3 ms·
The effects of welfare and various forms of economic stimuli? The effects of international trade, currency and central bank policies? And of course, large inv
by Mikeb85 13y ago
The effects of welfare and various forms of economic stimuli? The effects of international trade, currency and central bank policies?
And of course, large investment banks derive alot of benefit from the study of economics. Was just listening to Abby Joseph Cohen on Bloomberg radio yesterday - she's an economist and a senior investment strategist at Goldman Sachs - they obviously make alot of money through understanding economics and making correct predictions. While you can argue about the benefit to society, it's clear that economics can produce prediction models that work.
- dalai 13y agoDo they actually have prediction models that work? Goldman Sachs is not an outside observer. Every time they make a public prediction they are also affecting the outcome. The same goes for several well-known economists. Even if the prediction is not public, Goldman Sachs is quite capable of influencing a lot of people to get the outcome it wants.
- Mikeb85 13y ago> Do they actually have prediction models that work? The proof is in the proverbial pudding - they trade on their prediction models, and make money.
- mrow84 13y agoYour claimed proof ignores dalai's point: that Goldman Sachs' predictions affect the system they are making 'predictions' about. If I predict you are going to get a nosebleed, and then punch you in the face, it's a bit disingenuous for me to claim that I have gained insight into the general causes of nosebleeds, isn't it?
- Mikeb85 13y agoWhile Goldman Sachs is big, they're not big enough to move the markets on their own. No single firm is. The idea that firms move entire markets is pure fantasy. Depending on liquidity they might move a single security one way or another (some stocks trade such little volume that YOU can move their price on your own), but not entire sectors, never mind the entire economy.
- atmosx 13y agoFirst thing: Goldman Sachs makes a lot of money because they are making the rules, not because they are good at anything. Secondly: The economist Stimuli to which you are referring, and the effects of international trade can be read up-down-sideways depending on which part of the Earth you live. They are not universally good as a huge part of the USA-EU middle class believes. If the USA were not imposing rules that give an extremely unfair advantage to USA (oil for example) corps, they may not be so omnipotent. That said, Goldman Sachs is really the worst example I can think of. Even in Lehman's case, the USA gov let Lehman fail but GS was too big to fail. Paulson (ex-GS) called Blackfain (Goldman Sachs CEO) in order to examine Lehman's book because he knew better. Of course Blackfain and Paulson (who had huge amounts of stock of at GS) decided to let Lehman fail and create a huge gap at the market, while saving AIG who owed money to GS and GS of course. Indirectly, they ensured huge profits for GS by killing the competition and that... Now, what economics have to do with GS and the financial sector is beyond me. I don't see any theories applied there... It's all monopoly, a win-win situation: You buy high-ROI financial products and if things get out of hand, don't worry: You're too big to fail ;-) that's one hell of an economic theory. Too bad you can't apply it elsewhere... (oh yes, there are no laws that can be bend in chemistry or physics...)
- Mikeb85 13y agoYour knowledge of GS' history and the banking/investment sector in general is terrible. > the USA gov let Lehman fail but GS was too big to fail GS made a killing by short selling mortgage-backed securities right before the housing crisis. They made 11 billion in 2007, 2 billion in 2008, and 13 billion in 2009. > Paulson (ex-GS) called Blackfain (Goldman Sachs CEO)... decided to let Lehman fail.... First, it's Blankfein. Second, GS did short Lehman shares because they knew the business was in trouble... > Now, what economics have to do with GS and the financial sector is beyond me. Economics is the science that people in the finance sector use to create predictive models about the worldwide economy, so that they can predict company earnings, eventually leading to predictions concerning securities pricing, leading to trading strategies. Investment banks employ more economists than any other sector. That's why it matters. Your conspiracy theories are interesting, but nonsensical. Anyhow, I used Goldman Sachs as an example because I listened to one of their economists talk on the radio last night. Just happened to be on my mind.