4 ms·
A couple of years ago I moved to the Yukon and had the opportunity to go Moose hunting. I really didn't know if I'd be OK with killing such a large animal and "
by grecy 13y ago
A couple of years ago I moved to the Yukon and had the opportunity to go Moose hunting. I really didn't know if I'd be OK with killing such a large animal and "getting down to it" and have found to experience to be quite powerful.
There is a lot of respect for the animal and we treat every square centimeter of edible meat with the utmost care. It's quite a strange sensation to be working so hard (it's extremely heavy and time consuming to field dress such a large animal) but have this feeling that it's the right thing to be doing. Somehow, I know my ancestors have been doing this for tens of thousands of years.
When I cook at home I make certain that every plate is eaten or saved for leftovers. I would never let someone simply scrape that into the trash, as I might have done when buying shrink wrapped meat from Safeway.
It's a highly rewarding and enlightening process which I highly, highly recommend to anyone that eats meat.
UPDATE: I've been putting the finishing touches on a blog entry about this experience and photos from my first moose hunting trip.... I'll try to have it done later today, the post will be at the top of http://theroadchoseme.com http://theroadchoseme.com when it's done.
- famousactress 13y agoI really wish more people who eat meat would put themselves in a position to experience this. It's awesome that you took away so much respect for the animal and the process. I'd love to see that kind of awareness at scale. (full disclosure: I'm vegan)
- Jgrubb 13y agoQ: How do you know if someone is a vegan? A: THEY'LL TELL YOU. (full disclosure: married to a vegan, I couldn't resist)
- famousactress 13y agoFWIW I mentioned it because the conversation is about eating meat, not because I need you to think I'm awesome. In fact, I think the joke has some very relevant truth to it. I think heralding veganism is a ridiculous mission from a practical standpoint, and lots of people and organizations are spinning their wheels converting a tiny fraction of the population to a totally meatless diet when instead it makes so much more sense to focus on even mildly reducing meat consumption (or waste) from a much broader segment of the population.
- Jgrubb 13y agoI totally agree with you on every point, except for the one about heralding veganism being ridiculous. I don't think it's ridiculous at all, especially when I look around at the average morbidly obese guy here in Northern NJ, and then go to Thanksgiving out in Michigan with my wife's family and the meat eaters are in the minority. Everyone at Thanksgiving looks amazing and healthy. I think the greater and more meaningful challenge would just be to get more people to think about what they're eating at all, regardless of what it is. I think reduced meat consumption would happen automatically if people actually mentally connected the animals in this story to the burger they're putting in their mouth. I think veganism is the logical conclusion to becoming truly aware of what you're eating, personally.
- arsenerei 13y ago> I think veganism is the logical conclusion to becoming truly aware of what you're eating, personally. You said you're married to a vegan, suggesting you're not vegan yourself. So by you're statement you're not truly aware of what you're eating? Or are you vegan as well?
- Jgrubb 13y agoNot a vegan, and I can say yes - I perform the mental disconnect in my mind that I think happens with most people when they eat meat that I don't really think about where it comes from. If I did/when I do think about it, I generally don't eat it.
- Zikes 13y agoI think your anecdote is a flawed positive correlation. Your wife's family may be largely vegan, but that doesn't strictly account for their health and wellbeing vs your average obese person. I think that their veganism is part of a broader health consciousness, where they most likely pay more attention to their nutrition and exercise than do the average "morbidly obese guy" in Northern NJ. I've no doubt that if they were to practice a similar lifestyle but include meats they would look and be equally healthy. And for an equally anecdotal counterpoint: look up Crossfitters and the paleo diet, of which meat makes up a key proportion.
- steveklabnik 13y agoAs someone who is... often vegan, this happens because other people give you shit for not eating something. Usually, people notice that you say no to something that tastes good. And then they ask you why. So you tell them. And then they say something like this. I know vegans who have resorted to just saying they have allergies, because it's easier than dealing with how poorly people treat them for simply not choosing to eat certain things.
- bane 13y agoIf you look through this thread, the reason vegans get blowback/mistreated is because of the near constant browbeating and morale posturing they do to justify their life-style. If there was a population that arbitrarily decided to stop wearing underwear and came to me and constantly announced that they are underwear free and told me that wearing underwear was morally wrong and constantly chastised me for it, I'd think they'd be treated in much the same way.
- grecy 13y agoI agree 100% My brother is vegetarian, and bordered on vegan for a few years, my girlfriend is the same, and before hunting I was eating meat maybe once a week or two. Going into the first hunt, I said to myself "if you can't handle this, then you should stop eating meat". The first time it was a little gruesome and shocking, but it was a fantastic learning experience and I wouldn't have it any other way.
- danpat 13y agoThis has been my experience almost exactly (s/Yukon/Alberta/). I now hunt yearly and basically don't any meat that I didn't kill myself. One deer is enough for a couple for a year. I found the experience it very self-illuminating, the hypocrisy of will-not-kill-but-will-eat-from-store became much more focused. The experience of hunting wildly varies. I've had one or two gut-wrenching bad shots, hitting the animal in the leg then having to track it down and end it. Most of the time, the animal is dead before the sound of the shot reaches them, before which they were blissfully grazing. Regardless of the experience, you reflect on what you've just done far more than when you buy meat on a shelf.
- tspiteri 13y agoIf it works for you, fine. But I object to you calling people who eat what they do not kill hypocrites. If someone takes part in a protest against meat products because of animal suffering, and then eats meat or wears leather, they are hypocrites. But if they cannot bring themselves to kill the animal themselves but still eat meat, they are not hypocrites. If they were, people who are queasy when they see blood, but would want a surgeon to care for them or their friends when they are in an accident, would be will-not-doctor-but-will-be-doctored hypocrites. I think the main problem here is that when some people have an experience they find illuminating, their reaction is to look down on other people who do not share the newly acquired viewpoint.
- jtreminio 13y ago> If someone takes part in a protest against meat products because of animal suffering, and then eats meat or wears leather, they are hypocrites. I highly disagree. Why would wearing a leather jacket make me a hypocrite? It's very much possible to raise and butcher an animal humanely, and still enjoy its meat and leather.
- tspiteri 13y agoI was not specific enough. I should have said if someone takes part in a protest against all meat products. You are right: it is not hypocritical to campaign against inhumane treatment of animals but not against humane butchering.
- arsenerei 13y agoI have a few questions in regard to your powerful and enlightening experience: * Will you only cook what you kill? * If not, will this experience change the type of meat you purchase? (e.g., free range only) * Have you or will you now cook offal?
- grecy 13y agoAbsolutely, happy to answer whatever questions you have. * Will you only cook what you kill?* Yep. I have only eaten meat and fish that I (or my close friends) have hunted for the last ~2.5 years. We get a Moose every year, we've gotten a few bison, I go salmon fishing lots. * If not, will this experience change the type of meat you purchase? (e.g., free range only)* It's been so long since I even looked at meat for sale, I honestly couldn't tell you how much it even costs. I buy free-range eggs, and prefer local when I can find it. * Have you or will you now cook offal?* We always keep (and cook) the heart, a friend keeps (and cooks) the liver. So far, I have not kept or eaten anything else. I'm not against the idea, it's not something I've explored or learned about. I have kept a few of the hides, but getting them tanned is wickedly expensive and I don't have much use for them. I try to give them away.
- arsenerei 13y agoOkay, awesome. I appreciate your openness and your responses. :)
- nzp 13y agoThere seems to be quite a number of people who embrace the reasoning that it's more ethical to eat animals if one kills them themselves. (I'm not sure if I'm not reading this into what you're writing, if this is not your position I apologise, but anyway this is for the purpose of discussing said position in general.) I disagree with this in general. The act of feeding oneself is necessary for survival, whereas killing animals is not. First of all, the animal couldn't care less if someone treats its corpse with respect--it's already dead, so I don't see how the animal benefits from this. Second, I'd say that the negative effects on the killer's mind from the act of killing far outweigh any positive effects from mindfulness in handling food produced from the kill. Killing desensitizes, you become accustomed to taking life from another sentient being. The meat industry is likewise taking care to use every edible part of the animal, they're not producing any waste as far as that goes. Further, I don't think eating everything in the plate is making any measurable difference in terms of total meat consumed (if that's the implicit idea behind this). It's like the “think about the starving children in Africa” routine, which never made sense: people in Africa aren't starving because kids in the West aren't eating their whole dinners, and what good does cleaning the plate (i.e. making the food gone) do to remedy the situation. :) > It's a highly rewarding and enlightening process which I highly, highly recommend to anyone that eats meat. The bottom line of what I'm trying to say is I just can't see anything enlightening, let alone rewarding, in a process which necessitates killing other sentient beings. Of course, there is absolutely no doubt that hunting is infinitely more ethical than what is being done by the meat industry. It's really incomparable, so if you have to eat meat do take care it's from a reasonable source like hunting or “organic” (I hate that word) farming. However, that likely doesn't scale at all at the current levels of population. In my mind the best thing to do would be to just stop killing animals for food. Some time ago I came across this interesting Youtube video[0] but never got around to post it here, and this discussion reminded me of that[1]. Basically, this guy (a Theravada monk) summarizes almost perfectly what I'm trying to say. Because of the horrible things industrial meat production does, I can't quite agree with him that it's OK to buy meat in the supermarket (as long as you're not specifically desiring meat), but otherwise I think he is spot on. [0] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zisXgVnv-cI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zisXgVnv-cI [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6884572 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6884572
- 13y ago