3 ms·
Note that the actual original title of this piece is "The Power of No", which is plainly much less informative than the subtitle, which I actually submitted ("H
by lisper 13y ago
Note that the actual original title of this piece is "The Power of No", which is plainly much less informative than the subtitle, which I actually submitted ("How a simple change could fix the patent system -- but it will never happen" just in case the mods change my submission). c.f. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6834019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6834019
And yes, I realize that this submission directly contradicts my earlier vow not to submit direct links any more. What I didn't realize at the time I made that vow was that it directly contradicts explicit HN posting guidelines. I think that particular part of the guidelines is counterproductive, but as long as the guidelines are what they are I will respect them. But I will also keep pointing out why I think they should be changed.
- tocomment 13y agoSorry, dumb question. What's a direct link and why can't you submit them?
- lisper 13y agoThere are two kinds of HN submissions: URLs, and text submissions. What I called a "direct link" is a URL submission. An "indirect link" would be a text submission with an embedded URL, but these turn out to be specifically disallowed by the HN submission guidelines. (I didn't know that when I wrote the submission referred to in the upstream comment.)
- Dylan16807 13y agoThe guidelines are contradictory. If you want a title that properly explains the article and its relevance to HN you're supposed to make a blog post. But at the same time you're not supposed to submit blog spam. So if you're not going to write an essay about an article there is no way to simultaneously fix a bad title and obey the guidelines.