" to them. It's what happens when you project a 3-D image onto a 2-D piece of film using all manner of weird wave interactions from a coherent source blah blah blah science talk blah. So the terrible awful analogy is they're saying their simulation of a projection of some weirdness into normal space looks like our gravity and space and mom and apple pie. The awful analogy being that the squigglies on holographic film are to the actual object, as their weird theory is to something vaguely like the space we live in, at least in some aspects. Take two things and there's a certain look to them and a certain transform in between and thats pretty much kinda whats going on in both cases. This post exceeds the US recommended daily allowance of "kinda" "sorta" "mostly" so take it with a death star sized grain of salt. I'll laugh at anyone flaming me for not getting it exactly right cause this is simplified almost to not meaning much.
- yk 13y agoI am not entirely sure either, what they mean by hologram. The problem is, that holographic principle ( or similar) can mean different things depending on the context. But in string theories, it is sometimes the case that lower dimensional theories can encode the same information as the full string theory. Just as illustration, if the endpoints of your strings are stuck on a two dimensional plane, but the strings can vibrate in three dimensions, then you can potentially describe the system as a theory of the endpoints in two dimensions ( and the vibration mode of the string would potentially be encoded as the type of particle), or you can describe how the strings move through three dimensions. As for recommended reading, I liked Brian Green's The Elegant Universe.
- Steuard 13y agoThere is nothing else I've ever seen like Feynman's QED, not for any field of physics. It's spectacular: a "popular" level book for a general audience that doesn't tell a single fib (even by omission), and that captures the essence of the subject without delving into the math required for serious calculations. I dream of writing a book like this (about string theory or anything else).
- eru 13y agoHow to Mock a Mockingbird might come close in spirit for combinatorical logic.
- dchichkov 13y agoIf you can accept some tiny bits of math, I'd suggest Susskind's lectures. As close to the real thing as it can get, and almost effortless on your part.