5 ms·
> Citation needed. Any real economist. Inevitably, if any industry is profitable, competition will arise. Government regulation (often through corruption) i
by Mikeb85 13y ago
> Citation needed.
Any real economist.
Inevitably, if any industry is profitable, competition will arise. Government regulation (often through corruption) is the only mechanism which ensures a lack of competition. This can be observed in any industry throughout the last 100 years.
You're right that companies can lock up the vast majority of a market by out-competing others, but this generally doesn't last very long (typically a decade or less).
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Inevitably, if any industry is profitable, competition will arise. An industry can be profitable for the existing market participants and still have a high enough cost of entry as to have a negative expected profit over any meaningful timeframe for a prospective new entrant. In practice, this is likely to change due to changing external conditions (e.g., technological progress that lowers the cost of entry or creates previously-impossible substitutes) but there is no theoretical reason why this must be the case.
- Mikeb85 13y ago> but there is no theoretical reason why this must be the case. Yet it has always turned out to be the case anyway... Even in the world of offshore drilling (which probably has a higher cost of entry than any other business you could possibly enter) there are tons of start-ups, joint ventures, etc... Of course, the oil business is also very susceptible to corruption, but wherever land rights are auctioned fairly, you see good competition.
- revscat 13y agoThis is flatly incorrect. 1) Property. If you have a monopoly on the property in a given area you can charge whatever you want for rent, and no competition will be around to add competition. 2) Vertical monopolies. If your company buys out not just the competition, but the entire supply chain, and there is a high cost of entry to being able to enter the market -- say automobiles -- then you can quash competition as it arises. 3) Coal mines. If the only job you can get is in a coal mine, and the operator of said mine owns all the mines in your geographic region, you don't have much of a choice. This is especially true if you are working 12+ hours a day 7 days a week for a pittance, or are a minor child. 4) This is libertarian fantasy and rightfully deserves the scorn and ridicule it has so far received in this thread. There are many, many ways to abuse the market to the detriment of the workers, both with and without regulation.
- Xdes 13y agoIf a monopoly raises the price too high then the consumer will seek a substitute or simply not purchase the good. This is true regardless of the form of the monopoly. 1) If rent is too high then renters will leave. 2) If an automobile is too expensive then consumers will use mass transit or carpool. 3) If there is a coal shortage due to labor conditions then consumers will use natural gas or other alternative sources of energy.
- huxley 13y ago"It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong." -- Richard P. Feynman Your hypothesis doesn't take into account the complexities of people's lives which often overwhelm simple economic models. 1. 26.4% of all US renters spend over 50% their income on rent. The most commonly agreed-upon sustainable percentages are between 25-33%. 2. Sadly, there doesn't appear to be much correlation between the cost of transportation (car purchase, gasoline, car maintenance) and mass transit/car pooling increases. In North America, the idea of status being linked to the automobile is a strong counterincentive to mass transit/car pooling. People would rather be poorer than to be thought as too poor to drive. 3. Switching from one fuel to another is not a simple choice for homeowners, you need to switch your furnace (which may be tied to a long-term contract with the fuel supplier), you need to have a local supplier, and you will inevitably face the fact that as demand in the new fuel increases, so will its price.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoThis is simplistic: there are not always viable alternatives, even in a free market. 1) Rent is too high, where do I go? Do I leave my job to live in the country side without one? 2) Public transportation has to exist to be an alternative to the automobile, and often requires public intervention to be viable. 3) Did someone build the pipelines necessary for gas to reach my house? Does the same company own both coal and gas supplies? How do I keep from freezing to death this winter?
- Xdes 13y ago
- AnIrishDuck 13y ago> Any real economist. Any real economist can cite many monoplies that arise through market forces alone. > Inevitably, if any industry is profitable, competition will arise. This is not true. There are many different definitions of "profit", and there are many cases where an industry that makes a real business profit will not support a competitor that makes an economic profit. The obvious example is markets with very large economies of scale [1]. > Government regulation (often through corruption) is the only mechanism which ensures a lack of competition. This can be observed in any industry throughout the last 100 years. I'm interpreting this to mean "only through government intervention can we ensure a lack of competition". Again, this is not true. Any party that can make a massive capital investment (which already vastly reduces the pool of competition) can enter a space and make any future entrance by a competitor completely unprofitable. To see an example of this, lets go a century back in time to the day of Standard Oil. Standard Oil was notorious for leveraging its massive capital advantage to destroy its competitors. It would enter a new market and lower its prices (leveraging its massive war chest). Once its competitors left business, it would raise prices again to screw over consumers. After many people caught wind of this blatant market manipulation, it turned to deceptive practices and things like tying agreements [2]. What government policy led to the dominant monopoly of Standard Oil? > You're right that companies can lock up the vast majority of a market by out-competing others, but this generally doesn't last very long (typically a decade or less). Standard Oil was supreme for over thirty years. If only we could invent a time machine, to hear the gales of laughter from the businessmen of the day at the notion that Rockefeller became the king of oil by "out-competing" others. He became dominant through backroom deals and anti-competitive practices. Government intervention was what finally ended the Standard Oil monopoly. It was also likely the only thing (barring the death of Rockefeller or some kind of market shift) that ever would. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_scale http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_scale 2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_oil#Monopoly_charges_and_anti-trust_legislation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_oil#Monopoly_charges_a...
- Mikeb85 13y ago> He became dominant through backroom deals and anti-competitive practices. Backroom deals AKA corruption. Corruption and regulation are two sides of the same coin. Had the market been perfectly competitive (ie. state governments not succumbing to corruption) the monopoly likely would not have formed and lasted. Your only example merely proves my point. Try to find a monopoly that has arisen in an open market, free from government 'intervention' (either regulation OR corruption).
- mikeash 13y agoAsk five economists a question, and you'll get six answers. Anyone who pretends that economists agree on anything is not worth taking seriously.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoAny real economist? Then surely they are unified on this position, and there isn't any debate at all because its just so sparkingly obvious (again, this isn't true, there are plenty of theories out there). Free market monopolies are only allowed to last a decade or less BECAUSE of government intervention; otherwise they would last much longer. Your 100 year time line horizon corresponds to about the time when governments began regulating and dismantling monopolies.