9 ms·
We all know that OSC is a horrible bigot, right? I feel like any sort of fatherly advice he emits needs to be suffixed with "...unless you're gay, then you shou
by PhasmaFelis 13y ago
We all know that OSC is a horrible bigot, right? I feel like any sort of fatherly advice he emits needs to be suffixed with "...unless you're gay, then you should be in prison."
- ankitml 13y agoThere is no reason to not listen his views on software, if he has weird views on homos. He is a horrible bigot when it comes to gays. We as logical rationalists should stop labeling someone as 'Insert some hateful word' and ignore everything what he says. This is occurring more and more these days, if we dont like someone's economic views we label him as communist and completely stop hearing him. Few days back someone mentioned; Zed shaw is too cocky, so whatever he says is shit.
- andyjohnson0 13y agoThe article isn't about software; its about people who happen to working in the software industry. And the problem with people like Card is that their prejudices are a sign that their understanding of other people, and their capability for basic human empathy, is just fundamentally broken. Hence the lazy, stereotyped description of "coders", "players", etc. in the piece. I do agree that we shouldn't ignore everything he says because of this. He might still have something useful to say about things that don't involve people. Trees, for example.
- ankitml 13y agoHe may have better understanding of people who make software. His understanding of gays doesnt have a problem, his perception of gays has. According to his twisted value system they are bad people. However his understanding of software people is not clouded by his values. In any case I am only trying to defend him because I saw people just read his name from article title and decided they should not read it full. So please go ahead read what he has to say, then decide if he is correct or not instead of judging article beforehand. My 2 cents.
- andyjohnson0 13y ago"He may have better understanding of people who make software. His understanding of gays doesnt have a problem, his perception of gays has." There is no such thing as "software people". Just as there is no such thing "farmer people", "construction people", or "aeroplane people". They are all just people. And I don't understand your understanding/perception distinction. "So please go ahead read what he has to say, then decide if he is correct or not instead of judging article beforehand." My comment was posted over ninety minutes after reading the article. I really don't know on what basis you assumed otherwise. And I'm away to fight the android emulator now.
- vinceguidry 13y ago> Zed shaw is too cocky, so whatever he says is shit. I don't find Zed's views on programming to be terribly insightful either. I have a hunch that one directly leads to the other. I watched a talk he did about Javascript, several times, making sure I understood what he was saying when he was calling it a pile of shit, and walked away with the realization that Zed either didn't understand basic OOP, or did at some point then decided that it wasn't sexy anymore. Because all the problems he found could be easily fixed with basic SOLID techniques. I have a hunch that his "Learn XXX the hard way" books wouldn't be very helpful either, the tone set in the title indicates to me that instead of translating good principles to code, he's going to beat us over the head with a bottom-up approach to learning a language rather than the saner way. All of this points to Zed as someone trying to fit the world to his personality, rather than trying to truly understand the world as it is. His first response to some programming thing not fitting in with the way he thinks it should is to lambast it as stupid, this goes with languages, other developers, pretty much anything. Now, that's not exactly "Zed's cocky, so everything he says sucks," but what it does mean is that unless you have Zed's personality, you're not going to get much out of what he has to say. Because you won't approach problems the same way he does. Personally I prefer Giles Bowkett, whose tone and personality doesn't get in the way of his ideas. When something gets in his way, he works around it (with a small amount of cursing) rather than call it shit for 30 minutes. His books solve problems rather than creates them. So while criticizing a person's personality isn't, by itself, the way to enlightenment, you shouldn't completely ignore such things, either. Because if you look closely enough, these traits will point to the deeper problems with their ideas that you do need to come to a fuller understanding.
- jerlundy 13y agoIrrelevant.
- adamnemecek 13y agoNice ad hominem.
- swombat 13y agoWe do, but that seems like a fairly off-topic comment in this case, since this is an article about software companies... What I also know is he's a pretty terrible writer - Ender's Game is fantastic, but the sequels are progressively worse and worse in a horrifying fashion that boggles the mind until you realise that OSC is someone who has a very, very basic understanding (or lack thereof) of human relationships and politics... Makes one think that Ender's Game was a bit of a fluke. But that's totally off-topic.
- jacalata 13y agoIt seems pretty on topic to question advice about people management from someone who you think has a poor grasp on how people work.
- saraid216 13y ago> Makes one think that Ender's Game was a bit of a fluke. Ender's Game was about as bad as the rest on that count...
- Crito 13y agoThe reason why people don't pick up on Card's shit writing while reading Enders Game is because in Enders Game he substitutes "actually writing complex characters that develop as the story progresses" with "child characters who merely become less foolish as the story progresses". It is a surprisingly common cop-out, making a character a child is a great way to disguise the fact that they only grow in one dimension.
- sanoli 13y agoI didn't even think Eder's Game was great or anything. Just an ok SF story. Now, reading your argument, it makes sense. Back in my mind I was probably thinking "What's so great about these little kids learning some shit and growing a couple of years?"
- alandarev 13y agoOh, I must be easily impressionable then. Quite enjoyed the language it was written in. I cannot argue the advice being fully valid, but some points he outlined are exactly what I have been observing so far.
- barking 13y agoYou should consider what you just wrote and and what it says about you.
- SwellJoe 13y agoOne shouldn't feel obligated to be tolerant of intolerance expressed by people with power and privilege against those who have less power and privilege (like a wealthy, straight, white male attacking LGBTQ folks). That's a very common tactic of bigots to claim that being told they should stop oppressing people is oppressive toward them. Demanding an end to oppression is not oppressive toward those who currently benefit from that oppression.
- barking 13y agoThe linked page doesn't mention gays once, it's about programming. The post I replied to, seemed to me to suggest that everthing OSC says about anything can be discounted because he is judged to be anti-gay. We're not going to listen to him on anything from now on unless perhaps he recants and does penance for his sins
- SwellJoe 13y agoThere are other good reasons not to listen to OSC, like having never run a software company or been a significant participant in the software industry. But, I think it's OK to point out that the guy is a backward bigot and is driven by his religion more than good sense; it speaks to his character and to his approach to the world. If his views on life, society, law, and everything else, are shaped by a fairy tale (and they are), I'd like to know it.
- Lolecule 13y agoIt's not being tolerant of intolerance to consider his views on an entirely disparate topic. If his views on LGBTQ people were being discussed, then yes they are repellant and I would say so, but they have nothing to do with the topic at hand. Judging all of someone's views as wrong because some of their views are wrong is foolish. As for the article itself, I found it to be overly stereotypical and lacking in actual insight.
- gscott 13y agoYou have some heavy duty hate going on to dislike everything a person does because of their opinion on another matter.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoYeah, funny how it colors your opinion of a guy's reliability when he wants you and your friends thrown in prison as a warning to others. Crazy, I know!
- xmonkee 13y agoIt's understandable, but doesn't make it right. I personally dislike his opinions enough not to pay a dollar to watch his movies or read his books. I might even be loathe to give him enough respect to read this article, but that's a prejudice and it's not right.
- grammaton 13y agoThis presumes that every belief and idea occupies an equal plane of legitimacy, and that everything is basically a matter of opinion. It's not. His views are not acceptable. He's free to voice them all he likes, of course, but choosing to ignore him completely on the basis of some of his unacceptable views is not, in any way, "prejudice." Do keep in mind, please, that on the basis of just one thing - someone's sexual orientation - this guy is willing to give them legal status as second class citizens and incite armed rebellion against any government that would recognize their rights as people. If he's willing to do something that bad to someone solely on the basis of their sexual preferences, why on earth should anyone feel the least bit bad about choosing to simply ignore him on the basis of one of his beliefs?
- gscott 13y agoI believe what you want to say is that you want to declare war on him for his beliefs. Go after his writing works, even decades in the past, go after him for his current works, and seek to destroy him because he has a difference of opinion with him.
- simonh 13y agoIf we ignore everything ever said by people with nasty beliefs, we'd basically never read anything written more than 100 years ago, and a decent chunk of the stuff written since. Anti-slavery campaigners in to 1800s used to beat their children. Pretty much every writer in antiquity was either a slaver or pederasts by modern standards. Where do you stop? It's worth being aware of so you know to take such things into account, you never know when such views might introduce an unwritten assumption or colour a conclusion, but if it's not relevant to the material then it's a side issue.
- ghshephard 13y agoThe difference here, is that it's not the 1800s, and OSC continues to not just hold, but evangelize his hateful positions. See: http://www.nauvoo.com/library/card-hypocrites.html http://www.nauvoo.com/library/card-hypocrites.html for one of the reasons people find him repellent. Choice quote (after he had a chance to reflect on the response to his essay): "...it has become clearer and clearer to me, since writing this essay, that gay activism as a movement is no longer looking for civil rights, which by and large homosexuals already have. Rather they are seeking to enforce acceptance of their sexual liaisons as having equal validity with heterosexual marriages, to the point of having legal rights as spouses, the right to adopt children, and the right to insist that their behavior be taught to children in public schools as a completely acceptable "alternative lifestyle." It does not take a homophobe to recognize how destructive such a program will be in a society already reeling from the terrible consequences of "no-fault" divorce, social tolerance of extramarital promiscuity, and failing to protect our adolescents until they can channel their sexual passions in a socially productive way. Having already lost control of the car, we now find the gay activists screaming at us to speed up as we drive headlong toward the cliff."
- ribs 13y agoIt's just a fact that even people with repugnant beliefs about certain classes of people can still make complete sense in other domains.
- 13y ago
- myhf 13y agoOnce you realize that 100% of his writing is about the self-hating gay Mormon experience, you notice a lot more subtext. In this piece, the junior programmer who becomes a middle-manager to please the marketers is a metaphor for gay Mormons who marry women to please the church.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Shahor 13y agowtf did I just read :s
- bsenftner 13y agoI agree! Some of you are painting a fiction here with your overzealous OSC bashing.
- jessaustin 13y agoI've read a great deal of OSC's work, and I've found nothing to contradict (and much to confirm) your hypothesis. Several of the gay characters in Songmaster (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Songmaster http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Songmaster) are stand-ins for the author, and the same themes and situations are addressed (perhaps in more oblique fashion) in the more popular Ender's Game.
- tadaaaa 13y agoOrson is probably a repressed gay himself, but it's impossible for him to admit this to himself. That's why he has to hate gays so much.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- xmonkee 13y agoSeriously, that makes sense. Ender with the weird sister (non)incest situation is a stand-in for the author. He's not actually a bad person, just really repressed?
- tomc1985 13y agoYes, because every word out of a bigot's mouth is horrible, regardless of content or context.... [/sarcasm] Horrible people sometimes say good things... Good people sometimes say horrible things...
- yummyfajitas 13y agoYour characterization of OSC is incorrect. He only believes sodomy laws should be used carefully to make sure people don't "shake the confidence of the community", and that most homosexuals should not be jailed. http://www.nauvoo.com/library/card-hypocrites.html http://www.nauvoo.com/library/card-hypocrites.html I don't agree with OSC, and I doubt he'd like me very much due to my propensity for casual sex and my desire to abolish state marriage. That said, I do share his distaste for the gay rights movement's propensity to attack and attempt to blacklist and attack their opponents. I feel this tendency to eschew rational argument, push intellectually dishonest positions and attack those who disagree is very dangerous. And I won't be subscribing to your blacklist of Card and other folks who don't buy into the modern orthodoxy. I'm curious though - Communism has been far more harmful to the world than opposition to gay marriage. Do you also favor bringing back the anti-communist blacklists of the McCarthy era?
- PhasmaFelis 13y ago> Your characterization of OSC is incorrect. He only believes sodomy laws should be used carefully to make sure people don't "shake the confidence of the community", and that most homosexuals should not be jailed. Ah. Yes. My mistake. He thinks only the uppity gay folks should be thrown in prison in order to properly terrorize the rest, who can remain free as long as they understand how disgusting and shameful they are and don't try to corrupt decent folks. You really think that's different? You really think that's better? > I'm curious though - Communism has been far more harmful to the world than opposition to gay marriage. Do you also favor bringing back the anti-communist blacklists of the McCarthy era? <facepalm> No. Obviously. You're confusing me with the other guy. I reserve the right to approve or disapprove of anyone I please, but I don't advocate systematic and/or governmental oppression of people I disagree with. That's what bigots do, and specifically what Card does. "Blacklist." For fuck's sake. Card wants me thrown in prison; I want people to be aware of his feelings and make their own decisions; and somehow I'm the oppressor?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe communist blacklist was merely a list of communists published the Hollywood Reporter, making studios aware of their feelings so studios could make their own decisions. It later expanded to include other communists, who's feelings the studios were made aware of in order to make their own decision. I didn't call you an oppressor. I agree with you that Card, much like the Communists in Hollywood, is an advocate of oppression. But I'm still curious - in addition to making everyone aware of anti-gay opinions to make their own decision, do you also favor making everyone aware of pro-communist opinions to make their own decision? Perhaps distributing photos of anyone wearing a Che t-shirts so others can make their own decisions [1]? (I'm not asking why you don't do it yourself, obviously you pick your own personal causes. I'm simply asking whether you would support others doing it, and if not, why not.) [1] Yes, I'm being very naughty mentioning Che, the guy who put gays into communist labor camps. Am I citing him as a homophobe or a communist? Who knows?
- chris_wot 13y agoWow, way to go. Whilst he may have some beliefs that aren't very popular or even nice, does that mean that what's in the article is bad or wrong? Perhaps you should focus on his arguments, and not on the man himself. For once, this really is an ad hominem attack!
- ronaldx 13y agoI would make an ad hominem attack, yes. I don't believe ad hominem is fallacious in this sense. Orson Scott Card has expressed such a lack of humanity elswhere that I do not understand why I would spend my time deciding whether his other arguments have any merit. He has disqualified himself from my consideration.
- xmonkee 13y agoI don't think that qualifies for an ad hominem at all. It's only ad hominem if the factor you're dismissing the author due to happens to be irrelevant to his current argument. That's not the case, I agree. Having said that, I just want to make it clear that I don't know enough about him to agree with your position on him. I know he's anti-gay, and I've read the Ender books. That's about it.
- Crito 13y agoTry reading "A Memory of Earth". It was the thirds and last Card book I read, after I read Enders Game and Enders Shadow, and disliked both, I was told that maybe I should just read a non-Ender book since I clearly just had something against the Ender universe. I saw "A Memory of Earth" at a yardsale for a dollar so I bought it without knowing anything about it besides that it was Card, and not Ender-universe. Actually, don't try reading it. It is literally the worse book I've ever read. Confused and idiotic plot, cliched one dimensional characters, a serious sense of confused genre.... A few years later, I looked the book up on wikipedia and learned that it is his sci-fi version of The Book of Mormon.... yeah, the guy is a total hack.
- chris_wot 13y agoThe author has nothing to do with the substance of the article. If you cannot see that, I'm truly sorry for you.
- theorique 13y agoYes, the left never shuts up about it. I deplore his views, and Ender's Game was still a great book. People are complex.
- rmc 13y agoYes, people who are denied their rights, beaten up and killed tend to get annoyed about it. They have a right to be annoyed.
- theorique 13y agoOf course, but we've all heard the message a million times and we get it: bigotry is bad, OSC is a bigot against gays, and hence he is bad. No argument from me about those known truths. But does it have to be repeated every time the man's name gets mentioned like we don't know it?
- grammaton 13y agoMaybe because, in every audience, there are some people who have been beaten, or know people who have been beaten or killed, because of beliefs like this? Folks who've watched someone get their teeth kicked out over the sexual orientation tend to get a little...passionate...when a known homophobe's name comes up. They might even mention this out loud!
- altero 13y agoWhat if someone gets beaten up by minority members? Or does not get a job thanks to positive discrimination?
- 127 13y agoThis is curiously always stated, but never referred or quoted, even out of context. If you're going to make strong assertions on persons character you better have the ability to back it up. It's not my job to dig up this material.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI really like his writing though. I sort of view him a bit like a crazy old uncle, who can do amazing things, but you just shouldn't let him near your neighbors when he visits. Personally, I suspect that he is in denial anyway.
- nathan_long 13y agoI was hoping to see some discussion of the points he makes about how developers relate to business. How is your comment relevant to the article? It's like saying, "You wouldn't learn algebra from a COMMUNIST, would you?"
- mabbo 13y agoThere are many people on this planet who are brilliant, but flawed. If you disregard all the brilliance because you dislike the flaws, you miss out. Tom Cruise has made some fantastic films. But Scientology... The Scopes Monkey trial eventually lead to evolution being taught in (most) schools... but Scopes was apparently pretty okay with Eugenics. Mel Gibson was Mad Max... But he's a racist. Fred Phelps won some important Civil Rights cases in the 60s... but Westboro Baptist Church, wtf man? Card is a tool in his personal life, and I'll fight him tooth and nail on those issues. I still loved Ender's Game, and I still found this article cute and fun to read. Even a stopped clock is right twice a day.
- sologrrl 13y agoThis whole subthread is a perfect example of why collapsible comments are badly needed on HN. All heat and no light.