4 ms·
Getting to the moon is not a technology challenge (we've shown it can be done with 1960's era technology) it's a financial one. It's hugely expensive. I'm not s
by ams6110 13y ago
Getting to the moon is not a technology challenge (we've shown it can be done with 1960's era technology) it's a financial one. It's hugely expensive. I'm not sure how you "exploit" the resources of the moon when it's entirely cost-prohibitive just to get there and return.
- vanderZwan 13y ago> it's entirely cost-prohibitive just to get there and return. On the other hand, the scientific advances required to solve that issue would probably have wondrous consequences even for transportation that doesn't leave the planet.
- adventured 13y agoChina is the only country capable of conquering that financial challenge. Next to using SpaceX + robots, China is the only entity that can build something on the moon. It helps that they have both the industrial base (as America did in the 1960s), cheap labor and are ascendant on wealth. Once China masters the basics I believe they'll find it much easier than most expect to build a small colony on the moon. Many people may die in the process, but that's likely to be a sacrifice they're willing to make (which many countries would not be). If you're willing to fail a lot more often - resulting in deaths - you can reduce costs significantly and expedite the timeline. The Soviets demonstrated that in many ways space can be brute forced if you're less worried about death. Strap people to rockets and shoot them at the moon, many will make it there intact.
- kgabis 13y agoThe Soviets demonstrated that in many ways space can be brute forced if you're less worried about death. Strap people to rockets and shoot them at the moon, many will make it there intact. Not really. "By space program, 18 NASA astronauts (4.1%) and four Russian cosmonauts (0.9% of all the people launched) died while in a spacecraft." [0] [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_accidents_and_incidents http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_acc...
- gaius 13y agoWhen there's a viable fusion reactor requiring He3, the economics of moon-mining will change.
- nabla9 13y agoEven then, building separate deuterium-tritium fusion reactors that produce He3 for He-He fusion reactors could be more financially sound idea.
- loceng 13y agoWe should not touch our moon. We shouldn't extract anything from it, and we should add very little to it. Earth's weather depends on it, so unless we're trying to manage our weather and its gravitational pull, etc.. then we shouldn't touch it.. and we shouldn't be trying to play with our Earth's moon unless we need to for some unexpected solar event.
- chr1 13y agoIf we don't touch it, it eventually will go away from our earth. We should develop technology to be able to keep our moon.
- loceng 13y agoThat would be 10s to 100s thousands of years from now..
- UnFleshedOne 13y agoWhat exactly could we do to it that would affect its mass significantly? Ship a significant mass back to earth? If things come to that scale, it can be easily corrected by dropping asteroids on it to balance the mass loss. This sounds like a "we shouldn't have any fusion or fission in space!" argument.
- loceng 13y agoThat might be a possibility.
- anonymfus 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coon_2:_Hindsight http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coon_2:_Hindsight
- loceng 13y agoI don't watch Southpark - but that sounds like a funny episode.
- 13y ago
- moocowduckquack 13y agoConstantly replenished surface water + solar panels = rocket fuel with only 1/6th G of gravity well tax.
- nabla9 13y agoI find the argument for minerals to be off at least few orders of magnitudes financially, >"The Moon is full of resources - mainly rare earth elements, titanium, and uranium, which the Earth is really short of, and these resources can be used without limitation. Titanium is ninth-most abundant element in the Earth's crust. Normal soil contains 0.5% - 1.5% titanium. All we need is energy for the process of separating them. Rare earth elements are expensive but not so expensive that we need to go to the moon. After we have used all conventional mines for rare earth, we can get them from the bottom of the sea more economically (see for example: http://www.nature.com/news/2011/110703/full/news.2011.393.html http://www.nature.com/news/2011/110703/full/news.2011.393.ht... ) Uranium would be incredibly expensive if it would be mined on the moon. In theory HE3 mining could be viable, unless investments in deuterium+tritium fusion reactor that would produce HE3 for helium reactors is better investment.
- monkeynotes 13y agoSeems to me it is a technological challenge to improve the efficiency of getting to and from the moon.
- chj 13y agoHow can you find a way to drive the cost down if you are not doing it at all? The resources don't need to be returned to earth if they can be put to immediate use on moon station.