4 ms·
Anonymity is vital for many types of discussions. Can you imagine HN working if people were required to put their name and job titles ? Just because someone wo
by threeseed 13y ago
Anonymity is vital for many types of discussions.
Can you imagine HN working if people were required to put their name and job titles ? Just because someone works for Microsoft for example does that make their support or criticism of the company any less valuable. Or what about all the political discussions where there could be legitimate fears of reprisal by government agencies.
- Anderkent 13y ago> Just because someone works for Microsoft for example does that make their support or criticism of the company any less valuable. It does not make it less valuable, but it does change how we interpret it. If I found myself commenting on my current (or previous) workspace, I'd feel obligated to disclose my relationship.
- GrinningFool 13y agoDisclosing your relationship to a company in a comment is a fair sight less than disclosing your identity to that company in the same comment. Particularly if you're a current employee.
- Anderkent 13y agoYou're right. I was considering these as two separate requirements, didn't really think of the name part.
- btown 13y agoIt's so much more than this, though. Even if you're ethically obligated to disclose your relationship with your workplace when discussing said workplace, are you ethically/legally obligated to connect your identity to your views on education policy, or on criminal incarceration, or on musical genres, or on the future of a programming language that happens to be your boss's favorite programming language? To reduce it to company criticism is to create a straw man out of the entire case for anonymity. Now, all this said, I fully expect to be "doxxed" publicly at some point on my various accounts, so I keep that in mind when making commentary, and I hedge my bets. The fact that it was Google that has prevented me from discussing things on YouTube without doxxing myself, though, is truly disappointing. Maybe they're not losing any money by losing commenters like me, but if I'm ever inspired to create viral content that could make ad money, Vimeo's getting that ad money now.
- wpietri 13y agoQuora works surprisingly well with a real names policy. They let you post particular comments anonymously if you want. Then it's pretty obvious when people are using anonymity for good reasons and when they're just being dickish. There, community voting plus some moderation polices things pretty well.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoDepends on what mean by "working well". I don't post on Quora nor do I read anything posted there because they don't let you read without logging in. I heard many others say similar things. That doesn't mean Quora isn't working well for you, but you should be aware of the fact that some who are willing to contribute in constructive ways are not contributing to Quora as things stand.
- wpietri 13y agoNo, I have big issues with them requiring authentication to browse. However, I mean "working well" in the context of the point I was replying to. That is, they get a lot of good anonymous posts, but the real names policy plus some good policing keeps the bullshit [1] to a minimum. [1] http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/greater-internet-fuckwad-theory http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/greater-internet-fuckwad-theor...
- codezero 13y agoYou can read anything on Quora if you add ?share=1 to the end of the URL.
- vidarh 13y agoIt's not even necessarily always anonymity, but about being able to break the most obvious links. It's easy to find my name from my HN userid. If you google it, my first name comes up tied to other accounts. But if you search for my name, HN does not come up on the first page at least. Nevertheless, I'm sort-of conscious that what I post on HN is easy to tie to me real-world. On Reddit, I use another username. Not because I'm particularly worried about individuals making the connection - if you look through my comment history on Reddit, it is fairly trivial to figure out who I am. The other direction is slightly trickier, but probably not much. But I don't want someone just casually typing my name into Google to get page up and page down with comments I have made in what amounts to casual conversations. That Google does not appear to understand that compartmentalisation is part and parcel part of social interaction, and that people put an enormous amount of effort into adjusting their identity for different situations, or if they do understand choose to willingly and knowingly ignore it, says heaps about the company. I don't know which alternative is worst, but it's one more reason to tell the Google recruiters to go away next time they call...