3 ms·
I don't think the article makes the claim you think it does. Growth is not the same as growthism.
by dnautics 13y ago
I don't think the article makes the claim you think it does. Growth is not the same as growthism.
- asperous 13y agoWhat do you mean?
- dnautics 13y agoFrom the article: "That is the great mistake growthism makes. But growth is not an end. It is a means. A means to, at best, expanding eudaimonia; the capacity to live meaningfully well. And a means, at least, to expanding human freedom." clearly he doesn't think growth is bad. What i believe he thinks is bad is forcing growth. To try to force it as an end.
- cromwellian 13y agoyou're defending the author for wishy washy terminology. This is no different than someone who writes a screed against socialism, or affirmative action, and then pivots around and says "not all of it is bad" Who is going to determine what growth is good and which is bad. Is growth in food output bad? Growth in HackerNews readership? Growth in tablet or smartphone usage? Growth in the number of people on the internet? You can't just rail against growth and then hand-wave an exit from the argument. Specifics are needed.
- dnautics 13y agoI think you're mistaken. The author is very careful in his use of the term growthism versus growth. He doesn't at any point explicitly define what growthism is, but that's because the whole point of the essay is to introduce the concept to a new audience, so most of the essay is given over to (an admittedly diffuse) description of what, exactly it is. your point that the essay seems ranting, is valid, and definitely a weak point.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cromwellian 13y agoOh, you mean the strawman that "growth must be accomplished at all costs" without even defining what growth is? What human action does not produce costs and benefits? If growth must be accomplished at all costs, why do we have any regulation or social safety net at all? Clearly, there are some costs we are not willing to pay. Yes, some people don't believe in any regulation because it hurts economic growth. But call what we have in the West 'growthism' making straw. You think the Chinese who are suffocating in super-smog storms in Harbin right now aren't in favor of regulation? People on the Right make the same mistake. They take any regulation or social programs and call it "socialism". I think these "isms" are bad for studying the problem. We have a complex, mixed economy and boiling it down to bumper sticker isms isn't going to help understand what our problems are.
- adventured 13y agoChina isn't lacking regulations or controls. The Chinese Government has dictatorship-like control over all aspects of the economy. They can literally do what they want, when they want. They're lacking enforcement, which is a very different problem from not having regulations on the books. Companies bribe their way out of enforcement. That's why their cities are suffocating from air pollution. It's the way business is done in China.
- homunculus 13y agoIt's the way business is done everywhere. My perception is that in the US the 'bribes' aren't paid at the bureaucratic level but at the campaign 'contribution' level. That way the 'regulation' is hobbled before the legislation is passed. And if big business somehow gets hung up in a regulatory/legal issue, a la the banking industry or the oil industry, they pay their fines and it's back to business as usual.
- dnautics 13y agoI've started a small business without bribing anyone. Well, I did have to pay a remittance to the IRS to get nonprofit status. Which, is still being processed.