5 ms·
How can a company so shamelessly extract money (through forceful deals, no doubt) from an open source OS, and get away with it? Linux companies dodged this bul
by mtgx 13y ago
How can a company so shamelessly extract money (through forceful deals, no doubt) from an open source OS, and get away with it?
Linux companies dodged this bullet for the most part, from both Microsoft and SCU, but it seems Microsoft "succeeded" this time against Android with their mostly garbage patents in the same way patent trolls and mass-bittorrent lawsuits have succeeded so far - by scaring people/companies into paying up, without having to get into any lawsuit, which is exactly what patent trolls have been doing for a while.
As soon as B&N was about to invalidate some of their main patents, they quickly "invested" $300 million into B&N (i.e. they settled), and B&N dropped the lawsuit. I wish more OEM's would've had the balls to call their bluff.
So EFF - any proposals for stopping corporate patent trolls like Microsoft, Rockstar Consortium and Intellectual Ventures, yet?
- zmmmmm 13y ago> Linux companies dodged this bullet for the most part, from both Microsoft and SCU It's worth noting that many of the patents asserted in the B&N case had nothing to do with mobile and were equally applicable to any form of Linux. The only reason MS did not assert them to quell Linux adoption is a) they did not need to and b) it would have been seen as anti-competitive. As such we've been kind of lulled into a false sense of security about the huge stockpile of stupid patents these early operating systems companies have built up. It's more or less like nuclear waste - lying around waiting for someone to build dirty bombs with it. And of course, since there is a clock ticking on the expiry of the patents, MS and others will start becoming increasingly keen to deploy them if only to extract value before the expiry.
- Goronmon 13y agoHow can a company so shamelessly extract money (through forceful deals, no doubt) from an open source OS, and get away with it? It's as simple as 'software patents'. This is the result of the current system.
- ChrisAntaki 13y agoMy guess is that the device manufacturers see some legitimacy to Microsoft's claims, or at least fear a judge would. Perhaps if all the manufacturers banded together, well mainly Samsung, they could fight it. But if that would have been profitable, I'd assume it would have happened by now.
- marcosdumay 13y agoMore realistic, device manufacturers understand that seeing a judge long enough to know his opinion (whatever it is) is more expensive than paying the protection racket.
- brianpgordon 13y agoSCU? You mean SCO?
- gibwell 13y agoOnly parts of Android are open source, and in any case it's a fundamentally commercial project conducted by giant corporations. What about it being partly open source has any bearing on the patent issue? (I'm not defending Microsoft here - just saying that Android being partly open doesn't seem to be relevant to the battle between Microsoft and Google)
- anuraj 13y agoAndroid is not fully open source nor are critical components of mobile firmware including base band and graphics code.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]