3 ms·
In order to make it tractable, you pick a finite model space, train it on finite data, and use a finite algorithm to find the best choice inside of that space.
by joe_the_user 13y ago
In order to make it tractable, you pick a finite model space, train it on finite data, and use a finite algorithm to find the best choice inside of that space. That means you can fail in three ways---you can over-constrain your model space so that the true model cannot be found, you can underpower your search so that you have less an ability to discern the best model in your chosen model space, and you can terminate your search early and fail to reach that point entirely.
It seems like you can "mis-power" your model also.
For example, the Ptolemaic system could approximate the movement of the planets to any degree if you added enough "wheels within wheels" but since these were "the wrong wheels", the necessary wheels grew without bounds to achieve reasonable approximation over time.
- alok-g 13y agoAwesome example!
- tel 13y agoTotally agree, though I'd call that maybe "picking the wrong shape" for your model space. You can pay a whole lot but if you cannot admit a shape that gets close to the truth then you're spending your data in vain.
- eru 13y agoFunny enough, the wheels within wheels are equivalent to a Fourier transform.
- tel 13y agoAlso, to add, when DGL bring this kind of mental model up they do so to motivate a kind of semi-parametric modeling where the design space changes progressively to move closer to the true model without growing so quickly as to make inference unstable. The problem being, of course, that this causes your algorithm run time to blow out to something cubic, I think, and so you have a beautiful model that loses out on search error.
- rcthompson 13y ago> For example, the Ptolemaic system could approximate the movement of the planets to any degree if you added enough "wheels within wheels" but since these were "the wrong wheels", the necessary wheels grew without bounds to achieve reasonable approximation over time. That would be an example of over-constraining your model (i.e. imposing the arbitrary constraint of a stationary Earth).
- joe_the_user 13y agoI don't think this is useful way to phrase the situation. A system of Ptolemaic circles can approximate the paths taken by any system. So the system really isn't absolutely constrained to follow or not follow any given path. You could claim you have constrained your model not be some other better model but that, again, seems like a poor way to phrase things since a more accurate model is also constrained not to be a poor model. Even specifically, the Newtonian/Keplerian system has the constrain of the sun being stationary as much as the Ptolemaic system has the constraint of the earth being stationary. Edit: As Eru points out, the Ptolemaic system basically uses the Fourier transform to represent paths. Thus the approximation is actually completely unconstrained in the space of paths, that is it can approximate anything. But by that token, the fact that it can approximate a given path explains nothing and the choices that are simple in this system are not necessarily the best choices for the given case, estimating planetary motion. See - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deferent_and_epicycle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deferent_and_epicycle
- rcthompson 13y agoThat's a good point, but after re-reading tel's original comment, I think my statement is still correct. Notice that tel's statement was that "you can over-constrain your model space so that the true model cannot be found". This doesn't necessarily mean constraining your model so that the true model is excluded from your parameter space. If your constraints technically encompass the true solution but only admit an overly complex parametrization of the solution, then it will still reduce (perhaps drastically) your power to find the true model. In this case, "overly complex" means unnecessarily many nonzero (or not almost zero) coefficients in the Fourier series.