4 ms·
> If your committed to reducing an organisation by X%, then a certain number of people are going to be fired. And it makes sense they are the lowest performing
by e12e 13y ago
> If your committed to reducing an organisation by X%, then a certain number of people are going to be fired. And it makes sense they are the lowest performing percentile.
It may make sense to reduce the number of employees. If you chose to do so, it'd be great if you could keep your (relatively) "best" and fire your "worst". The problem is that it's really, really hard to measure how good your employees are. It's even hard to define what a "good" employee is. Especially, perhaps, in a large company.
Take YUI, for instance. How much does someone working in localization of YUI contribute to quarterly revenue? Is he or she more valuable than the person responsible for selling ads? How about the community manager for the Traffic Webserver? How much revenue does he or she contribute? Are the these roles even comparable?
I wonder how things would look if they went by seniority, and simply fired the last 10% to join (maybe with the exception of certain "specialists", like the CEO... ).
- smegel 13y ago> The problem is that it's really, really hard to measure how good your employees are. It's even hard to define what a "good" employee is. Especially, perhaps, in a large company. At a company level that is absolutely correct. I think it supports the notion of firing by team - if anyone can measure the worth of an employee, it is their direct line manager, who is responsible for giving them work and judging the timeliness and quality of the outcome. However, as this "measure" is essentially incomparable between teams, it can't be effectively extrapolated to form a company wide view of the "bottom 10%". Asking each manager to get rid of their least effective employee both spreads the cuts evenly across skill sets, while ensuring that the measure of employee worth is being made by the most qualified person to do so. > I wonder how things would look if they went by seniority, and simply fired the last 10% to join Well, like firing by team, it is just another arbitrary measure. But I think I would rather an arbitrary measure that at least tries to take into account employee worth rather than when they joined.
- allochthon 13y agowhile ensuring that the measure of employee worth is being made by the most qualified person to do so. This implicitly assumes that the line manager is competent and not spread too thin.
- sokoloff 13y ago> I wonder how things would look if they went by seniority, and simply fired the last 10% to join It would look like a company that would have a terrible time hiring anyone decent, perhaps ever again. Who would want to volunteer to be the most likely to be let go, especially given that you'd stay at risk round after round (if the hiring after you was able to absorb 100% of the next layoff, you'd still end up the lowest tenured employee). Ossified has-beens isn't a comfortable or profitable staffing model.