8 ms·
Making a loss on Bitcoin
- cstrat 13y agoI guess it was always to be expected that this was going to happen, I don't think people realised just how quickly. Once the whole idea of bitcoin being a money maker was popularised people jumped on board. I am wondering if, and when, we will hit an point where people stop buying mining rigs because the difficulty keeps rising and the payback just isn't there. Even when we hit that point, there are thousands of devices out there fuelling the rise in difficulty.
- trafficlight 13y agoThat time has already passed. Mining rate isn't going to get any better than the ASICs available now. I think the turning point was around August or September. Though if the exchange rate is at least $400 or $500 per bitcoin, that would change for a little while.
- cstrat 13y agoIf the exchange rate does hit $400 or $500 imagine how many more people will jump on board with the idea that only 3 months earlier bitcoins were $50... further driving up the difficulty when those newcomers buy rigs trying to strike it big.
- trafficlight 13y agoMoral of the story? Be the guy selling shovels.
- fsckin 13y agoI got a refund from BFL well outside the 60 day window by using the 'nuclear option': the PayPal executive escalations team. It's been months and they still haven't gotten close to shipping orders around the time I put mine in. I'm kinda sad that I won't be mining glorious coins. I guess it's a bullet narrowly missed.
- Afforess 13y agoI know lots of people complain about Paypal being shitty for orders, but this is why I still prefer to use them. They have great consumer protections.
- bobbygoodlatte 13y agoOP didn't make a loss on Bitcoin. He made a loss on Butterfly Labs. Consumer mining these days is only profitable for narrow windows — you need to take delivery of one of the first miners in a new ASIC generation to have a chance. It's much smarter to invest in Bitcoin directly.
- SeanDav 13y agoIt is only "smart" to invest in Bitcoin with hindsight. Bitcoin is a pure gamble, no one can predict what the price will do and if it will all crash horribly tomorrow. There is very little difference between "investing" in Bitcoin and pulling the lever on a slot machine. In either case you may make a killing or lose everything you put in - so only put in what you don't mind losing.
- kbelbina 13y agoThe difference is a slot machine is mathematically negative expectation. Also Bitcoin is zero sum after commissions. So very different.
- joosters 13y agoBut since you have to pay the commissions and trading costs, there's not much difference after all...
- kbelbina 13y agoYou can't prove that there is no edge in Bitcoin trading. You can prove it with slot machines.
- SeanDav 13y agoBitcoin is most certainly not zero sum. Zero Sum implies that for every winner, there must be a loser. It is quite possible for everyone to lose money on Bitcoin, with no winner. If tomorrow the USA gets together with China and Russia and persuades the entire world to outlaw Bitcoin, with the threat of a heavy punishment for anyone trading in Bitcoin, the value of Bitcoin will crash, probably very close to 0. In this scenario (which is not all that far-fetched) absolutely everyone loses, hence not a zero sum market.
- dustingetz 13y agoif all those ASICs were so profitable, wouldn't the company making them be keeping them for themselves?
- wmf 13y agoProbably, although not necessarily. Managing 1 KW worth of ASICs is easy but 1 MW worth is considerably more expensive.
- cstrat 13y agoAlso, I think it is in their best interests if the community buy into the idea. Rather than if they mine everything and horde it all.
- TylerE 13y agoThat's exactly what they did. Screwed the buyers over good and plenty.
- trentmb 13y agoThey're as profitable as a pan, pick, and shovel are to a gold miner.
- icebraining 13y agoNo, because they needed the pre-orders to build all those ASICs in the first place. You could also say that a startup founder believes in the project, s/he should keep all equity instead of raising capital.
- iak8god 13y agoI ordered one of these (5GH/s "Jalapeno") from BFL in March because it seemed like a really good idea at the time. Received it in October, putzed around with it for a couple of weeks, and sold it on eBay for a small profit last week once I realized that it was not even going to pay for itself. Too bad, I'd like to participate. The one time I bought a few bitcoins, I started by transferring money from a bank account to a site that takes a cut, and then from there to MtGox. The whole thing took way too long and tied my identity to the transactions. It occurs to me that some people might be willing to mine at a small loss in order to get BTC that's never been near their name.
- jerguismi 13y agoI don't understand why people seem to think that mining is a good way to "participate". Mining is pretty much self-correcting problem - people have incentives to mine, for profit. If you want bitcoin to be successful, there are much better ways to promote it than with mining - for example, software products, startups, implementing bitcoin for your business etc.
- iak8god 13y agoI think cryptocurrencies are neat and I'd like to be a part of the bitcoin economy if it's possible to do that without radically changing my life. One way to do that without taking on much risk would be to buy a noisy little machine that will produce about as much as it cost me and maybe a little extra. That's the kind of participation a lot of people are interested in. If other people want to radically change their lives to support bitcoin, then more power to them. If it's hard for a moderately interested casual user to get involved in the economy, then there's probably not much of a future for bitcoin. At the moment it is impossible to start mining for profit. No one is buying new ASICs because they won't pay for themselves. Almost everyone who's mining now is racing to earn back their initial investment.
- s0rce 13y agoI refunded my BFL long outside the 60 day window with a simple e-mail. It was clear they weren't shipping anywhere near on schedule and it wasn't going to be profitable.
- Jach 13y ago> Seven months after purchase Hahaha. Many people waited over a year. > If Butterfly Labs had shipped their devices anything like on schedule, it would have been easier to make a small profit. Only for the people who ordered pre-2013 (as they were supposed to ship Oct. 2012), and back when btc was $10. That would exclude you. As others mention, bitcoin as a currency seems to have a better chance of ROI (or at least quicker ROI), unless you can get in on the shipping and upcoming 28nm ASICs. I feel bad for the people who ordered from BFL using bitcoin back in 2012.
- daemin 13y agoI wonder if BFL kept the bitcoins or changed them over to hard currency then?
- jerguismi 13y agoYou mean soft currency? Bitcoin is the hardest currency to exist, you know... http://stakeventures.com/articles/2012/03/07/the-may-scale-of-money-hardness-and-bitcoin http://stakeventures.com/articles/2012/03/07/the-may-scale-o...
- daemin 13y agoI'm a bit dubious of that scale. Like what can you buy in a shop for gold or silver bullion? I know friends that trade in silver coins, but I don't see them walking into a store to buy things with such coinage.
- yason 13y agoSince the difficulty is periodically changed based on the hashing rate, it makes an interesting case. Everybody would generally be better off to throttle the rate because the difficulty would tone down as well and you could still make the same money with regular, much cheaper hardware. But there would be more people doing that which would spread the gains more evenly. On the other hand, that's not how it will ever work because everyone is locally optimizing for their own profit and buying larger racks -- first big GPUs and now ASIC miners -- which ironically doesn't result in profits proportionally equal to the larger investments. In the end it shouldn't even matter: mining bitcoins is just a way to distribute the 21 million coins to people and the cpu power required to do that hasn't got anything to do with the final value of a single block. Your cost to acquire one bitcoin just varies based on how much competition you have.
- vog 13y ago> mining bitcoins is just a way to distribute the 21 million coins to people No. This is a common misconception. Mining Bitcoins is necessary to keep the network running and secure. Distributing Bitcoins is just a side effect to encourage people putting number-crunching power at the network in the early stage, as this is what makes the network secure in the first place. The additional coins will become tiny and vanish over time. They are continually replaced by transaction fees. Over time, the Bitcoin users will pay the "mining people" directly, via transaction fees, for doing all that hard number crunching with their specialized hardware.
- yason 13y agoI basically know how it works, that was just my interpretation of the scheme and I stick to it. But I think I used the term mining in an unorthodox way. What I meant by mining is getting reward coins from doing the number-crunching required to find good hashes for blocks. I think the current semantics is that mining means doing that hash-finding number-crunching but it's also being used to refer to mining bitcoins which is maybe a bit misleading. Thus, I rephrase my statement: I maintain that bitcoin rewards themselves aren't necessary —— the rewards are just an incentive and indeed a convenient way to distribute bitcoins in a rather stable way. When we hit the 21 million mark and have no new bitcoins left, the number-crunching part would still have to continue. This is no problem because of transaction fees will provide a sufficient incentive for that. And this brings us back to my point that theoretically we could've started with just that. Theoretically, we could've started with distributing 21 million bitcoins to 21 million random people and let the peer-to-peer network start with doing only transaction verification, and incentivize that with transaction fees. (Probably wouldn't have worked in reality but that's only because of the human factor.) That's what I meant.
- DanBC 13y agoThose butterfly labs lumps are small. They're useful to people who want to steal electricity because they can be easily hidden. So, if you can buy them cheap second hand, and are okay with stealing electricity and installing them in hidden locations, then you might make a bit of money.
- MasterScrat 13y agoDoesn't it need to be connected to a computer to work?
- petemc_ 13y agoYou can connect up to 7 to a rpi.
- MasterScrat 13y agoIf electricity price is the main problem, why not go solar?
- shawabawa3 13y agoYou'd probably make more selling the solar electricity then
- DanBC 13y agobecause that adds capital cost. You're paying for the bitcoin mining unit and for the solar panels. For the older GPU bitcoin mining farms you'd need a substantial solar array to cover costs! That's at least one good thing about fpgas and asics - lower running costs.
- ratsimihah 13y agoGot the same Jalapeño about two weeks ago, and I mined about $25 worth of BTC so far. On my way to break even the initial $150 investment, lol.