6 ms·
Young and Educated in Europe, but Desperate for Jobs
- lukasm 13y agoI like how the title indicates that educated = job. Correlation Does Not Imply Causation
- lsc 13y agoFrom one perspective, the title seems to be juxtaposing "educated" and "jobless" to say that these folks worked hard and got an education, and still are jobless. This angle works on several levels; you know, the 'protestant work ethic' would say these are good people because they worked hard to get through college. From a capitalist perspective, well, traditionally you go to college with the expectation that you will be able to get a white-collar job afterwards, and if that is no longer true, well, it's big, important news. From another perspective, the title says you should care about these folks because they are educated, middle-class kids, just like you or your kids. The idea here is that your average upper-middle class person probably doesn't have as much sympathy for the unemployed people in the lower classes. But if you frame the situation as general downward social mobility for the middle classes, it looks a lot more alarming (I mean, to other middle-class people)
- lukasm 13y agoTrue that, but my point is, it's really bad that journalist are trying preserve a false assumption that college is a proxy to a white-collar job. Kids are constantly hearing that they have to do good in school so later on they will be rewarded. That's intuitive, but not true. I managed to change my thinking on 3rd year. I stopped optimizing for high grade if there is no value. It's hard if you hear for 20 years the opposite.
- lsc 13y ago>True that, but my point is, it's really bad that journalist are trying preserve a false assumption that college is a proxy to a white-collar job I thought the journalist was directly pointing out that this assumption was not as true as it once was. They were pointing that out in a very "this is shocking" kind of way... but it /is/ shocking. The vast majority of students go to college thinking that they will be able to get a white-collar job upon graduation. The only way that thinking will change is with more articles like this. The other thing to consider is that there is still an extremely strong correlation between having a degree and having a white-collar job. We can argue on what direction causation runs, but the correlation is inarguable.
- pjmlp 13y agoThere are many jobs that you won't even be considered without a degree. Her example is one of them. In most European countries, nursing is a degree that shares part of the education with medicine.
- lsc 13y agoYeah. Speaking as someone who doesn't have a degree, I'm not sure that I'd get much any of a raise as a SysAdmin/systems person if I got a degree; probably not any more of a raise than I'd get for that much more experience, anyhow. But a degree would help a lot if I decided to change jobs, or even get a professional licence of some sort. For example, getting a real-estate licence, something I've considered in the course of researching my own investments, is possible without a degree, but more difficult. A degree would also help me move into management in another person's company, the traditional upwards path for aging computer operators. A degree would also come in handy if I want to emigrate to a first-world country before I become rich. Again, it's not required, but the process is rather longer and more nasty without a degree. I'm not saying a degree has zero value. It doesn't have infinite value, though, and the cost of a degree is not zero. To bring the conversation back to me, I got out of high school in '97. I immediately got a really good programming/sysadmin job because, well, it was 1997. They were hiring any idiot with a pulse. I was able to turn that opportunity into a solid reputation with solid experience that I was able to use to remain employed through the crash. If I had gone to college, and got out in 2001? I bet I would have been unemployed for another five years after graduating. The job market for people with my skillset was brutal. I think that if you have a good chance to start your career? you should take it, even if that means delaying school. Of course, if you have a chance to go to school for free, and that chance will go away if you don't take it right away? you should take that, too... but I think the former is more common than the latter. Usually, if you can go to school now, you can go to school four years from now, but it's dramatically easier to start your career when there is a lot of demand in your field. Now, I'm mostly speaking of finances. there is a psychological aspect to school, too. There is value to learning how to fit in, but again, that value is not infinite, and the cost is not zero.
- morgante 13y agoI wonder what's the situation like for software developers and engineers? Equally dire, or would learning to program be a way out for them?
- Yuuyake 13y agoThere's plenty of IT jobs (software/system engineering, admin work etc.) but you have to know something. I interviewed people for intern and junior programmer positions (mainly Java devs) and they had no idea what an interface is or why we would use it. Ha! They had no idea about basic CS concepts, how the computer works etc. Yet they wanted to work at a place with one of the highest wages in the area. Well...
- antonius 13y ago" ...or would learning to program be a way out for them." In my opinion, not everyone is able to code. Not because it's some sort of exclusive club but because being a programmer involves thinking differently in order to find some sort of solution.
- morgante 13y ago> In my opinion, not everyone is able to code. Not because it's some sort of exclusive club but because being a programmer involves thinking differently to solve problems. Generally, I agree (having seen people who really can't do it continuously struggle through coding exercises). That being said, I'd be interested in hearing if people even try. Surely some could manage it.
- bronbron 13y agoProgramming's not a panacea for everyone's problems, you know? I mean, I get that you're just coming from a place of decency and trying to help, but suppose tomorrow every unemployed person decides to become a programmer - does that really help? Or does it just make the market for programmers worse? I get that you're trying to help, but there are systemic problems to be resolved here.
- 13y ago
- katelynsills 13y agoThere's the general rule that the more restrictions you have on how employers can hire, how they can pay, and how they can fire, the less likely they are to hire more people and take risks in hiring. This means being less likely to hire the young, the old, those without a spotless record, and even women who may start families. I'm not by any means an expert on labor in Europe, but it seems like the obvious way to increase the number of jobs, especially to those who need them most, is to allow employers more flexibility. Instead of artificially creating stratification (some people having no jobs or very temporary jobs, and some having incredibly cushy ones) we would have many more low paying jobs in the middle.
- e12e 13y agoSo your solution is more of what's described in the second paragraph: "it was a rare flicker of opportunity after a series of temporary positions, applications that went nowhere and employers who increasingly demanded that young people work long, unpaid stretches just to be considered for something permanent." ?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gametheoretic 13y agoYou don't do your camp any favors with this category of response.
- danieldk 13y agoWhy not? It is one of the consequences of removing labor rights. It's a difficult balance: too many labor rights will stifle the economy, too few will stifle the worker. I am happy that in most European countries workers are entitled to a 40 or 48 hour work week, plenty of holidays, and paid overtime. Because life is not only work... One area where more flexibility is required in Southern European, and even Western European, countries is making it easier to hire and fire an employee.
- 13y ago
- redwood 13y agoSad stuff. Somehow I have hope that things will work out: that it won't all be a waste, that people's minds won't just atrophy. That this will be a opportunity to think different, get creative and scrappy, and focus on non-financial pursuits. But who knows. Maybe this really is a societal-level rot that will linger into older age... I sure hope not.
- jpelker 13y agoIf these kids (and their parents) begin to not be able to afford to eat or house themselves, they'll likely riot and steal/destroy their countries. At that point, what will they have to lose?
- magnusss 13y agoWhy aren't the apparent plethora of young, educated, and motivated workers starting more companies, rather than hoping in vain for existing companies to hire them? Or, asking the question another way, is there something about the legal or financial structure of Southern Europe that makes it harder or riskier to found a business than elsewhere?
- dingaling 13y ago1. Lack of market: retail spending is still occasionally dropping month-on- month. 2. Lack of liquidity: what bank, already in perilous condition, is going to lend to these young people? 3. Lack of savings to compensate for ( 2 ) Spanish financial indicators: http://www.tradingeconomics.com/spain/consumer-spending http://www.tradingeconomics.com/spain/consumer-spending
- gametheoretic 13y agoReports on gender issues were going to be a tough sell regardless.
- carterschonwald 13y agoyou have to jump through a lot more hoops to create an incorporated business entity in europe. Much much easier in the US.
- jpelker 13y agoThey also don't know how. I don't remember learning how to run a simple little business for myself in school and I studied International Business.
- pjmlp 13y agoIt is an institutional and social problem. Institutional, because there are endless bureaucracy and taxes you have to fight until the company if finally up and running. Social, because in many European countries you are only allowed to fail once. Where in US, failure is seen as a mean to learn from the mistakes for the next company, here it is seen as a failure to be an Entrepreneur at all.
- ajuc 13y agoIt's basically the same in USA (places with jobs and without), but it's the same country, and internal migration is not considered a big deal. And university is espansive, so people that doesn't expect to gain enough by graduating don't go there. In manu EU countries university education is free.
- Yuuyake 13y agoI don't want to sound like a douche, but... I call bullshit! "[...] master’s degree in sociology" - I really wanted to stop reading after this line. There's a handful of jobs that require only sociological skill and in most cases they don't pay that much. Anyone who doesn't know that should blame only themselves, not the system or the employers. Go google "what can a sociology major do". Even Berkley's (which I find to be a decent school at least) sociology dept's website clearly states that sociology is only an addition to some other skills. Not sure about other countries but in my homeland sociology studies are piss easy and that's why they are so popular. People just want to have it all with zero effort. To the really small % of people who study it because they truly love it: 1) you either have to be the best at it in that case 2) if you're not, then get a different job. Not everyone can make a living doing what they love the most. I love gaming but I doubt I could ever get to the point where I'd be able to make a living from it. No jobs for people with a nursing degree, what?? All over Europe there's a shortage of nurses! I'd love to read the whole story of that person. What she tried, what she did, where did she apply etc. It's a hard job, that's why there are shortages, but if you decided to go into a nursing school I'd guess you know that. No one will hire you only because you have a degree, geez don't people know that? Nowadays everyone can get a degree! Btw. why didn't they mention in the article any university names? Anyway even if you, somehow, graduate from a distinguished uni but did nothing extra, or did not find what you really want to to then again you should only blame yourself. As a European who did an exchange in France I met many Italians and Spanish during my life. They were usually quite hard working, focused and new what they want from life. And according to them they were the exceptions. Apparently the majority people from those countries recently prefer to party than work hard. Young people seriously should stop acting like princesses and princes, taking things for granted just because they are special and instead try to do something by themselves.
- apsec112 13y ago"Anyone who doesn't know that should blame only themselves, not the system or the employers." Since these kids were literally wearing diapers, every single authority in their lives has told them: Go to college. Go to college and you will get a good job. Go to college and you will have made it. Go to college and you won't flip burgers. Go to college and you are a success. "In the 21st century, one of the best anti-poverty programs is a world-class education." - Barack Obama, State of the Union 2010 "Does The College Major Matter? Not Really" - New York Times editorial (http://thechoice.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/29/does-the-college-major-matter-not-really/ http://thechoice.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/29/does-the-colle...) "Your College Major Is a Minor Issue, Employers Say" - Wall Street Journal Careers (http://blogs.wsj.com/atwork/2013/04/10/your-college-major-is-a-minor-issue-employers-say/ http://blogs.wsj.com/atwork/2013/04/10/your-college-major-is...) (etc, etc, etc, you can go on forever) It is the height of audacity to lie to a child, literally every day, for literally twenty years, and then blame them for not being cynical enough to realize it.