7 ms·
> The Man Who Does Not Exist tells me he is a libertarian, an Ayn Rand disciple, and, in the parlance of Silicon Valley, views himself a disrupter. Making mone
by bradleyjg 13y ago
> The Man Who Does Not Exist tells me he is a libertarian, an Ayn Rand disciple, and, in the parlance of Silicon Valley, views himself a disrupter.
Making money by breaking regulations and lease terms is hardly the stuff of the heroic inventor. What other criminals count as "disrputers"? Insider traders? Identity thieves? Insurance fraudsters?
This guy is sociopath and I hope he ends up in prison.
- S4M 13y agoYeah, I hate the fact that his actions will have for consequence to even increase the rents and real estate prices in New York, which, from what I heard, are already expensive enough.
- aliston 13y agoYou also have to also ask why it is that these arbitrage opportunities exist in the first place. It seems to me that the fact that these folks exist is essentially the market arguing that there are inefficiencies in government regulation of the hotel industry. Perhaps the government shouldn't be implementing arbitrary taxes to direct to the politically connected.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pyduan 13y agoThe fact there are arbitrage opportunities are precisely the reason the regulations exist. The problem is that the market equilibrium would be really bad for residents. You have to stop and think about what there being no such opportunity would mean: housing in these areas is in scarce supply, and letting the market do its thing would incentivize people to convert rooms to full-time hotels at the expense of people who actually live there (since the true market value of a room is much higher than the average rent; in other words, your arbitrage opportunity), which will in turn reduce the supply of apartments available for residents, thus making rent even more expensive than it is right now for the few that will be able to afford it. I agree the regulations are not perfect, but people have to understand it comes from a conscious political decision to protect residents. And this by the way is why you need a government to create such rules, because contrary to what people like the man in this article might think, the market equilibrium is not always the most desirable situation.
- cbr 13y agowhich will in turn reduce the supply of apartments available for residents If the cities allow new construction the supply should expand to match the increased demand, creating jobs in the process.
- ceejayoz 13y agoManhattan has somewhat limited space for new construction.
- hapless 13y agoManhattan could re-zone to permit a great deal more construction, but it is unlikely to happen. First, residents strongly oppose it. Second, much of the transport system is maxed out. Building more housing or office space would only overburden systems operating at capacity. (e.g. the west side highway, fdr drive, lexington avenue subway line are all unusably crowded)
- saalweachter 13y agoWhat is the zoning like in Manhattan? I see intermingled residential/office/commercial spaces everywhere I go (heck, my last office was in the same building as apartments, with a store-turned-restaurant on the ground floor), so I didn't realize there were zoning restrictions in that sense.
- hapless 13y agolots and lots of historic districts there are crippling height restrictions all over the place, and you have to buy un-used "air rights" from your neighbors to build anything taller than what already exists in the neighborhood environmental impact studies (weirdly) can be used against projects local "community boards" have a lot of power and the aforementioned centrally imposed limits on development -- the city's top-level boards may not like what you're doing to transportation
- 13y ago
- bradleyjg 13y agoThe FREEEDOM!!! argument only works for landlords who own the whole building and are running a hotel without following the hotel laws. People who are subletting in violation of thier lease terms or co-op/condo agreement are not only breaking the law but also willfully breaching contracts they have freely agreed to. I thought that libertarians considered negotiated contracts a key mechanism of ordering a society?
- yoshokatana 13y agoI'm not a libertarian, so I can't speak on OP's argument, but in NYC the ability for renters to sublet their apartments is enshrined by law, and technically any contract that doesn't allow subletting is breaking said law (which, if I remember correctly (and IANAL), makes that clause of the contract void, but not the rest of the contract).
- auctiontheory 13y agoOoh, my inner Scheme programmer likes nested parentheses in a post! I believe NYC forbids short-term sublets - that's the big issue here. Plus the taxes, of course.
- mbreese 13y agoSubletting is well regulated too... yes, renters have the right to sublet, but they also have a set of restrictions on the process. For example, you can't sublet for less than 30 days, which would make the entire thing unusable for AirBnB. And if the apartment is rent controlled, then you have another set of regulations.
- _delirium 13y agoHe's violating contracts he signed, not only government regulations. These contracts are in place specifically because the market demands them. Most people don't want to live in a condo building that also includes DIY hotel rooms. Taking this into account, condo developers usually include clauses in the sales contract where your more or less agree not to turn your condo into a hotel room. This allows them to reassure prospective purchasers that such a scenario won't happen. That's why the person in this story not only needs to avoid the government, but also private-sector contract enforcement. Hence, he's looking for buildings with no doorman and no live-in super, since those would be more likely to notice his illicit activity. I don't see how that's libertarian or even Randian. Rand's view was that violating a contract is an act of indirect violence, essentially theft.
- avn2109 13y ago>>"These contracts are in place specifically because the market demands them." The devil's advocate here would say, "These contracts are in place because the market is rigged here by powerful, entrenched, rent-seeking interests that are colluding."
- auctiontheory 13y agothe fact that these folks exist is essentially the market arguing that there are inefficiencies in government regulation of the hotel industry The "inefficiency" you've spotted is that a business which ignores all rules, regulations and taxes will have a huge competitive advantage over those who comply. That's true in any industry, not just housing.
- saalweachter 13y agoYou can also take advantage of the arbitrage opportunities created by the regulations against selling cigarettes and beer to minors and make a tidy profit. A similar opportunity exists for all sorts of waste disposal, if you ignore all the pesky environmental regulations.
- azernik 13y agoBy that argument, tax evasion of any kind is a symptom of "inefficiencies in the government regulation of income". Just because someone has a financial incentive to violate the law, doesn't mean that the law is bad.
- awkward 13y agoIs "inefficiencies in government regulation" code for taxes?
- moocowduckquack 13y agoHe seems fairly dislikable and he is probably on the wrong side of the law, but what possible benefit would prison be here?
- dllthomas 13y agoIt might be of benefit to neighbors he is bothering, and by extension anyone else who will be forced to bear the brunt of externalities he similarly ignores in the future.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoIf it is externalities that you are worried about, the externalities from him being in prison are likely to be far higher than the externalities of him trying to rent out a few apartments. I don't agree with the guy, but I also suspect he may have a point about some of the regulations being over prescriptive. Also, I think that believing that this guy should be in prison for these actions is far more sociopathic than anything this article claims that this guy is doing.
- dllthomas 13y agoThe costs of punishment almost always exceed the cost of the individual action. The question is the cost of enforcement in total versus the prevented cost in total, including both the costs that would be caused by this guy and the costs that would be caused by others that are deterred by the credible threat of enforcement. Having said that, I am extremely sympathetic to the notion that NYC markets may be over-regulated, and have mixed feelings about the notion that evasion is an appropriate way to deal with that. I don't necessarily think this guy should be in prison; I was narrowly answering your question: "[W]hat possible benefit would prison be here?"
- chongli 13y agoThe question is the cost of enforcement in total versus the prevented cost in total, including both the costs that would be caused by this guy and the costs that would be caused by others that are deterred by the credible threat of enforcement. And therein lies the rub. Sociopaths are not deterred by any but the most credible of threats. They will always find new avenues of exploit down at the bottom. To make an extreme effort to try and wipe out all sociopaths, parasites, free riders (or whatever else you want to call them) would impose enormous, crippling costs on our society.
- ForHackernews 13y ago> He considers himself a New York entrepreneur who wants to make a buck and doesn’t have much patience for what he views as arbitrary rules and regulations, such as those that govern renting apartments to Airbnb subscribers. I don't see how this guy is any different from Airbnb itself (or other disruptive-and-dubiously-legal operations like the various digital gypsy cab companies).
- hapless 13y agoHe's not very different from AirBnB. He breaks the law directly. AirBnB merely induces its customers to break the law. In both cases, they're bad actors.
- 001sky 13y agoThis doesn't follow. AirBnB does what it does. The laws in each and every area do what they do. There is no need for them to overlap, nor does a legal entity taking a position against AirBnB's potential customers make them a 'bad actor'in the general sense.
- philwelch 13y agoI appreciate the concept of disobeying unjust laws, but I don't think hotel taxes are a valid example.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- patcon 13y agoairbnb is a bad actor? Come on. It's not nearly that simple. The Helsinki Design Lab (HDL), a governmental agency originally created in 1968 to encourage design thinking in Finland, engaged in an interesting study. In Helsinki, there's an unofficial day where historically, citizens have essentially opened illegal restaurants for the day. They sell out of homes and apartments and open windows, or often just give it away for free. Obviously all of this is highly illegal, but it's an amazing cultural experience that is beloved. HDL polled some of the people who created these pop-up restaurants, trying to figure out whether they had any interest in openning real restaurants. The answer was an overwhelming no. So the lab set out to answer an interesting question: "Why is it that none of these people who open free restaurants for a day -- these entrepreneurs who clearly love the essence of serving and creating food -- why is it that they find it such a ridiculous proposition to open a business?" It's a good question and worth asking. Here was a result of that investigation (among other things, such as streamlining the bureaucracy around registering and managing the business): http://www.helsinkidesignlab.org/dossiers/open-kitchen http://www.helsinkidesignlab.org/dossiers/open-kitchen You say AirBnb is a "bad actor" for breaking the law, and I say that that's incredibly unimaginative. Every single person on airbnb wants to open a hotel, but they frankly disengage from the formal process, likely for valid reasons. AirBnb is helping to identify that this is a problem that needs solving.
- coderzach 13y agoI think you're conflating morality and legality. How does breaking regulations make him a sociopath? Who is he harming? In what world is renting an apartment, albeit against regulation and terms of the lease, an offense ANYWHERE NEAR insider trading, identity theft, or insurance fraud? Am I missing something?
- hapless 13y ago* He is defrauding his landlords. They rented him property on the understanding that it was a legal and low-risk engagement. * He is hurting the neighbors to the properties he re-rents. They arranged to live in residential neighborhoods adjacent to other semi-permanent residents, not an illegal hotel. Hotels are not found in charming residential neighborhoods for a reason: nobody wants to live next to them. * He is evading taxes that are used to improve new yorkers' quality of life at little/no expense to local residents. * Insurance fraud is a probable consequence of his business. Since it's hard to get commercial insurance for your illegal venture, if he has ANY insurance, it would be a renter's policy and maybe a personal umbrella policy. Any claims he made would be fraudulent.
- Turing_Machine 13y ago"used to improve new yorkers' quality of life at little/no expense to local residents" Well, except for the losses from non-visitors who avoid cities with outrageously high "let's rip off our guests" taxes. Those people may not be directly visible, but I assure you they are real.
- hapless 13y agoif a 15% hotel tax is what steers you away from one of the world's preeminent tourist destinations, I'm not sure that you were going to add much to the local economy. (To be a little less snarky, the microeconomics of the situation indicate it's probably not that damaging. Your hotel stay is probably less than half of your costs of visiting, so a 15% markup on that component alone doesn't raise the overall price of a trip very much.)
- yapcguy 13y agoThe guy doesn't exist. The whole article is a work of fiction. Pando must be desperate for traffic. > After dropping out of college, the Man took a job in high-frequency trading when he was 20, where, he claims, he made a killing. Are we supposed to believe that a person who dropped out of college, with no computer science or programming background, is hired by a hedge fund or the proprietary trading desk of a large bank to help develop their HFT software and algorithms?
- fwr 13y agoTo be fair, there are a lot of other ways to "make a killing" in HFT which are not developing software and algorithms for hedge funds or large banks.
- S4M 13y agoI was surprised by that as well, but there may be some explanation. For example, he was a teenage hacker and had connections - through his family or other. So maybe he knew someone at a high frequency trading hedge fund who saw that the guy could code, and gave him a chance. I agree that it's a bit far fetched, but IMHO it's plausible and I wouldn't be surprised if more than one person had already landed a lucrative job in the financial sector that way.
- rollo_tommasi 13y agoOr maybe he just lied? He doesn't seem like the most trustworthy kind of guy to begin with.
- Mikeb85 13y ago> Are we supposed to believe that a person who dropped out of college, with no computer science or programming background, is hired by a hedge fund or the proprietary trading desk of a large bank to help develop their HFT software and algorithms? No kidding. Not to mention, if he indeed 'made a killing' in the finance industry, why would he be hustling trying to resell iPads and now Air-bnb suites? Seems something programming-related or becoming an ex-pat in a tropical country with nice beaches would be more suitable for someone in their 20's that hates their job and has a lot of money...
- ErikAugust 13y agoWhile I think your final statement is rather vitriolic, I do agree the article styling him an "entrepreneur" or "disrupter" is ridiculous. He is a step or two above a drug dealer. That's about where I would land him.
- dnautics 13y agowould you have said the same about a speakeasy bartender during the prohibition era?
- ErikAugust 13y agoSomewhere between the bartender and the owner.
- JimmyM 13y agoSurely such a person would be literally on the level of a drug dealer?
- Nursie 13y agoAnd is this guy a terrorist or a freedom fighter? It can be very hard to tell.
- eruditely 13y agoYour moral values a complete replica of the state?
- olalonde 13y ago> This guy is sociopath and I hope he ends up in prison. Woah, that escalated quickly. This type of comment is more what I would expect from a sociopath then the mostly harmless individual described in this article. Don't you have any empathy for him? Have you considered that the author might not have depicted him in an accurate way? Don't you think prison would be a disproportionate punishment for his alleged crimes? Geez, the world is not black and white.
- greenyoda 13y agoPeople go to prison for tax evasion pretty regularly. This guy seems to be deliberately evading the NYC hotel tax on many transactions per year.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bjornsing 13y agoAnd OP continues: > Business is a zero-sum game. That's pretty much as far from "libertarian Ayn Rand disciple" as you can get. This Man That Does Not Exist sounds more like a Libertarian Straw Man, serving the purposes of a writer with an authoritarian streak.
- jasonwocky 13y agoPlenty of "disciples" cling to a few soundbites from their idols that enable them to rationalize their behavior, without ever seeking to understand their idols' broader points.
- trippy_biscuits 13y agoIsn't his logic/mentality the same as those who speed while driving?