4 ms·
"The authors contrasted American-style cutthroat capitalism with Nordic-style cuddly capitalism" America hasn't had cut-throat Capitalism in a century. Few se
by adventured 13y ago
"The authors contrasted American-style cutthroat capitalism with Nordic-style cuddly capitalism"
America hasn't had cut-throat Capitalism in a century.
Few seem to understand the difference between 19th century Capitalism, with actual free markets, and 21st century Socialism. You'd think the entire 19th century never happened, such that authors have no reference source for actual 'cut-throat' Capitalism.
We have soft European Socialism. The government system spends 40% of GDP ($6.7 trillion out of $17 trillion). We don't have a free market in nearly any sector, including the biggest such as: healthcare, education, banking, telecom, energy, utilities. When 80% of your economy lacks any actual free markets, how can one claim Capitalism as the system?
In fact, our government spends so much we're bankrupt a few times over when you count entitlements + public debt, none of which can ever be paid in full. The public debt is of course laughable, we couldn't pay it down in a century of surpluses, even at 2% interest rates. We're currently in the process of actively defaulting on our debt, using QE (aka debt monetization) to devalue said debt.
The Federal Government alone spends so much, it's half the size of the entire Chinese economy.
We have the largest welfare system in world history, by far. We have the largest entitlement system in history, by far. We have the largest government-controlled health system in history, by far.
America has more regulations on its books than any other country, by far. We add thousands upon thousands of regulations annually. We have the most regulated economy in history, there isn't even a close #2.
Our taxes are worse than Canada (supposedly a semi-Socialist nation), and among the highest for industrialized nations when you count local + state + federal. We also have the largest and most convoluted tax system by far, the total IRS tax code is so large no human could ever reasonably read it.
Where's the Capitalism? It doesn't exist.
- chiaro 13y agoIt's not pure capitalism, of course. But America is undeniably more capitalistic than the majority of OECD countries and even goes so far as to consider capitalism an ideal, and capitalistic policies to be more virtuous. And the US is very much a low-tax country, in aggregate. See this graph: http://blogs.crikey.com.au/pollytics/files/2011/12/taxasgdp2.png http://blogs.crikey.com.au/pollytics/files/2011/12/taxasgdp2... From source: http://blogs.crikey.com.au/pollytics/2011/12/08/australian-exceptionalism/ http://blogs.crikey.com.au/pollytics/2011/12/08/australian-e...
- saraid216 13y ago> 19th century Capitalism, with actual free markets To be absolutely clear, when people say that free markets have never been a thing, you're saying that this claim is false and we've had them in America in the 19th century?
- btilly 13y agoWe did have something much closer to them. The popular reaction to what happened under those markets is why we developed anti-trust regulation, and taxes on rich people. (Which peaked in the 1950s with a marginal income tax of 92-93% on earned income over $1 million/year.) Bill Gates is, in many ways, the Andrew Carnegie of our day. Both in good and bad ways.
- rsynnott 13y ago> 21st century Socialism If you think that any major world economy is socialist, you're deluded. > Our taxes are worse than Canada (supposedly a semi-Socialist nation) Wait, what, no, it isn't. Why do you think this? Are you confusing socialism with social democracy, or something?
- frenchy 13y agoOne thing you should understand about Americans is that the word 'socialist' means something a bit different to them.
- aianus 13y agoAs a Canadian working in SF, I can assure you I owe the Canadian government a big fat check when I go back for the difference in taxes.