6 ms·
Google Can Bring an End to Censorship in 10 Days
- teawithcarl 13y agoGoogle Could End Censorship in China in 10 Days - Why doesn't it? http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/nov/22/google-end-china-web-censorship-10-days?CMP=twt_gu http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/nov/22/google-... This Guardian article is a "shorter version" of the original article at http://en.GreatFire.org http://en.GreatFire.org
- lazyjones 13y agoNo, because surveillance is censorship too.
- DanBC 13y agoAs far as I'm aware Google hasn't ever shot anyone in the head, which is a common occurrence in China. (China executes more people than all other nations combined. Real numbers are hard to find, but about 5,000 people in 2009 is accepted for a low end figure by most people. That's 13 per day, or one person every two hours.) Comparing Google's surveillance to Chinese totalitarian state is obscene.
- judk 13y agoWhat about when China gov hacks into Google (has already happened) (and NSA is still happening) and uses Google user data for China Govt "common occurrences"?
- FreakyT 13y agoHow is the author overlooking the most obvious course of action the Chinese government could take? China could easily block Google outright -- while the Github reversal the author mentions is certainly surprising, Google represents only a small sliver of Chinese search engine use [1] and probably wouldn't result in much of a mass outcry. [1] http://thenextweb.com/asia/2013/09/17/baidu-still-tops-chinas-search-market-with-63-share-as-merger-shakes-up-chasing-pack/ http://thenextweb.com/asia/2013/09/17/baidu-still-tops-china...
- dec0dedab0de 13y agoThe article specifically mentions China blocking Google. “Google! Do it! If they don't block you, freedom wins. If they do block you, there will be much more opposition to censorship inside China and the system will be forced to change, thus freedom wins too!”
- smoyer 13y agoThe article describes how the their (small?) group of activists is willing to "bet the house", and that the potential outcome could include Google being blocked. It's nice that they're willing to see Google blocked, but they're not actually giving up anything if that happens. Google on the other hand is a public company and has a lot more to lose if they're blocked. What would the shareholders say to Google risking the ad revenue from Chinese Internet users? And they're already fighting for marketshare with Baidu ... they could end up losing enough ground to never recover. The activists might find that tack is a far better way to proceed. Google could easily just say "switching to HTTPS is in accordance with our policies throughout the rest of the world and it's (one way) to protect Chinese users from spying by the NSA (and others). Actively redirecting blocked requests to cached pages would on the other hand offend the Chinese government and would signal Google's true intent. If you're going to be activists, you need to have a much better understanding of corporate motivations as well as become much more tuned into politics.
- teawithcarl 13y agoSincerely, that's not correct. GreatFire.org is at the cutting-edge of research (including from Harvard, Princeton, and many software engineers globally and in China) to end the censorship in China. GreatFire.org is on the front lines of solving censorship. This idea is new research that works. Google has a preponderant position in search in 125 nations, and is not hurting that much from retreating to HongKong. Baidu can't even get a foothold going in Japan. On the other hand, the blunt mercantilism which keeps Google, Twitter, YouTube, Facebook out of China stands to weaken by applying this excellent idea. Google actually may benefit by responding adroitly to the intentional evisceration of Google by the Chinese government. The beauty of this research is that it probes a blind spot in China policy not easily remedied, while hitting the one place China cares about - money and the national economy.
- est 13y agothat seems to be a great idea, google could also do Germans a favor by hosting "this video is not available in your country" mirrors, right?
- nisa 13y agoIt's Google themselves that block the videos on YouTube for German visitors. Their rationale is that this frees them from paying the fantasy fees that GEMA wants from them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blocking_of_YouTube_videos_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blocking_of_YouTube_videos_in_...
- est 13y agoguess what, China has laws that 'regulate' news and online videos, too
- lucb1e 13y ago> The code-sharing site Github uses encrypted-only access and, perhaps not intentionally, broke the pattern of Internet control in China. Encrypted-only access is not a solution, it's a patch. Here is how China could break it if they wanted to: 1. Choose domains that you want to monitor in this way. E.g. github.com. 2. Requests to any IP for that domain on port 443 will return a certificate that the Chinese government issued using CNNIC. This is trusted by at least Mozilla: http://snag.gy/E1ftE.jpg http://snag.gy/E1ftE.jpg (note to self: delete that ca) 3. Requests to any IP for that domain on port 80 will be converted to ssl. So the browser is connected over http to the ISP, and the ISP's servers will connect over https/ssl to Github. In all instances, monitoring is possible. Forcing ssl is no solution. It does make monitoring harder though, and I suppose that is a good thing already, but all the Chinese government needs to do is throw money at it and the ISPs will be able to handle this.
- livnev 13y agoSurely, this is an (admittedly broad and difficult) issue with CAs and the trust element of SSL authentication. By the theory of SSL, an 'attacker' is not supposed to have control over a 'trusted' CA, so SSL is 'supposed to' protect against this.
- lucb1e 13y agoI only thought of the Chinese govt issuing a certificate after writing half the post. Initially I was just going to comment on the easy possibility of MITM attacks. These would fail whenever anyone forced https into their address bar, but I think less than 5% of the people do that. That would mean just refusing connections for the <5% and still sniffing everyone else.
- paulgb 13y agoStrict transport security (http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_Strict_Transport_Security http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_Strict_Transport_Securit...) is an attempt to prevent exactly this. However assuming that the user is always on a MITM'd connection, a preloaded list in the browser becomes necessary.
- salient 13y agoGoogle doing this would be great, and I do support it. However, the effect would be so much greater if all US companies allied against stuff like this, and form some kind of BSA against censorship and surveillance by governments around the world. The last time Google did this with the Chinese government, I remember Microsoft was ecstatic at potentially replacing Google in China with Bing, by following the same requests Google wouldn't, from the government, just so they can win even an extra 1 percent market share (which they never did, anyway - Baidu filled the gap). As long as US companies keep screwing each other over for that extra 1 percent they can gain over their competitors in China, if they do follow China's orders, while the competitors do not, this is going to be a very hard thing to "win". So shame on those who do that.
- charliesmith 13y agoIn the past we have strongly suggested that all sites switch to HTTPS. If this happened on "World Global HTTPS Awareness Day", i.e., at about the same time, then I think China would be faced with some tough decisions.
- pdfcollect 13y agoWhat about surveillance by Google itself? What we should be asking ourself is how do we improve https://duckduckgo.com https://duckduckgo.com ? or something similar.
- tokenrove 13y agoGoogle has employees in China, and making a strong-arm motion like this could put them in danger.
- charliesmith 13y agoThat is a valid point and past Google blog posts have alluded to this danger. I made this point in the longer blog post which appears on our web site, but not in The Guardian article. http://googleblog.blogspot.co.uk/2010/01/new-approach-to-china.html http://googleblog.blogspot.co.uk/2010/01/new-approach-to-chi...
- oddx 13y agoI'm not native english speaker, so sorry if I wrong. But does Schmidt actually means '10 days'? If I understood correctly Schmidt mean that if we (all people who do internet) starts to encrypt everything (http 2?) then it will be more difficult to do censorship. And he unlikely mean 10 days, probably 10 years.
- lambda 13y agoHe meant that Google could encrypt their own traffic in 10 days, and offer mirrors of blocked websites via their cache feature; not that everyone could encrypt all traffic in 10 days.
- oddx 13y agoCan you provide quote for your interpretation? For me "You cannot stop it if it’s a good idea broadly held" sounds more about global technological and ideological shift.
- lambda 13y agoSorry, Eric Schmidt had said that we could end censorship in a decade (10 years). That's the quote at the top of the article: "We can end government censorship in a decade. The solution to government surveillance is to encrypt everything." The author of this article, "charlie", is contending that actually, Google could end it in 10 days, simply by turning on encryption for their own service and offering cached versions of any sites that are blocked. So yes, Schmidt was talking about a global technological shift, while this author was talking about a simple pragmatic step that could be taken by one company, Google, and which they already have the infrastructure for as they already do everything needed (encrypt traffic, offer caches) for their other properties.
- jpollock 13y agoAre you sure Google's big enough in China to have an impact? http://www.chinainternetwatch.com/4371/search-engine-market-update-q3-2013/ http://www.chinainternetwatch.com/4371/search-engine-market-... Even worse, that's by revenue, not searches: http://www.chinainternetwatch.com/3809/china-search-engine-market-share-update-august-2013/ http://www.chinainternetwatch.com/3809/china-search-engine-m... 3% of search is a blip. [EDIT: Fixed the links mangled by cut-n-paste from other thread]
- criley2 13y agoDid you even read the article? Eric talks about how American designed encryption paradigms will eventually introduce free speech that cannot be stopped or surveilled even in places like China. What Google's search market shares have to do with that concept is beyond me, though.
- jpollock 13y agoThe article was not about the technology, but about the ability for Google to unilaterally affect the ability for the Chinese government to surveil their population. The premise relies on Google being irreplaceable to the Chinese economy. We are gambling with Google’s stack that they are big enough and important enough that the Chinese authorities would not dare block it in mainland China completely. However, that isn't supported by the data - Google's market share. If Google did something which the government truly objected to, such as offering encrypted proxies (which encrypted search is), then they could block the entire domain and only affect the portion of their population that uses it. Market share is a good proxy to measure that population, and it's 3%. I'm not convinced that 3% is large enough to cause the government to give up.
- MichaelTieso 13y agoWhile I support the work they are doing, the Chinese themselves don't care all that much about the sites that are blocked. Having lived in China, everyone I spoke to did not care about Facebook being blocked. I'm making a huge generalization but to them if Facebook is blocked then it must not be very important. Why use Facebook anyway when I have QQ? Changing the public view from within China to fight against censorship is harder but I think it would be far more effective.
- ams6110 13y agoI supposed that encrypted search is better than not, but won't help when the NSA is tapping from inside their machine rooms.
- ywyrd 13y agoKeep in mind this quote comes from the same man who said, "If you have something that you don't want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn't be doing it in the first place."
- erichocean 13y agoI wish the correct response to that statement (and it's spiritual brother: if you've done nothing wrong, you should have nothing to hide) was as widely known as the statement itself. As an idea, it should be so thoroughly discredited by now that merely stating it approvingly marks one as either morally deficient, an idiot, or both. Making that statement should be at the same level of social disapproval as, say, suggesting genocide as a reasonable way to deal with undesirable people groups. As of today, though, regular run-of-the-mill people are unable to formulate why that statement is not just wrong, but ridiculously, appallingly so. I fear learning why will come at a rather significant cost to humanity in general. :( I guess this is how civilization moves forward. It's not pretty.
- sseveran 13y agoIf Google did encrypt traffic in China what would prevent China from serving Google China with a subpoena for the SSL private key under a gag order?
- WalterSear 13y ago"How Archer Daniels Midland could end world hunger in just 10 days" "How the United States Senate could end political gridlock in just 10 days"
- switch007 13y agoYou need an SSL certificate: Request URL: http://tripstamp.com/api/authenticate Request Method: POST
- scovetta 13y agoSSL is only a minor speed bump when you have control over trusted root CAs or the ability for "force" installation of your own CA.
- peeters 13y ago> Critics of our approach will say that the "do it, they might not block you" argument is tenuous at best. But that is not what we are saying. What we are saying is: >>“Google! Do it! If they don't block you, freedom wins. If they do block you, there will be much more opposition to censorship inside China and the system will be forced to change, thus freedom wins too!” >Win-win. I don't think the author realizes what a "win" means to corporations. Helping the cause of freedom doesn't turn losing a billion potential customers into a win, it's just the silver lining on a very dark cloud.
- charliesmith 13y agoNo - they are losing market share in search (3%) and if they keep their current course will continue to lose. The opportunity here is to gain one billion customers (well, 600 million now), by freeing the internet in China and hence at least making substantial money on ad sales.
- cbhl 13y agoI feel like this article is extremely short-sighted. If Google did the things that the author suggests, China would simply block all of Google instead. It has done this in the past, and would not hesitate to do so again.
- d0ugie 13y agoThe article postulates an effective outcry, akin to that of the github incident which resulted in success, were that to happen. Perhaps it is you who is shortsighted?
- d0ugie 13y agoA bold move such as this would, whether it worked or not, at least restore Google's credibility as an avoider of evil, the Google twinkle many of you think has fizzled.