3 ms·
> They make use of many specialist databases, extensive internet searches (carefully tailored not to disclose novel material), journals relevant to the art. Ho
by belorn 13y ago
> They make use of many specialist databases, extensive internet searches (carefully tailored not to disclose novel material), journals relevant to the art.
How is that contrary to the core concept of the assumption that "Government knows everything"? If they do use specialist databases (source?), and subscribe to journals, it is still simply just more files collected in their computer system, which patent examiners use when searching key words/phrases located in the patent application.
A few months, there was a article here on HN about how patent writers carefully choose words in patent application just so key word searching Google and patent databases won't result in prior art. The industry that writes the large mass of patents knows how to exploit the mismatch according to a word/phrase system.
Europe patent offices might have a current better time dealing with this, since the brute force method illustrated in the article do not exist here. Like with SQL injections, its harder to do an exploit without the possibility to try until the claim string matches.
- pbhjpbhj 13y ago[to reiterate I can't address the specifics of the USPTO, but can address how patent search and examination work from personal experience] >which patent examiners use when searching key words/phrases located in the patent application. // You said examiners only search patent documents in their computer systems. That's just wrong. There are many commercial databases of technology - IBM's Technical Disclosure Bulletins (TDB) that they used for defensive publication for example or compendiums of papers from various scientific journals. All areas of technology have trade magazines that give details of current tech, enough to provide a suggestion of where to search in more detail. Of course the internet is a vast resource too >how patent writers carefully choose words in patent application just so key word searching Google and patent databases won't result in prior art // Can you link that. It sounds like nonsense. Claims use language such as "fixing means" to allow breadth to the legal monopoly defined encompassing all relevant/possible forms of fixation - glue, screws, bolts, magnetics, welding, flexible retention. Searches are made for the idea, not the language used to express it. Again, it's not about string matching. If it were then it would be a simple computerised process. Example of sources of non-patent disclosures - http://www.delphion.com/search-prior_art#tdb http://www.delphion.com/search-prior_art#tdb, http://www.questel.com/index.php/en/product-and-services/prior-art-and-alert http://www.questel.com/index.php/en/product-and-services/pri... [questel orbit], http://www.sciencedirect.com/ http://www.sciencedirect.com/. It used to be that the UK PO had console based access (eg telnet) to create search queries against these (and other) databases. Now of course the web is [often] used as the interface medium.
- belorn 13y agoIt was posted 4 month ago under the title "Victory Lap for Ask Patents" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6084110 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6084110) "The second technique to getting bad software patents issued is to use a thesaurus. Often, software patent applicants make up new terms to describe things with perfectly good, existing names. A lot of examiners will search for prior art using, well, search tools. They have to; no single patent examiner can possibly be aware of more than (rounding to nearest whole number) 0% of the prior art which might have invalidated the application." While searches are made with the intention of finding the idea, no human made search engine can search for an concept. Search engines work on words. The semantic web tried to make a web searchable by concept and failed, and the closest second best is google (which only work for popular forms of the English language). Patent examiners could brute force and search for any synonym associated with each term and phrase, including those not making any sense in context, and use that to find prior art. Doubtful to the point of not a chance. However, going back to core augment here about a system that assumes that the government knows everything, and lets apply the same logic to the justice system. The police do all the evidence gathering, so why do they not simple judge and decide verdict themselves. After all, if we assume they know everything there is to know, why should the state doubt itself in deciding the outcome? Why should the justice system ever doubt the government expertise, and do a costly and slow judgement, hearing all side, and then weight it all as if the government expertise might not always be 100% right all the time? Is it enough that the police actually go and look outside the officer to collect evidence (like accessing outside databases or do internet searches)? Will that make them 100% right all the time?