7 ms·
Not all of it is reasonable, at all: "For instance, if the BRCA-related risk assessment for breast or ovarian cancer reports a false positive, it could lead a
by dnautics 13y ago
Not all of it is reasonable, at all:
"For instance, if the BRCA-related risk assessment for breast or ovarian cancer reports a false positive, it could lead a patient to undergo prophylactic surgery"
Uh, you don't think the surgeon is going to demand a second BRCA test be done before performing the surgery?
- mbreese 13y agoThe point isn't necessarily the second test (which would have to be done). It's also the emotional distress caused by a potential false positive, which could be severe. You could imagine in an extreme case some one finding a result with a poor prognosis and deciding to commit suicide. Now, if that result was a false positive, you can see where you'd want to have some assurances that their test was accurate. This is an extreme example, and I have no knowledge that it ever happened, but it is possible. This might not even require a technical fix with the test, but rather a marketing and reporting of results.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoFrom what I understand, the test doesn't attempt to diagnose an existing condition. Instead, it shows whether you have a gene that indicates a predisposition to the condition. In that case, prophylactic measures can be taken, once confirmed and if desired. This is what drove Angelina Jolie's decision to have a double-mastectomy. That's a hugely significant difference vs. actually being diagnosed with a life-threatening condition. I don't think people would commit suicide or become unduly despondent if they learned they have a gene. They would just know they need to take action, get further testing, be vigilant, etc. It's not much different (in spirit) from knowing that your family history predisposes you to a certain condition.
- mbreese 13y agoIt's all about education and results reporting. Where you or I might see a result as a predisposition to a phenotype with a statistical probability, someone else might see a death sentence. That could be one area that the FDA might be trying to address.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoI agree that it has to be clearly reported and explained. But, you know, there are in-home HIV tests that are FDA-approved. They tend to stress professional counseling and/or follow-up testing, etc. They also explain such somewhat-technical details as the window between infection and antibody formation, so it's an education process there as well. But, I think the availability of such a test is testament to the fact that easier access to important knowledge re: one's status may be worth the risks.
- mbreese 13y agoHIV tests are pretty simple, from a diagnostic test point of view. It's really a boolean - HIV present, or not present. The meaning of a particular genetic variant is much more ambiguous.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoIt's odd to me that you're saying HIV tests can give definitive devastating diagnoses to people alone in their homes, yet they are OK; but genetic testing provides a range of possibilities and recommends further investigation, but they are somehow so devastating that they would drive someone to despair or suicide.
- mbreese 13y agoI'm not trying to equate things to HIV tests, and it's probably a poor example. I'm not sure what the reporting process for an in-home HIV test would be. I recently had a doctor tell me that she's not allowed to actually give the results of an HIV test over the phone for fear of patient reactions. What I was trying to say was that that class of test should be easier to use and get a definitive yes/no answer with a smaller false positive rate.
- smackfu 13y ago>I don't think people would commit suicide or become unduly despondent if they learned they have a gene. What if the gene essentially means "you and your husband shouldn't have children?"
- Dylan16807 13y agoThey'd probably feel a hundred times worse if they found out by observing the symptoms in those future children.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoI think one can make a million hypothetical arguments against the testing. But, I just don't see people taking the test at face value and making major life decisions without further follow-up. I think most reasonable people would consider it a screen. If the testing was wildly inaccurate, then that's another issue. It almost becomes more an FTC consumer protection-type matter at that point. But, there is no indication that this is the problem. They go on to state that their testing is done in CLIA-certified laboratories: https://www.23andme.com/howitworks/ https://www.23andme.com/howitworks/ (near bottom of page) http://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Legislation/CLIA/index.html?redirect=/clia/ http://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Legislation/CLIA... BTW, I'm not really defending the service, per se. In fact, I have issues with it that are more along the privacy lines. I just don't see where there's any proof that it has an outsized chance of ruining lives any more than, say, in-home HIV testing.
- numbsafari 13y agoWithout an appropriate study to determine reasonable efficacy, it is possible that the diagnostic technique could result in a large number of false positives. This could result in a large number of unnecessary follow-up BRCA tests which could potentially increase the waiting time for test results or unduly raise costs for lots of patients. Not to mention the stress of feeling like you may be suffering from a potentially expensive and life-threatening illness. So: totally reasonable.
- judk 13y agoWhy more than 1 follow up test?
- gorner 13y agoMultiple unneeded follow-up tests across the population, not per person.
- grandalf 13y agoThere is always a point in any discussion of medicine where broad "public health" concerns creep in. If we really cared about public health we'd have a drastically different system. In any case I think it's hard to make a persuasive argument that if the members of the public were only kept more naive about their own health risks, public health would improve.
- grandalf 13y agoYour verdict of reasonableness depends on the idea that physicians are not going to be able to properly advise patients who they think might have gotten a false positive result. Considering that over half of American adults believe Elvis is alive, I think the small percentage who may slightly overreact to the kind of presentation that 23andme gives of these kinds of results is a complete non-issue.
- tptacek 13y agoYou seem to believe the average doctor is well-versed in the mechanics of genetic testing, or (perhaps equivalently) that the average doctor isn't wholly dependent on the mechanisms of FDA approval for product selection.
- sp332 13y agoBut if another company like 23AM pops up, they could be the "second company". If companies are not required to prove that they are reliable, then you could too easily get multiple false positives.
- dnautics 13y agono, because presumably a licenced doctor would rely on a test provider that was FDA-approved.
- Spooky23 13y agoPeople get wacky when facing things like this. Remember the stories of Steve Jobs turning to crazy diets instead of treating his cancer medically? If you dump a bunch of information in front of people who may or may not be prepared from an intellectual or emotional perspective to deal with it, they may take dramatic and unwarranted action.
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoDont take my freedom to decide because of homeopathic weirdos like Jobs. I'm not one to usually complain about the nanny state, but this is deep into nanny statism here.
- dd36 13y agoDon't take away my freedom to trust test results.
- JabavuAdams 13y agoHave you lived or travelled extensively in countries that don't have public health or regulatory infrastructure? Organizations like the FDA and EPA were created in response to very real failings. The problem for many of us who grow up benefitting from these safety nets is that we don't have a sense of how hard-won these battles were. Life is good and so we start chipping away at the "nanny state" to get a tiny little bit more freedom. Actually more like a lack of inconvenience, not really freedom. I've been thinking about this a lot lately. Is this just a natural social cycle?
- Spooky23 13y agoI don't think it's a natural social cycle, it's the outgrowth of the general mistrust of government that has festered over the last 30-40 years or so. I don't think that our political institutions have dealt with the changes in the media well. The ideology that inspired the construction of these safety nets is gone for the most part -- we've degraded to bread and circuses. The political machinery on one side focuses on handing out stuff in exchange for votes, and the other side focuses on vilifying "those people". Nobody believes in anything anymore.
- HeyLaughingBoy 13y agoThat really doesn't matter. The responsibility for correct results falls on the Device Manufacturer (in this case 23&me), not on the physician that ordered the test. I work for a large Medical Device manufacturer and questions like this come up all the time when we do Hazard Analysis. While the physician (or lab rules) may require a second confirmatory test, and that may give us warm fuzzies, it really can't be considered to be a hazard mitigation. It's still up to the manufacturer to not make the mistake in the first place.