2 ms·
I think this simply amounts to "damn, this thing by Google is copyright infringement if we altered the law to allow it that means we allow a lot of stuff that W
by pbhjpbhj 13y ago
I think this simply amounts to "damn, this thing by Google is copyright infringement if we altered the law to allow it that means we allow a lot of stuff that Warner and Sony don't want us to do ... so we're just going to pretend this is 'fair use'".
In other words the Judge seems convinced that it's crazy not to allow it. But that says nothing about what statute actually allows.
My view is that Google have gone way over the mark - the correct response is to change copyright law; and indeed to shorten terms vastly whilst they're at it. But politically parties in the US are presumably getting a lot of money from media companies and so democratisation of copyright with a return to the idea of it being about benefiting the public domain simply isn't going to happen.
- magicalist 13y agoFair use and the factors for determining if something constitutes fair use are part of case law going back centuries, and copyright for the public good has been held up for just as long (in spite of setbacks like the extension of copyright length and the anti-circumvention sections of the DMCA). To your specific suggestion for the future, fortunately Congress codified fair use back in the 1970s, so the "four factors" enshrining fair use are absolutely found in copyright law: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoYes, but the judge isn't just using a shoe-horn to fit Google's actions in to fair use he's using a car compactor.
- Kliment 13y agoThat just means that everyone in the US just got a free car compactor for their own free use arguments. You should be rejoicing.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoI don't think most of us are capable of committing tortuous infringement at a level to make it comparable with Google. Nor are we capable of extracting the value in that to make it financially profitable to do. Personally I'd rather the law be altered explicitly rather than allowing ad-hoc alterations to accommodate massive corporations.