6 ms·
The evolutionary origin of depression
- amichail 17y agoThis will change in the future: everyone will know early on in life what their capabilities are based on analysis of their DNA.
- Retric 17y agoDepression is not unique to humans. So I suspect it's a little more complex and fundamental than a failure to understand your limitations.
- tokenadult 17y agoDepression is not unique to humans. What animal model of depression do you have in mind?
- mynameishere 17y agoParrots and dogs will tear apart their environments (and sometimes their bodies) under certain circumstances, such as extended loneliness. Seems similar to human depression.
- wallflower 17y agoYes, my housemate's dog has separation anxiety which is not good (but he was adopted from a shelter). We hypothesize he gets all anxious because when we are leaving and locking him in his (reinforced) cage - he doesn't know if we'll ever return. Which is different from humans - as in we know that it is only a matter of time.
- joeyo 17y agoThis review, and its references, are a little dated, so I presume that the animal models are much more sophisticated by now: http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1440-1819.1990.tb00461.x http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1440-1819.1990.tb00461.x
- tokenadult 17y agoDo you really think that people can set all of their personal goals just from knowing their genome?
- amichail 17y agoYour genome will give you critical information about the sorts of things you would be good at. For example, an analysis of your genome might tell you that you should pursue a startup that makes use of sophisticated mathematics. The specifics of that startup are up to you.
- tokenadult 17y agoan analysis of your genome might tell you that you should pursue a startup that makes use of sophisticated mathematics. Are there any participants here who can point to some genetic research on how likely it is that genome analysis will ever be that specific on the individual level?
- wjy 17y agoI think it would be much more effective to evaluate whether you're actually good at sophisticated mathematics.
- colins_pride 17y agoMy environment shapes me far more than my genes. I know this because I'm not the same person who woke up this morning. Sure, my genes may predispose me to Alzheimers or Diabetes or cancer. They drive my physical characteristics, and maybe much more. But my essence is not pre-destined by my genes.
- 10ren 17y agoIt's an intriguing idea that seems to be associated with Soviet-era training and the mechanization of human beings, coerced into insect-like castes, as in Brave New World, and the lovely short-story Unaccompanied Sonata http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unaccompanied_Sonata http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unaccompanied_Sonata (or Ender's Game itself for that matter.) I know you don't mean coercion, but simply informed choice; but I think the rebuttal is the same: our theories are not adequate to predict such things, even if we had all the information; especially when factors like 10,000 hours of practice and motivation seem so important. At best, they can suggest a probability distribution. Or: you don't know til you try. I guess some specifics could be useful, like a probability distribution of expected height for a baby, for his/her potential as a basketball player. However, at the very young age where genome knowledge is most effective (by revealing as yet unexpressed traits). the baby is not able to make a choice. So it would effectively be Soviet-era training.
- pie 17y agoThis is one of those concepts that I always simply assumed to be true. Ordinary feelings of depression (i.e. specifically not chronic or "clinical" depression) are quite normal responses to situations that are, in fact, depressing. These feelings can help shake us out of situations we might otherwise suffer through.
- Afton 17y agoThis is interesting. I wonder if it means anything more than "depressive people are those that are unable to let go of failure"? Seems like an apt description of many generally depressed people I know. Side note: Anyone have thoughts on whether 'depression' is an umbrella term for distinct mental traits?
- tokenadult 17y agoAnyone have thoughts on whether 'depression' is an umbrella term for distinct mental traits? My sense of the evidence, as I read the masterwork on the subject http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0195135792/ http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0195135792/ just now for research I am doing, is that depression has multiple distinct causes, and a variety of particular manifestations.
- jerf 17y agoIn addition to tokenadult's comment, which I would expect is probably correct, I would relate this from my abnormal psych class: A number of conditions given the same label are known to be distinct, in that we can tell there's definitely more than one distinct thing going on, but nobody quite knows where to draw the line. Part of the purpose of the label is to give psychologists simply a word with an agreed meaning so they can discuss it with each other. As they narrow down exactly what the variants are and figure out where to draw the line, psychologists will give the variants new, separate names. This is closely analogous to the justification given in the Design Patterns book for programmers. And in both the design pattern and the DSM case, there is widespread misunderstanding about the fact that the most important thing for both is simply giving things names, since we can not talk clearly about what we do not have proper names for. Schizophrenia is the classic example, which started out as all but a synonym for "idiopathic mental disorder" and has gradually been refined into various distinct pieces, but not without controversy [1]. It remains an over-broad distinction, but of course that's because nobody really knows how to cut it down better yet. Depression definitely would seem to be very similar; just look at all the types listed here [2], which I'd hardly expect to be an exhaustive list. Certainly in the popular press, which rarely takes the time to really nail down what they are talking about, "depression" is a term so broad it has hardly any meaning beyond "I feel sad a lot". There's a lot of slicing and dicing done by the real professionals, which the popular press is entirely oblivious to. (I only sampled at the beginning, but I can at least say that's a true statement with confidence.) And there's more defining yet to be done. If you're interested in the subject, it's definitely an interesting one for hackers, seeing how the most complicated computing device known to man can go wrong. It can be... scary, though. (I don't have specific book recommendations though. Perhaps others will chime in.) 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schizophrenia#Controversies_and_research_directions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schizophrenia#Controversies_and... 2: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Types_of_psychological_depression http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Types_of_psychological_depressi...
- miloshh 17y agoInteresting hypothesis. However, isn't depression sometimes getting in the way of pursuing perfectly attainable goals? For example, finding more friends or losing a bit of weight are definitely not overly ambitious goals, but depressed people often despair that they will never be able to reach them.
- tokenadult 17y agoisn't depression sometimes getting in the way of pursuing perfectly attainable goals? It certainly plays out that way in actual medical cases, and cognitive therapy for depression is all about showing patients that they can still succeed in goal-directed behavior.
- pie 17y agoPerhaps the hypothesis would apply more to the approach/situation rather than the goal. If depressed people despair that they cannot find new friends or lose some weight, maybe the depression might direct them to try something new. That's how I see the idea presented here. (Unfortunately, you're right that many people are quick to give up and deem a goal impossible.)
- darshan 17y agoFrom the opening paragraph: [He] likens the relationship between mild and clinical depression to the one between normal and chronic pain. He sees both pain and low mood as warning mechanisms and thinks that, just as understanding chronic pain means first understanding normal pain, so understanding clinical depression means understanding mild depression. In other words, yes, people with clinical depression find that it gets in the way of their daily life. His hypothesis is about why normal, healthy people suffer from low mood / mild depression from time-to-time, and what evolutionary advantage that might give us.
- pwncat 17y agoI disagree with this argument. I think another one's more salient. For a pack animal such as primal humans probably were, a certain type of moderate depression is a survival mechanism for dealing with low social status. Your appetite and libido decrease, you become inassertive, you accept mistreatment from others. Subjectively, this process and experience sucks, but lacking desire to mate with the alpha female keeps the omega male alive. Much more importantly (since nature doesn't care much about unsuccessful individuals) it's a survival mechanism for the pack; the depressive response ensures that, in extreme scarcity, the less successful individuals slink away and accept starvation, rather than challenging and potentially causing harm to the more important ones. In modern society, this reaction is completely useless and utterly maladaptive. It also has a tendency to fire in people at all levels of social status, because modern society (with its dynamic, subtle, and multileveled play of social status) is confusing to the primal mind. So a depressive response can be rightly considered an illness. Civilization expects everyone to assume the role most closely analogous to high beta/low alpha. People who have omega traits tend to be depressives; people who have too many alpha traits are sociopaths.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- aswanson 17y agoSounds reasonable, leading to the prime exception I take with this whole line of inquiry known as "evolutionary psychology": the lack of falsifiability of any plausible hypothesis. You can handwave pretty much any narrative that somewhat fits the data and publish.
- ShardPhoenix 17y agoNot only is this particular hypothesis falsifiable, it has been more or less falsified (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection). Also, it seems to me that in these kinds of discussions, a lot of these evolutionary-psychology stories are not meant to say "this is exactly why this thing evolved", but to demonstrate that there are reasons that such a thing could evolve. A lot of this kind of thinking is probably derived from arguing with anti-evolutionists who claim that such-and-such could never have evolved because it's apparently mal-adaptive.
- diN0bot 17y agoseems more likely to me that depression doesn't get in the way of survival and reproduction.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- rriepe 17y agoMy theory on it is something between "pack" benefit and "individual" benefit. I believe that depression is beneficial to pack hunters. It goes like this: Operating in groups offers a great advantage. If a member of the group is lost, however, there follows a period of time where the group is more vulnerable. They haven't yet adapted (tactically) to a smaller group, so business as usual could end up getting them killed. A period of mourning, however, with lowered dangerous activity, puts the group in less danger while they recoup from their loss. During this time they're more likely to gain new members, train young ones or simply adapt their tactics to fit their smaller numbers. Think of it like this: Take Kobe off the team and the Lakers start to really suck. However, let them fill the fifth spot and rethink their strategies... and they start to look like a good team again.
- TheSOB88 17y agoSeems true, but I think we're talkin about a different kind of depression here than mourning over someone's death.
- b-man 17y agoI don't think the journalist did a good job when he took his conclusions as: "Depression may turn out to be an inevitable price of living in a dynamic society." That amounts to, Hey, we are doing something that hurt us as a society, but what the heck, lets all take the symptom of our mistake as a 'price' for our 'correct' path. The blind leading the wounded.
- tokenadult 17y agoHaving thought about this article for a day, I'm wondering what the view of the cited scientist is of elevated human mood states, those that correspond to pathological states of hypomania and mania. One of the tricky issues in treating depression is to avoid inducing mania.