4 ms·
This is going to get drastically worse, as capital becomes able to remove most human labor from the production equation using robotics in the next few decades.
by adventured 13y ago
This is going to get drastically worse, as capital becomes able to remove most human labor from the production equation using robotics in the next few decades.
I've yet to see a solution to the seemingly inevitable outcome of traditional human labor dropping to nearly zero value. And or why we'd want to prevent it from happening, given the upside to robotics.
The only way to stop (slow down?) the rise of robotics, is to place arbitrary restrictions on machines to hamper their value proposition. I expect politicians all over the world to begin attempting this before another decade goes by.
Will we see a dramatic increase in the formation of unions as a defensive response? Most likely.
- parasight 13y agoWhat about a tax on machines in combination with an unconditional basic income? Right now the worker is the loser in this game. Why not make him the winner? With technology he is no longer forced to do boring work. Machines can do it much better.
- adventured 13y agoI would expect a tax on machines, absolutely. Many possibilities will be floated: such as taxes, limiting how many hours per day a machine can operate, limiting which hours of the day a machine can operate, projecting human costs onto the machines (cost of health insurance, sick leave, vacation time, etc). Organized labor will pull for machines being restrained to as much of an equal footing with human labor as possible. Whether that will actually happen or not, impossible to guess. I do expect various cities, jurisdictions, countries, etc. will try implementing various schemes though.
- riggins 13y agoWill we see a dramatic increase in the formation of unions as a defensive response? Most likely. I'm struggling to follow how a union could help this situation. What would happen? Workers would go on strike if their firms use robots? Seems like that would just push the owner to accelerate robot orders. My guess is that unions are pretty useless in the face of automation. Does anyone know any precedents? I agree in spirit though. What I think is likely is the rise of populism. I think the battle will have to be waged in the political arena.
- adventured 13y agoNot suggesting it would help, but rather that it's the expected response from labor. Organized labor means far greater political influence. Robots don't vote, yet. That greater political influence will be necessary to restrict robotics / slow down the process of innovation and productivity gains (and labor job destruction).
- zzen 13y agoI think we all know the precedent: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite And yeah, if it gets really bad, violent protest is just a more extreme continuation of unions.
- eru 13y ago> The only way to stop (slow down?) the rise of robotics, is to place arbitrary restrictions on machines to hamper their value proposition. I expect politicians all over the world to begin attempting this before another decade goes by. Depends a bit on how international competition between jurisdictions will play out.
- jpatokal 13y agoThis is not about robotics, it's about cheap labour displacing expensive labour through outsourcing and companies capturing some of the vast difference in cost. Which also means it's temporary, since incomes (and thus costs) rise in the poorer countries, and any excess margin eventually will get competed away. That said, since "temporary" here may well last several generations, there's plenty of societal upheaval ahead.
- ciokan 13y agoIt won't. Inject too much robotics and we will have no money to spend on their products. The wheel must keep spinning. If the human labor is replaced by robotics everywhere we, as humans, will have no earnings and without any income the market will freeze as demand will go down as well. All I can say, we're living interesting times.
- gtremper 13y agoIf robots can replace all human jobs, then why does anyone need to work? Or why does money even make sense them. All people need is food, water, and shelter. If machines can provide all that, lacking a job doesn't matter.
- krapp 13y agoRobots won't replace the human need to exploit finite resources and other people for personal gain. Which is why I think complete replacement of human labor by robots isn't likely to happen, even if it becomes technically possible -- because the entire reason for displacing human labor with automation is to remove the need to pay more people to do more work, entirely a capitalist means to a capitalist end that doesn't make sense if the rich don't keep getting richer, or if there's not an economy to take advantage of all the efficiency in all the automation.
- aianus 13y agoBecause a large part of life is competition for a mate. This tends to manifest itself in American culture as the pursuit of material wealth and social status through employment.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoThat's just kind of silly. We have so much silly thinking in HN. So in this robot magic land people are just living with basic necessities and that's? Sounds like the robot utopia worked out great ... Why does money make sense? Do your magic robots work on perpetual motion? And the robot owners are going to provide all these necessities ? Why ?
- 3pt14159 13y agoGeolibertarianism would solve it pretty effectively, since it would allow the human to opt-out.
- YokoZar 13y agoIf labor costs (ie wages) get exceptionally low, it starts making sense to develop more labor-intensive technology. Consider how the industrial revolution started by replacing expensive weavers with cheap migrant workers using power looms. There could just as easily be some sort of technology or industry that takes off tomorrow because it's more able to use this abundant supply of low-skilled workers we're worrying about.
- GFischer 13y agoSomeone will still have money, and (I guess) a desire to spend it. My own dystopian vision is of a world made almost entirely of services to those few with money - most of us will be/are selling nonessential services (entertainment, leisure, nonessential medical services & care, advertising, etc..). Most of government is probably in the "nonessential" category. Some % of the workforce will still work on R&D and essential services of course. Having all the basics covered by a small percentage of the workforce doesn't mean the rest will have to work less.. on the contrary, the battle to divest people from their money will be fiercer than ever - more and better and more exotic services, more advertising, etc. It would be interesting to live in a post-scarcity society, but we're nowhere near there yet (and I'll be a bit Malthusian and say that we should curb the population growth a bit if we want to have what I consider to be a good standard of living in the future)