4 ms·
"the device used to take the blood pressure reading, if I understand things right, did have to be approved by the FDA" that is true, the FDA would bust a mfgr
by VLM 13y ago
"the device used to take the blood pressure reading, if I understand things right, did have to be approved by the FDA"
that is true, the FDA would bust a mfgr of a device that claimed to report blood pressure but instead did astrology. This specific example of 23andme is, as near as I can tell, getting busted for interpreting the results, not for using 'cat /dev/urandom' to generate the results and then interpreting them.
Kind of like the same FCC that gets excited about out of band RF interference also got sorta excited by janet jackson's halftime show.
- judk 13y agoHow did you use both FDA and FCC correctly and then fail to notice they are not the same word?
- ajcarpy2005 13y agoHe didn't fail to notice they're different agencies. He is asserting that they both (being both government agencies) have each been inconsistent in their regulation.
- jrochkind1 13y agoI am not sure there is as big a black-and-white distinction between 'providng' and 'interpreting' as you suggest. 23andme is a 'device' that takes a bodily fluid sample as input, and provides genetic information as output. A an automated blood pressure cuff is a device that, well, I don't know how it works, but wikipedia says it "They do not measure systolic and diastolic pressures directly, per se, but calculate them from the mean pressure and empirical statistical oscillometric parameters", whatever that means, and produces some blood pressure numbers as output. 23andme is obviously a much more complex 'device'. Both both take some sort of measurement of your person, and then provide medical information. Even if you could somehow draw a line at some point in this process of translation from physical measurements to medical information, some point at which the 'interpretation' begins, I'm not sure why one would suggest that either side of that line would be exempt from FDA regulation!
- Dylan16807 13y ago>23andme is a 'device' that takes a bodily fluid sample as input, and provides genetic information as output. I don't think that's true, which is the problem. They don't just provide genetic information. They provide information detailing the impact of those genes, as medical science understands them. >Even if you could somehow draw a line at some point in this process of translation from physical measurements to medical information, some point at which the 'interpretation' begins, I'm not sure why one would suggest that either side of that line would be exempt from FDA regulation! Neither side would be exempt, but the physical side would be trivially approved as "yes, this does in fact measure those genes, good work everyone, pop the champagne".