2 ms·
In the technology world, 18 months is still a very long time. It's actually even worse now since the US switched to first-to-file. Suppose you invent somethin
by lisper 13y ago
In the technology world, 18 months is still a very long time.
It's actually even worse now since the US switched to first-to-file. Suppose you invent something and show it to your buddy, Fred. Fred can then turn around and patent your invention, and then sue you for using it. And unless you took the precaution of patenting it yourself or formally publishing it to establish prior art, Fred will win. The fact that you actually invented it doesn't matter.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoThe fact you invented it means you have prior art. Proving it in court may be hard, but the patent is legally invalid if it counts as a "public" disclosure (cf Windsurfer vs Tabor Marine [it's been a long time I may have misremembered that caselaw it's Australian IIRC but the principle is the same]). There is no requirement for "formal publication". It needs to be disclosed in public, that could be a photo on your Facebook, showing a person in the pub with the public present, anything. The fact that you invented it gives you absolute indemnity in the law and a public disclosure invalidates any subsequent patent application. But as always you can't protect against being sued for anything.
- lisper 13y ago> It needs to be disclosed in public, that could be a photo on your Facebook, showing a person in the pub with the public present, anything. No, this is not enough. You have to be able to prove in court of law that you disclosed it when you said you did, and that your disclosure was in fact a disclosure of the invention in question. So a blog post that says, "I just invented this cool widget" is not enough. Even a blog post with a detailed description may not be enough unless you have some way of proving that you did not go back and edit the post after the fact. And in my scenario where you don't make a public disclosure but just show the thing to your friend Fred who then decides to stab you in the back, you will almost certainly have no recourse whatsoever. In theory, yes, the fact that you invented it and Fred didn't protects you. In practice, to avail yourself of this protection you have to prove that Fred didn't invent it independently, and that will be nearly impossible for you to prove if Fred is even a remotely competent backstabber. (And, of course, in actual practice it won't be Fred, it will be FredCo, Inc.)
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoYes, as it's tort law the measure is usually that you have to show beyond reasonable doubt that something is true in order for it to be considered fact by the court. I did point this out in the post but it's kinda implicit within the topic of law that courts require proof. For the avoidance of doubt - any public disclosure which you can show beyond reasonable doubt to have been made prior to the priority date of the application may be used to invalidate the patent. [Jurisdictions vary but AFAIK this is now true both before the USPTO and EPO and member state's offices]. Is it really necessary to point out that it has to disclose the invention. Or that it has to be public within the legal definition. Do you want to go in to how "prior" should be interpreted?