8 ms·
Webdesign tool Macaw raises $275k on Kickstarter, $200k more than original goal
- mjhea0 13y ago$30 came from me!! ha
- tomasien 13y agoAnother of the "oh it's been tried a million times, it'll never work, it'll never happen" ideas that are out there that might ACTUALLY work. I love those kinds of ideas.
- nej 13y agoCurious if all the output code is arranged in absolute positioning.
- ble 13y agoFrom macaw.co: ABSOLUTE TO STATIC CONVERSION Macaw offers designers the freedom of absolute positioning within the interface but will convert to a static document flow upon export by calculating the necessary margins, padding, floats and clears. It's the best of both worlds.
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoWatch the 20 minute demo, it’s pretty darn amazing. http://vimeo.com/70771444 http://vimeo.com/70771444
- rfnslyr 13y agoIt's so much easier and rewarding to just learn the basic code to structure a webpage. What if I don't really know much web dev, but master this tool? Where will that get me? "So it shows here you've developed 8 websites for clients, wow, what does your stack look like?" "Oh I kinda just mastered this one specific tool, I don't really know how to code." Reminds me of Dreamweaver days.
- darth_aardvark 13y agoI think the idea is that this is for people who have learned the code to structure a webpage, but are sick of fiddling around with CSS/LESS/SASS to get a certain div in exactly the right place.
- nilliams 13y agoAgree, it seems like a complementary tool for people who know how to code. I also would have loved to have this tool a couple of years ago to help explain certain concepts to my boss (an HTML/CSS naysayer), i.e. 'these are the kind of layout things that can be abstracted'.
- adamnemecek 13y agoIs this opinion this generation's version of "Real men only write code in (C|assembly|Fortran)"?
- nilliams 13y agoWell it's not quite so transparent in its naivete, since a lot of people have tried and failed to create decent visual editors for HTML & CSS in the past. This particular editor does seem a significantly better attempt than previous efforts though, namely that it seems to be written with a understanding of the equivalent, idiomatic code.
- rfnslyr 13y agoNot really since you can code just as well in other languages, but with tools like these, we've seen them built and we've seen how bad they were. Just going off experience.
- fatbat 13y agoDepends on your end goal I suppose. Not everyone wants to learn development. Some people just prefer getting things done and this tool certainly has potential to help in that regard.
- MisterBastahrd 13y ago
- neovive 13y agoLooks interesting. My initial impression was that it reminded me of an Adobe Edge app. I wonder if it will be compatible with existing frameworks, such as Bootstrap, Foundation, etc.
- dopamean 13y agoMaybe this isn't relevant but I've often wondered if it could be useful for people looking to raise money on Kickstarter to put a cap on the amount they raise. If you really only need 75k is it always a good thing to end up with way, way more than you asked for?
- CompelTechnic 13y agofor people making physical products a cap would make sense. Printrbot was a pretty good example- order fulfillment took a lot longer than anticipated because of the high volume. On the other hand, delivering a desktop application is about equally difficult for 200 customers or 2000 customers, so the Macaw guys should just revel in their extra cash (aside from the stretch goals that they chose to take on as well, and printing a handful of extra t-shirts).
- dopamean 13y agoThis makes sense. The cases I was thinking of were actually for companies planning on making physical products.
- venomsnake 13y agoNot entirely convinced. Too much money that you are obliged to spend can sink a project just as well as underfunding. Due to some "Mythical man month" reasons adding more people and features can put you in quagmire easily unless you have very good project managers. I am not sure even those could bear the influx of order of magnitude more money than needed. Kickstarters are not preorders.
- wmf 13y agoStretch goals will extend the schedule (something that Kickstarter doesn't really explain), but you don't have to have stretch goals. If people give you more money than you need you can just keep it.
- georgemcbay 13y agoYou don't have to spend the extra money on things that will blow out the schedule. Anyone aware of the realities of software development enough to think about capping the max should be aware of the mythical man month and cognizant enough to realize they can just bank that extra money as a rainy day fund for when the product almost certainly goes over schedule even with the original plan (Hofstadter's law).
- yelnatz 13y agoThe only bad thing about Macaw is that early access is not until January 2014.
- bbx 13y agoMacaw is much closer to Fireworks than Photoshop. I've never used Fireworks but a colleague of mine did. It's so much better suited for web design. But Adobe failed to market it properly (I actually never heard of Fireworks before 2011, several years after I started). That's probably the reason why it's discontinued. Macaw tries to capitalize on this void left by Fireworks, a void that actually may have never been filled by any web design software. I think the keyword is "fluid". Unlike Photoshop, almost nothing in Macaw is engraved in pixels. You can easily modify elements without worrying about half-eaten pixels, resizable boxes or weird rounded borders. Sounds like Fireworks? Yes, but Macaw adds a powerful feature (and probably the most criticized one): code generation. As some others said, it does sound like Dreamweaver. But Macaw's code quality is vastly superior and quite impressive. Being a front-end developer and a graphic designer, I'm right in Macaw's target market. I think I'll try it out but I probably won't use much of the generated code. I'm comfortable enough with CSS to understand how my own written code will behave in the browser. I've developed best practices that would be hard to merge with any software generated code. But Macaw is also a design tool with interesting features. And having missed the Fireworks train, I think I'll try to catch this one. My design process have grown simpler and more focused over the years, and although I'm comfortable with Photoshop, it sometimes feels like an overkill.
- gfodor 13y agoMacaw doesn't strike me as anything like Fireworks, other than the fact it is a tool for people creating assets for the web. Fireworks's killer feature was that it merged both vector and bitmap creation tools. Fireworks was great but it was primarily focused on creating image assets that will be displayed on a web page. (The best tool for this nowadays imho is Sketch.) Macaw is basically taking another stab at the Dreamweaver model. The major hurdle I see for it is that it seems to be a one-way street if you go by the demo. You can generate code from a Macaw project, but you can't just pop open your existing html/css and start working with it. The main asset you are working with is a mcw file. For real-world work on serious projects, people in the trenches are going to manually hack on the CSS. They're also going to be generating HTML on the fly with code and will need templates to plug into their view system. The creators of Macaw seem like they know what they're doing but they need to have a story for how they fit into a real workflow before this makes sense. Their smart code generator looks like it will be great for getting a mockup together, but the killer app will be is if this tool can be used throughout the life of an app to iterate on its design.
- wildgift 13y agoWhen Adobe buys them up, will funders get shares of Adobe stock?
- throwmeaway2525 13y agoHa, was thinking about Adobe already, too. Users will rue the day. But for the founders' benefit: hey Adobe, go look at their Kickstarter. Why don't you just acqui-hire these guys right now?
- Segmentation 13y agoDesigners, what is M∀CAW still missing? (serious answers please)
- myk7 13y agoImporting already created projects and editing that website.
- boucher 13y agoI was wondering if there would be any answers about this. Without that feature, it's a one way tool: all changes must be made here, the compiled product can't be usefully edited. I imagine it would be pretty challenging to parse an existing website into something usable, but it would definitely make the tool a lot more useful (not to say it won't still be useful to lots of people).
- adamnemecek 13y agoIIRC from the video, at Macaw's core is an embedded webkit engine so they might not have to do any parsing at all but instead interface said engine. That being said, I'm not quite sure how difficult it would be to go from having it parsed to making something that can work with the parsed code since it might have a structure that would have to be further parsed to extract the meaning of the code.
- pcurve 13y agoHard to ask anything specific without using it, but are you also targeting UI designers who create complex web-applications? If so, what are some of the features that will make their lives easier? Sorry for the vague question... I think this will be great for general web page layouts, but maybe a video showing complex form designs and layouts would seal the deal for me.
- foxhedgehog 13y agoexport to less / sass / stylus; read in existing projects; support for compilation applications like brunch.io; support for scripting: js, cs, etc.
- throwmeaway2525 13y agoA tangent, but that brings me back to this again: "Kickstarter cannot be used to fund websites or apps focused on e-commerce, business, and social networking." It's a weird rule. This tool has business applications, no? (Also not, but still...) More on topic, I'll bet these guys are going to have a wild and successful ride. I think cross-platform support will be key, too (one of the consistent complaints about Pixelmator, as a semi-related example, is that there isn't a PC version available).
- oglo 13y agoSo .. we're all CS guys here. Does anyone have any idea as to how such a system can work? Just curious as to how they're making it work.
- xmpir 13y agoDidn't Google just offer something very similar? https://www.google.com/webdesigner https://www.google.com/webdesigner
- cobrabyte 13y agoSeems to be primarily aimed at creating ads. Also, it's been shown to create code that's far from being considered semantic HTML.
- PixelCut 13y agoMacaw looks great for generating the CSS and HTML code. For JavaScript Canvas or SVG code, we make a tool called WebCode (http://www.webcodeapp.com http://www.webcodeapp.com). WebCode is a vector drawing app that instantly generates code.
- apierre 13y agoIt looks very nice, it makes me think of Flux. The problem with wysiwyg editors from previous generations (Dreamweaver, Frontpage, etc) is that you could never arrange the layout the way you wanted and ended up being developers worse enemies with the poor code being generated. Now you'll have the power of Photoshop (Positioning, layers, transparency, etc) with a clean code output (grid aware, responsive, css3)
- d0m 13y agoIs it possible to use it on an existing project? Change a couple things and save it back without all the html/css being changed?
- richardkmichael 13y agoIs it open source? It would be really nice to see this come to Linux eventually too (though, the KS FAQ indicates they're not looking at Linux at the moment).
- blueblob 13y agoIt always makes me sad when people don't support linux. Especially when they are starting the design for Mac, it shouldn't be that hard to compile for both.
- oddshocks 13y ago"We have no plans to bring Macaw to Linux at this time. Once the Mac and Windows versions are released we will look into Linux." Eh.
- lstamour 13y agoWas it just me, or did they write Macaw up to now, based on the demo video, in JavaScript, CSS and HTML5 like Adobe is doing with its own tools? http://topcoat.io http://topcoat.io anyone? Not to dismiss the work, as to me this should mean getting it cross-platform that much faster. ;-)
- pbhjpbhj 13y ago>"Please note: Macaw v1 for Mac OS X should be ready to roll in January 2014. We have already started on a PC version, but it may take a couple extra months to polish up." // Bah. Pet hate - Mac OS X runs on PCs. Presumably they mean an MS Windows [8?] version? Wish people would be upfront about this it's silly having to hunt around to find if they're supporting Linux.