3 ms·
Why was my title edited? It said "How reddit tried to solve the "new link" problem/ why HN doesn't need a new algo" How is this new title an improvement? I w
by jedberg 13y ago
Why was my title edited?
It said "How reddit tried to solve the "new link" problem/ why HN doesn't need a new algo"
How is this new title an improvement? I would at least expect a comment here when a title is edited as to why so I can learn for next time.
- drakaal 13y agoNot an admin, so I can't tell you for sure. Lots of times they edit titles they feel are designed to "game" the HN audience. Posting "why hn doesn't need a new algo" if you aren't part of the HN team likely was viewed as either misrepresentation, or an attempt to game. I don't have any direct insight just my experience in the past.
- nkohari 13y agoIn that case, it seems odd to allow the original post title of Why Hacker News should use a different Deterministic Algorithm, Not a Random One but not jedberg's.
- amerika_blog 13y agoHN uses the editorial approach to content, figuring that having some people edit user-supplied content will make it more standard and enjoyable, like a newspaper. I have some doubts about this as well.
- jedberg 13y agoThat's great and all, but in a newsroom, when the editor changes your title, they tell you why so you can do better next time. That is what is missing here.
- tommo123 13y agoThat's not true at all. What newsroom did you work in that had journalists writing their own titles and expecting even a modicum of influence over the final product once it has been handed in?
- glifchits 13y agoGetting feedback on your work is not the same as having influence over it.
- bennyg 13y agoA good editor will do that. It's about teaching and preparing journalists to be great.
- jedberg 13y agoI sat next to the Wired newsroom for a few years, and they certainly did it.
- rhizome 13y agoDoesn't history tell us that it's very common for reporters not to write their own headlines?
- mparr4 13y agoI work in a newsroom, albeit a small one--a public radio station--and we do that. I also have the freedom to tell my bosses "no" so I expect my newsroom is probably in the minority. Interesting side note: We're growing in a small market (Vermont) at a time when most newsrooms are shrinking or even collapsing, especially the small markets. Sure, correlation is not causation, but I would argue that the culture plays no small part in our success.
- amerika_blog 13y ago> That's great and all, but in a newsroom, when the editor changes your title, they tell you why so you can do better next time. I agree that would be nice. However, as you know from running a busy site, it's not always possible to give such feedback, or you'd drown under emails. I'm thinking of /r/redditrequest or any of the methods of reporting things like doxxing to the mods, which usually don't get any feedback for the user. My interest is this: I think content needs to be edited for maximal reading potential. That in turn leads to the question as to whether Reddit/HN are more like links lists (MetaFilter, blogs) or more like discussion forums (phpBB, vbulletin, etc). By "more like" I mean as communities, not as software.
- jedberg 13y agoYou know how we avoided this problem at reddit? We didn't edit the user's submissions. :)
- amerika_blog 13y agoI understand, but for devil's advocacy sake, that leads to other problems for the content reader, such as: * Duplicates. Endless duplicates. * Rejection of good content because the headline is bad. * Essentially outsourcing this function to subreddit mods, who have only rejection at hand. If someone mods a subreddit, and they see a submission that's perfect except the person misspelled "intimacy" in the title, they have two options only: * Accept it as it is. * Reject/delete it and get the user to submit again. There's a bit of high overhead there, and less of a powerful experience for the reader. I think that matters less with Reddit's mostly 15-25 audience but is more important here.
- ClayFerguson 13y agoAt least they didn't censor you when you posted the note saying they edited your content. If they wanted to they could have just deleted that too. I think any sort of censorship at all, once the word gets out, will be damaging to HackerNews, and they should stop doing it before it becomes their "reputation". Communities like this can form elsewhere. Hopefully they know they have no monopoly, and should err on the side of NON-censorship at all times.
- jedberg 13y agoIt wasn't censorship. Only governments can censor. HN is a private organization and has every right to do anything they want with the content. My only request was for feedback.
- markburns 13y ago> Only governments can censor. Bit of a side issue, but that's an interesting statement, I've never heard that before. A quick google doesn't seem to back that up, so I wonder what I'm missing, or why you said that?
- munchbunny 13y agoI think that's in the legal context: the US government is bound to the 1st Amendment, which has usually been interpreted broadly to apply to (almost) everything the government does. So when the US government does the censoring, it's often questionably legal. However, private organizations aren't usually bound by the same rules, so there's no law against a private organization doing the same thing. I suppose we can call it "censoring" in both cases, but usually only one of the cases is an actual violation of the law.
- arjie 13y agoWhen Americans use the word 'censorship' they seem to explicitly refer to censorship in the context of the First Amendment to the US Constitution. By the general meaning of the word, of course anyone can censor anyone else but in America it is meant to be "censorship that violates the First Amendment". I'm not American. It's just the best explanation I can come up with why this view is so common.
- rhizome 13y agoAs a reader, I'd say that only one title is necessary, so maybe they just took the first one. Also, sorry, but your post is pretty poorly written so it's kind of hard to figure out which of the titles better applies.