11 ms·
“Remove occurrences of the short name of the Debian derivative from Canonical”
- adrianmalacoda 13y agoI take it the Debian derivative from Canonical that cannot be named is sort of like a Prominent North American Enterprise Linux Vendor[0] for the average user? I'm curious if there's some sort of backstory to this. [0] http://www.pnaelv.net/ http://www.pnaelv.net/
- cconover 13y agoHere's the backstory: http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/11/canonical-abused-trademark-law-to-target-a-site-critical-of-ubuntu-privacy/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/11/canoni...
- piqufoh 13y agoTo quote U$@u > Ubuntu is an ancient African word meaning 'humanity to others'. Issuing take down notices? Stay classy Mark Shuttleworth
- adrianmalacoda 13y agoThanks. I'm not a fan of the whole Unity Amazon integration deal myself, but I think there's a clear difference between a site critical of Ubuntu using their name in the domain and their logo in the header image versus a passing remark in documentation or code. Mind you, I think the original case was a clear attempt at abuse of trademark law against legitimate criticism. I do feel, however, that the distro-that-can't-be-named remark sounds petty. If they want to avoid mentioning Ubuntu they could just say something like "Debian derivatives."
- marcosdumay 13y agoFirst, it's not Debian derivatives. It's a specific derivative that, unfortunately, can not be named. Then, It is a bit paranoid, but Debian people work very har to clear their distro from any IP risk, and writting down the name of that distro that can not be named is now a risk.
- marcosdumay 13y ago> there's a clear difference between a site critical of Ubuntu using their name in the domain and their logo in the header image versus a passing remark in documentation or code. IANAL, but as far as I understand US law (it's crazy, but everybody needs to learn it nowadays), the first use is explicitly permitted, while a passing citation in documentation is a more nebulous issue.
- Flimm 13y agoI'm very surprised by your statement. It would seem to me to be the opposite way round. Surely a passing a citation is fine, it's using someone's trademark in your branding (and a domain name and logo is arguably branding) that's the nebulous issue? Could you point out to me where I could learn about US law that would teach me this counter-intuitive reasoning?
- josteink 13y agoToday I learned about http://www.fixubuntu.com http://www.fixubuntu.com. Thanks Mark!
- puller 13y agoNo context. Seems petty? The issue was about the logo
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Karunamon 13y agoPetty as all heck on the part of Canonical, I agree.
- Flimm 13y agoIt doesn't matter, trademark law requires you to pro-actively prosecute violators if you want to keep your trademark. Although I still wish Canonical was more transparent about who gets to use its trademarks and who doesn't: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu-community/+bug/394328 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu-community/+bug/394328 sp332: You're right, although it's not clear to me that this definitely is not a violation. I hope it isn't for the sake of free speech.
- sp332 13y agoIt doesn't require you to threaten people who don't violate your trademark, but they did anyway.
- NateDad 13y agoShow me where in their message there were any threats.
- tedunangst 13y agoHow fun. It doesn't require you to send requests to people who don't violate your trademark, but they did anyway.
- sp332 13y ago
- lowlevel 13y agoSpeaking it's name only makes it more powerful.
- aroman 13y agoFear of the name increases fear of the thing itself.
- alexvr 13y agoI propose that we refer to Ubuntu as Voldemort from now on.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- aspensmonster 13y agoBut I thought fear of a name only increases fear of the thing itself? edit: dammit. Beaten to it.
- pfortuny 13y agoMay it be said that humanitytoothers is also unpronounceable? Can I use it in my homepage? The domain humanitytoothers.com is available! What does that mean?
- bronson 13y agoSuggest you buy humanity-toothers.com too.
- tedivm 13y agoSo Canonical started abusing trademark law to silence critics, by claiming they could only use the name Ubuntu with permission and in specific contexts. Debian, being the distro of freedom, is preemptively removing the trademarked name in order to make it impossible for Canonical to do the same to them. While it is extremely unlikely that Canonical ever would, the point stands that they've done this at least once to others. By taking this action Debian is protecting their users from what they perceive as an IP threat. While it may seem a little silly, I am very glad they're doing this if only because it's drawing attention to how far Canonical has gone with some of their whacky and controlling decisions. Context, for those who want it- http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/11/canonical-abused-trademark-law-to-target-a-site-critical-of-ubuntu-privacy/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/11/canoni...
- a3n 13y agoI guess it's getting time to move upstream. Which is fine, I've never given a dime to Canonical, they can do what they want. But it's too bad, they were one of the best things to happen to Linux.
- joeyh 13y agoJust to be clear, Debian didn't do this, I did. And only, so far in one package, which can be used to mirror Debian or various of its derivatives.
- comice 13y agoI'm no Canonical apologist, but they do have a "intellectual property" document and are quite clear about what they deem acceptable and what they don't. They very specifically say you need permission in domains: "You will require Canonical’s permission to use ... any Trademark in a domain name or URL or for merchandising purposes." http://www.canonical.com/intellectual-property-policy http://www.canonical.com/intellectual-property-policy
- hyperion2010 13y agoExcept that policies like that are completely meaningless in the face of the law. They are like the rules you used to make up as a kid.
- Flimm 13y agoYou have to enforce your trademark to keep it. It's one of the crucial differences between it and copyright or patents. mikeash: good point.
- mikeash 13y agoYes, but enforcement is only required to keep it when people are actually violating it. I'm no lawyer, but it looks to me that the "Fix Ubuntu" web site falls clearly under nominative fair use of the trademark, which is when you use a trademark to actually refer to the original product.
- glimmung 13y agoJust so - but /pretending/ to have such a right of veto speaks volumes about their approach. It respects neither the letter not the spirit of the law, and it makes Canonical look thuggish and crass. If they want to protect their brand, they could pay a little more attention to the reputational risks of their own behaviour.
- comice 13y agoMeaningless in the face of the law doesn't mean it's meaningless. It describes under what circumstances they'll send threatening letters and otherwise stamp their feet. Some people are intimidated by that kind of thing. And it can certainly cost you some real time and money dealing with it, and they have more than you.
- stolio 13y agoCanonical has been kind enough to not include the name "Debian" on their Debian derivative's front[0] or about[1] pages. It finally shows up in the about - about [short name of the Debian derivative from Canonical] page. [2] Compare this to Crunchbang - another Debian derivative that many Ubuntu users have fled to - their homepage includes the word Debian 6 times.[3] On their about page a link to Debian using the proper "Debian GNU/Linux" name is their first order of business.[4] I'm a Debian user and I must say much respect to Crunchbang for making the effort. [0] - http://www.ubuntu.com/ http://www.ubuntu.com/ [1] - http://www.ubuntu.com/about/ http://www.ubuntu.com/about/ [2] - http://www.ubuntu.com/about/about-ubuntu http://www.ubuntu.com/about/about-ubuntu [3] - http://www.crunchbang.com http://www.crunchbang.com [4] - http://crunchbang.org/about/ http://crunchbang.org/about/
- Flimm 13y agoThey do include Debian in their about page: http://www.ubuntu.com/about/about-ubuntu http://www.ubuntu.com/about/about-ubuntu Futhermore, you missed the "Ubuntu and Debian" page, which is only a two links away from the home page: http://www.ubuntu.com/about/about-ubuntu/ubuntu-and-debian http://www.ubuntu.com/about/about-ubuntu/ubuntu-and-debian
- stolio 13y agoubuntu.com/about/about-ubuntu is literally link number two above, I realize it's a bit obfuscated The point I was making is how deeply the connection to Debian is buried on the ubuntu.com site and contrasting it to Crunchbang's approach which is to give back mindshare As for your two links point, the fastest path I can find is 3: / --> /about --> /about/about-ubuntu --> about/about-ubuntu/ubuntu-and-debian 3 clicks, each link with it's own level of prominence. It's safe to say the Debian connection isn't featured for the average user. And I would imagine well over half the website is available within 3 three clicks of the homepage, I have half a mind to crawl it to find out... EDIT: I looked again and I can't find the word "Debian" at http://www.ubuntu.com/about/ http://www.ubuntu.com/about/, so either my search feature is broken or it's not there
- 13y ago
- mseepgood 13y ago"The-Distro-That-Must-Not-Be-Named"
- ryanthejuggler 13y agoVoldemort Linux?
- Flimm 13y agoThis is definitely a horrible move from Canonical, but I imagine they are simply following their legal counsel. In general terms, you have to prosecute violators of your trademark if you want to keep your trademark (unlike copyright or patents). In this case, they're probably making things worse for themselves overall, but I wish people would take the complexities of trademark law in account before accusing them of censorship. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trademark#Maintaining_rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trademark#Maintaining_rights
- hdevalence 13y agoTrademark law does not require you to harass people using your trademark to refer to your product. I wish people would not try to justify corporate bullying based on a misunderstanding of trademark law. Also: it's legal counsel, not legal council.
- Flimm 13y agoIANAL, but a domain name is more than just a reference to a product. ICANN gives trademark holders additional privileges when it comes to domain names.
- hdevalence 13y agohttp://www.icann.org/en/resources/compliance/complaints/ip/ http://www.icann.org/en/resources/compliance/complaints/ip/ > Complaints regarding trademark infringement due to website content and domain names are outside of ICANN's scope and authority. The only case where ICANN Has anything to say is in a case of domain squatting, which this isn't: although Canonical has a trademark interest in "Ubuntu", there's no violation since it's being used nominatively,and it's not being used in bad faith. (Search for UDRP for more information on this policy).
- Flimm 13y agoIn that case Canonical have really shot themselves in the foot :)
- natch 13y agoCurious, if anyone knows: how exactly are the square brackets in this line helping do anything that wouldn't be accomplished without them? /^[U][b][u][n][t][u]$/
- natch 13y agoFigured out the answer to my own question: it must be a silly/clever way to avoid having the literal string "Ubuntu" in the source.
- keithpeter 13y agoI suspect this may be an example of Mr Hess's sense of humour. Which I appreciate by the way.
- zx2c4 13y agoFrom the commit: + } elsif ($origin=~/^[U][b][u][n][t][u]$/ or $origin eq "Canonical") { That made me laugh.
- joeyh 13y agoclearly should have been just elsif ($origin=~ /^[UC][ba][nu][no][tn][ui]c?a?l?$/)
- ryanthejuggler 13y agoAhh, good ol' Canntica, my favorite OS.
- frankohn 13y agoThat's just wrong, they don't want to match "Cauntica" or something like that... :-)
- alextingle 13y agoWell, it made me giggle.
- mhubig 13y agoDamn! Canonical just made another good point why 'the Debian derivative from Canonical' should not be used any more ...