4 ms·
"He also said the subcontractor, Accenture, was playing a limited role and was well-qualified for the work." And I'm well-qualified for doing brain surgery. L
by edw519 17y ago
"He also said the subcontractor, Accenture, was playing a limited role and was well-qualified for the work."
And I'm well-qualified for doing brain surgery.
Like most enterprise debacles, this is NOT a technology problem. It's a management problem. Or lack thereof.
(Honestly fellow hackers, is there anything easier than payroll? That's what we used to give the new guys.)
- nradov 17y agoYou think payroll is a large enterprise is easy? Not a chance. They are dealing with multiple union contracts, salaried employees with various scales and benefits, students, etc. The legacy application is probably full of undocumented special cases that are necessary to get correct results, and have to be tediously reverse engineered. For another example, see the (in)famous C3 project. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrysler_Comprehensive_Compensation_System http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrysler_Comprehensive_Compensa... That said, I'm sure you're correct that there was some serious management failures on this project.
- mrduncan 17y agoThe legacy application is probably full of undocumented special cases that are necessary to get correct results, and have to be tediously reverse engineered. I think you hit the nail on the head right there. There is always some oddball case where workers X and Y get paid double time when there is a full moon on the third Tuesday of March in a leap year.
- edw519 17y ago"There is always some oddball case where workers X and Y get paid double time when there is a full moon on the third Tuesday of March in a leap year." And that's a tough case to program?
- wallflower 17y agoI've worked in the field of enterprise software; unfortunately, programming can be the least of your tasks. It is not a programming issue. A project manager has a lot of constituents (university employees) to satisfy. Lots of fiefdoms. It's more like a Zoo Keeper - an enterprise especially one like a university can be a complex ecoystem with its own predators - you can be in all-day meetings, dealing with the virtual ecosystem of vested interests, departments, groups who all want a say in how the software works. Pissing off someone inadvertently could cripple your project. As anyone who has tried to get the registrar to do X in Y time and has been referred to Z to get P's signature and so on, universities can operate on their time schedules and march to the beat of their own drummer. And, remember, a fair number of employees at a university who have been working there for 15 years and are used to doing things their old way might be passive-aggressive or hostile to the idea of something making a process more efficient.
- edw519 17y ago"You think payroll is a large enterprise is easy?" Compared to any other enterprise app, absolutely! The easiest, by far. "They are dealing with multiple union contracts, salaried employees with various scales and benefits, students, etc" Oh, you mean you have to do math? It's not like they're launching a rocket. Oh wait, that doesn't cost $30M either. Sorry. "...have to be tediously reverse engineered..." Or "tediously" analyzed and defined. Either way, it's what we do. Digital blocking and tackling. Relatively easy; that is, unless you don't know what you're doing and got the gig because your senior partner threatened the trustees by withholding audit approval. We hackers don't profess to be experts at accounting. Why do accountants insist on being experts at building software?
- seldo 17y agoTo be fair, Accenture don't profess to be experts at accounting either: they're generalist consultants. Interestingly, Accenture (then Anderson, DeLany & Co.) apparently built the first computerized payroll system in the US, back in 1953: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accenture#History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accenture#History
- edw519 17y ago"...apparently built the first computerized payroll system in the US, back in 1953..." ...and it will be ready next Tuesday.
- menloparkbum 17y agoActually, they do profess to be experts at building accounting systems. Accenture was spun out of an accounting firm and as you mention they've been building accounting systems since 1953. Building payroll and other accounting systems is one of the main things they do.
- moe 17y agoSo if they're doing it for 56 years then why don't they already have a modular offering where they can just mix & match the modules as required, akin to SAP? I know the answer(s) ofcourse, but couldn't resist asking...
- seldo 17y agoAs soon as I hear the words "software" and "Accenture" alarm bells start going off in my head. Accenture's model for software development is to get first-year consultants who've had 6 weeks' worth of online training in Java to "architect" the system, then send the implementation to big, cheap teams of pretty talented coders in India. Unfortunately, no matter how talented the coder, building to a specification put together by somebody who doesn't know what they're doing always results in terrible, broken systems. Having worked at companies where they've implemented systems, and seen first-hand the minimal levels of real IT experience they require from the consultants they get to architect software, any mention of Accenture and IT makes me run screaming away.
- edw519 17y agoDon't forget their business model. Pay the first year consultants $50K but bill them out at $125 per hour.
- poshj 17y agoIf it is that easy, why don't you and others just create an open source project for this matter and submit the result to university. I am sure they will glad to have it for free.