7 ms·
Helmets do not do as much as you think. They are not really very good for the types of accidents that bicycles have. For example, see: http://www.bicycling.com/
by brianwawok 13y ago
Helmets do not do as much as you think. They are not really very good for the types of accidents that bicycles have. For example, see: http://www.bicycling.com/senseless/index.html http://www.bicycling.com/senseless/index.html
- gambiting 13y agoI don't know, I have personally fallen off a bike travelling at around 25km/h and hit the side of my head on the pavement. If I wasn't wearing my helmet(and that was a regular, $40 helmet) I don't know if I would be still here - the helmet cracked,but my head was still completely intact,so I guess they have to work to some extent.
- disputin 13y agoAgreed. Some bike crashes have no impact to set off an airbag - other than the impact of the head.
- cocoflunchy 13y agoBike helmets are actually designed to crack under an impact; they protect you by absorbing a big part of the energy of the impact.
- awjr 13y agoIt's slightly more complex than that. If the helmet cracked then the force of the collision was transferred to your skull. Admittedly cracking the helmet would have taken some force out of the collision, but the moment it cracked it became useless.
- vacri 13y agoThis is why you throw away a 'used' helmet. It is the process of cracking - or even merely deforming - that is the protective act. That it's useless after cracking doesn't mean it hasn't done it's job. It's like saying the crumple zone of a car is useless because it crumpled in the accident.
- dasil003 13y ago> If the helmet cracked then the force of the collision was transferred to your skull. This does not make any sense at all. Your skull absorbs some force in all cases. The exact mechanics of what happens are definitely complex, but compressed and cracked polystyrene is still better than hitting your head directly on concrete, just as hitting your head on asphalt is. That is of course leaving aside the question of how much force was absorbed before it cracked and what was left afterwards, but in all cases it's not a binary assertion.
- apendleton 13y agoArgh, this kind of anecdotal evidence makes me crazy. Helmets aren't skulls. You have no idea whether the forces that caused the helmet to crack would have caused similar injury to your head had you not been wearing the helmet, nor do you have any idea whether the forces the helmet managed to absorb before failing are a significant fraction of the forces your head experienced during the accident. Nothing about your experience is sufficient grounds for the conclusion you draw at the end of your comment (that "they have to work to some extent"), nor can any single accident experience provide such grounds.
- kennywinker 13y agoI personally know people who object to helmets, and refuse to wear them even though we have a helmet law in my city. I'm not entirely in agreement, but there is logic to this line of reasoning: 1. Helmets, and helmet laws give the impression that cycling is a dangerous activity, and discourage people to cycle. 2. the biggest thing you can do to increase the safety of cycling, is create cycling infrastructure and put more cyclists on the road (I believe this is backed up by hard data, but I have no citations). 3. It follows from 1 & 2 that helmet laws make cycling less safe for all of us by decreasing the number of cyclists on the road. There is more to their argument than that, but that's the one I personally find most convincing. I still wear a helmet though, so clearly I'm not entirely convinced.
- joosters 13y agoYour first point is a strange one. Are you saying that cycling is not dangerous enough to warrant wearing a helmet? If so, then the other points are moot, and you could have simplified your argument to just "there's no need to wear a helmet". If on the other hand, you believe that cycling is dangerous enough to wear a helmet, then you're effectively saying that people shouldn't wear them in order to 'lure' other potential cyclists into cycling. That's just ludicrous!
- 001sky 13y agoIts sort of a mixed bag: So if they can help reduce injury, shouldn’t they be mandatory, just like motorbike helmets? Australia tried it in the early 90s and the result was a 15 to 20 per cent drop in the number of hospital admissions for head injuries. That would have been great, but it also reduced the number of cyclists by around 35 per cent. ---- A recent study in the British Medical Journal showed that cycling has a positive health impact around 77 times larger than the potential for serious injury; essentially, there’s a small chance that you’ll come a cropper, but a very large chance that you’ll reduce your likelihood of suffering mental illness, heart disease and obesity. That means the laws were hugely counterproductive [Personally, I wear a helmet, though.]
- singingfish 13y agoI have two pieces of relevant experience. Firstly I hit my head on the side when I was about 16 on a bike with no helmet, in a slow speed accident. I had unpleasent concussion, about 10 minutes of retrograde amnesia and 5 minutes or so of post traumatic amnesia. Some weird vomiting symptom about 3 days into recovery which would have been cause for serious concern if it repeated itself. I think I was off school for a whole week. I passed through high school with my usual marks (top end of the middle), and onto an undistinguished but advanced university education. Another friend was involved in a human versus baseball bat assault (skull fracture I think) around the same time and had big problems for a few years. I also worked in brain injury rehab for 4 years or so in my mid 20s. During that time I would have interacted with hundreds of patients with severe traumatic brain injuries. During that time I saw one paitent with a bike related TBI. Bike at full speed versus cow. I don't remember if he was wearing a helmet but his potential as a person was dramatically reduced, although nothing easy to observe casually. I used to be for compulsory bike helmet laws. These days I think the indirect risks of a reduced number of cyclists on the road (as evidenced by the australian experience) outweigh the direct risks of a small number of TBIs. I wear a helmet when I have longer distances to travel, or need to make use of dangerous main roads (I tend to cycle on wide underutilised sidewalks where possible). For short distances I don't wear a helmet. It's a risk, but a small one.
- nether 13y agoWhen I fell sans helmet, I rolled on the ground but my head never contacted the ground because my shoulder was in the way. I still wear a helmet for long distance or traffic rides.
- vacri 13y agoNot quite what that article is saying. A better characterisation would be "helmets are better than nothing, but don't do much for the most frequent kind of head injury in bike accidents". Helmets do do good things for some of the types of accidents that bicycles have. It's an important distinction to make, because some people will use it as an excuse to peddle the idea that helmets are worse than not wearing one. It's a great article, well-written and researched, but it should be noted that the author concludes by saying he still has his daughter wearing an old-style helmet while he waits for a next-gen one to become available.
- peapicker 13y agoThanks you for posting this link. After having a family member go thru a concussion this year, I see how difficult they are to deal with. I hadn't even thought about this in terms of bicycle helmets. I'm going to replace ours now that I know more about it. Thanks again!
- bguthrie 13y agoThat article does not appear to be making the argument that helmets are worthless, only that they don't protect against concussions. The $40 helmet is one of the great success stories of the past half-century. Like seat belts, air bags, and smoke detectors, bike helmets save countless lives every year. They do a stellar job of preventing catastrophic skull fractures, plus dings and scrapes from low-hanging tree branches and other common nuisances. Likewise, US safety standards haven't been updated to reflect more modern medical research on their seriousness.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoThey do naughty things with their statistics: >"Here's the trouble. Stat #3: As more people buckled on helmets, brain injuries also increased. Between 1997 and 2011 the number of bike-related concussions suffered annually by American riders increased by 67 percent, from 9,327 to 15,546, according to the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System, a yearly sampling of hospital emergency rooms conducted by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC)." >"Of course, concussions are more readily diagnosed now than they were 15 years ago. That likely accounts for some of the increase. It's also possible that some of the 149 fewer riders killed every year survived to get lumped into the brain-injury category. But that still leaves thousands unaccounted for. We're left with this stark statistical fact: The concussion rate among bicycle riders has grown faster than the sport." // So, yes 9327 -> 15546 is a 67% increase and as they rightly say the increased survival rate contributes as does the improved diagnosis. >"that still leaves thousands unaccounted for" // Except they already said that daily commuting had increased over years 1995 to 2009 by 60%. Which seems rather like it would account for a whole heap of those thousands of extra injuries; that there are a lot more cars might account for a lot more injuries occurring too. It's an interesting piece and the MIPS helmets probably are better but overall it just looks like it's there to sell the most expensive bike helmets as being the only possible option, especially the emotional CTA in the final para. [OT the site's policy page appears to have been MIA since some time in 2012, http://web.archive.org/web/20120122171726/http://www.bicycling.com/gear/policy/1,7980,,00.html http://web.archive.org/web/20120122171726/http://www.bicycli...]
- leurl7 13y agoAn other way to present things is that helmets have some effectiveness: source http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_helmet#Meta-analyses http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_helmet#Meta-analyses So at least use a one instead of none. Even if it has some merits on some points, http://www.bicycling.com/senseless/index.html http://www.bicycling.com/senseless/index.html is too much misleading and not that really seriously researched, cf. http://www.bhsi.org/bicyclingmag1305.htm http://www.bhsi.org/bicyclingmag1305.htm A current certified helmet is already very useful, even a simple one.
- michaelmior 13y agoA study I just happened to come across today http://www.universityaffairs.ca/bike-helmets-prevent-injuries.aspx http://www.universityaffairs.ca/bike-helmets-prevent-injurie...
- DanBC 13y agoThat link just takes a lot of words to say a few things: 1) Helmets are built to pass a safety standard (which I've already said) 2) Better helmets need to be built (I said that too) Your summary mischaracterises the article, which clearly says (more than once) that current helmets are good at saving lives.
- robomartin 13y agoWow. What an interesting article. Every time I think about quitting my daily HN addiction I come across something like this. Thanks for the link. Very interesting.