5 ms·
> 1) Property. If you have a monopoly on the property in a given area you can charge whatever you want for rent, and no competition will be around to add compet
by Mikeb85 13y ago
> 1) Property. If you have a monopoly on the property in a given area you can charge whatever you want for rent, and no competition will be around to add competition.
Then people can move elsewhere. People won't tolerate it forever. This can be seen in the real estate market in the city I live in. Several downtown blocks in prime locations have a single owner. She charged outrageous rents, and now half of these (prime) locations are empty, and new businesses have cropped up in the neighborhoods around the downtown core.
> 2) Vertical monopolies. If your company buys out not just the competition, but the entire supply chain, and there is a high cost of entry to being able to enter the market -- say automobiles -- then you can quash competition as it arises.
While this is possible in theory, it hasn't happened in a free market.
> 3) Coal mines. If the only job you can get is in a coal mine, and the operator of said mine owns all the mines in your geographic region, you don't have much of a choice. This is especially true if you are working 12+ hours a day 7 days a week for a pittance, or are a minor child.
I live in a country where people will travel 4000 KM for a job. People will move if they perceive economic conditions to be unfavourable. If enough people do this, the mine owner will be forced to raise wages or face a shortage of labour.
> 4) This is libertarian fantasy and rightfully deserves the scorn and ridicule it has so far received in this thread.
Only Americans would make an accusation of political bias in a discussion such as this, using such terms (libertarian).
Fact is, the study of economics is the same whether you're in a market economy or a controlled economy (and likewise whether you vote right, left, or centre). And most economies are mixed BTW.
- seanmcdirmid 13y ago> Then people can move elsewhere. People won't tolerate it forever. Are you referring to emigration? Ya, that happens for particularly bad governments, who don't have a monopoly on power in the world. Of course, moving can be tough, you might have to slug it out in a boat to reach Australia. > While this is possible in theory, it hasn't happened in a free market. Of course it has. Pre-sherman anti-trust act it happened all the time. > I live in a country where people will travel 4000 KM for a job. People will move if they perceive economic conditions to be unfavourable. If enough people do this, the mine owner will be forced to raise wages or face a shortage of labour. I live in a communist country where people will do the same. They might even move out of country. > Only Americans would make an accusation of political bias in a discussion such as this, using such terms (libertarian). Fact is, the study of economics is the same whether you're in a market economy or a controlled economy (and likewise whether you vote right, left, or centre). And most economies are mixed BTW. Your opinions do not match the universal truths of an economist, of which I know many (of different nationalities). Libercrazians like to pretend that they are supported by economists, most of whom (barring the Austrians) think they are whackos.
- Mikeb85 13y ago> Of course it has. Pre-sherman anti-trust act it happened all the time. Most of the sources for this aren't entirely convincing. A small example: http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/08/hammer-antitrust.asp http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/08/hammer-ant... A monopoly by definition must include a condition that there is no competition, not just that the market is dominated by 1 entity. The frequency that this happens due solely to market forces (ie. no coercion, violence, corruption, etc...) is low to nil. > Your opinions do not match the universal truths of an economist, of which I know many (of different nationalities). Libercrazians like to pretend that they are supported by economists, most of whom (barring the Austrians) think they are whackos. First, I'm hardly a libertarian (at least not of the American variety), nor do I find the pop-economic theories of 'Austrians' convincing. In fact, in all the economics I've studied (not my major, but took quite a few courses) the 'Austrian' school was hardly mentioned. I've seen it mentioned more on HN than I ever had before... BTW, my views would probably fall more in line with neoclassical economics, though I don't work in the field, I do make a living investing in stock markets.
- Touche 13y ago> While this is possible in theory, it hasn't happened in a free market. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Oil http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Oil
- ithkuil 13y agoThere are many places on earth where travelling 4000 KM for a job will transform you into an immigrant with few rights but usually willing to accept unfavourable conditions because of difference in currency value between your home and the place you found work, basically hoping that a decade or so of hard work will help your family's future back home. There are also places on earth where you cannot easily get to another sufficiently richer country, so you don't even have the incentive to spare some money, just to go through the hard life of being an immigrant and then either adapt or come back with nothing. People do choose this options, do struggle for visas etc, but usually to do that you have to be strongly motivated. The system often is kept somewhat balanced by this, but this doesn't means it's favourable to workers/consumers.